文献速递儿童口腔

儿童龋病管理:一项牙科诊所随机对照试验

Child Caries Management: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Dental Practice.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent Res · 2019-11-26

该多中心三臂平行组患者随机对照试验在英国初级牙科保健中比较三种乳牙龋管理策略3年临床效果。3至7岁至少一颗乳磨牙牙本质龋的儿童随机接受常规去龋充填加预防、生物管理封闭加预防或仅预防。结果显示三组在疼痛和/或感染发生率及发作次数上无差异证据。

要点

  • 对于高风险且已有龋病的儿童,三种策略在疼痛/感染上无差异证据。
  • 生物管理(封闭龋组织)与常规去龋充填加预防效果相当。
  • 仅预防策略也未显示劣于常规管理。

核心结论

  • 在具有高龋风险且已建立疾病的参与者中,三种治疗方法在牙痛和/或感染的发生率或发作次数上无差异证据。

研究设计与样本

  • 多中心三臂平行组患者随机对照试验,在英国初级牙科保健中进行,比较三种策略3年临床效果。
  • 纳入3至7岁、至少一颗乳磨牙有牙本质龋损的儿童,按1:1:1随机分为C+P、B+P和PA三组。
  • 共1144名参与者随机(C+P n=386;B+P n=381;PA n=377),由72名全科牙医实施;1058人(C+P n=352;B+P n=352;PA n=354)至少参加一次研究访视并纳入主要分析。
  • 中位随访33.8个月(四分位距23.8至36.7)。
  • 父母、儿童和牙医对分配臂非盲。

主要发现

  • 至少一次牙痛和/或感染的参与者比例:C+P 42%;B+P 40%;PA 45%。
  • 与C+P相比,B+P的调整风险差(97.5% CI)为-2%(-10%至6%),PA为4%(-4%至12%),无差异证据。
  • 牙痛和/或感染发作次数均值(SD):C+P 0.62(0.95);B+P 0.58(0.87);PA 0.72(0.98)。
  • 与C+P相比,B+P的调整发生率比(97.5% CI)为0.95(0.75至1.21),PA为1.18(0.94至1.48),不能得出优越性结论。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共同主要结局:随访期间(至少23个月)至少一次牙痛和/或感染的参与者比例,以及牙痛和/或感染发作次数。
  • 常规管理(C+P):完全去除龋坏牙体组织并放置修复体,加预防。
  • 生物管理(B+P):以修复方式封闭龋坏牙体组织,加预防。
  • 仅预防(PA):饮食、菌斑去除、氟化物和窝沟封闭。

临床怎么用

  • 对于高龋风险且已有龋病的乳牙,常规去龋充填、生物管理或仅预防在疼痛/感染结局上无差异证据。
  • 临床可根据具体情况选择生物管理或仅预防策略,而不必常规进行完全去龋充填。

局限性

  • 父母、儿童和牙医对分配臂非盲。
  • 随访中位33.8个月,但最短23个月,部分参与者随访时间较短。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

This multicenter 3-arm, parallel-group, patient-randomized controlled trial compared clinical effectiveness of 3 treatment strategies over 3 y for managing dental caries in primary teeth in UK primary dental care. Participants aged 3 to 7 y with at least 1 primary molar with dentinal carious lesion were randomized across 3 arms (1:1:1 via centrally administered system with variable-length random permuted blocks): C+P, conventional carious lesion management (complete carious tooth tissue removal and restoration placement) with prevention; B+P, biological management (sealing in carious tooth tissue restoratively) with prevention; and PA, prevention alone (diet, plaque removal, fluorides, and fissure sealants). Parents, children, and dentists were not blind to allocated arm. Co-primary outcomes were 1) the proportion of participants with at least 1 episode of dental pain and/or infection and 2) the number of episodes of dental pain and/or infection during follow-up (minimum, 23 mo). In sum, 1,144 participants were randomized (C+P, n = 386; B+P, n = 381; PA, n = 377) by 72 general dental practitioners, of whom 1,058 (C+P, n = 352; B+P, n = 352; PA, n = 354) attended at least 1 study visit and were included in the primary analysis. The median follow-up was 33.8 mo (interquartile range, 23.8 to 36.7). Proportions of participants with at least 1 episode of dental pain and/or infection were as follows: C+P, 42%; B+P, 40%; PA, 45%. There was no evidence of a difference in incidence of dental pain and/or infection when B+P (adjusted risk difference [97.5% CI]: -2% [-10% to 6%]) or PA (4% [-4% to 12%]) was compared with C+P. The mean (SD) number of episodes of dental pain and/or infection were as follows: C+P, 0.62 (0.95); B+P, 0.58 (0.87); and PA, 0.72 (0.98). Superiority could not be concluded for number of episodes between B+P (adjusted incident rate ratio (97.5% CI): 0.95 [0.75 to 1.21]) or PA (1.18 [0.94 to 1.48]) and C+P. In conclusion, there was no evidence of a difference among the 3 treatment approaches for incidence or number of episodes of dental pain and/or infection experienced by these participants with high caries risk and established disease (trial registration: ISRCTN77044005).

来源:J Dent Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Innes NP, Clarkson JE, Douglas GVA, et al. Child Caries Management: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Dental Practice. J Dent Res. 2019. PMID: 31771385. doi:10.1177/0022034519888882

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。