两州儿童窝沟封闭剂接受度测量的可行性与可用性
该研究在德克萨斯州和佛罗里达州检验了牙科质量联盟儿童窝沟封闭剂测量指标在实际使用条件下的信度和效度,两州覆盖全美近20%医疗补助儿童。研究发现各州高风险儿童比例差异大(德州85%,佛州39%),且德州31%纳入分母的儿童因已封闭、缺失或已修复牙齿而不符合条件,9岁时该比例达40%。作者建议取消龋风险评估要求并纳入3年回顾期。
要点
- 各州高风险儿童比例差异大,德州85%而佛州39%,风险计算方法不同影响信度。
- 德州31%分母儿童因已封闭、缺失或修复牙齿而不符合封闭剂条件,9岁时达40%。
- 建议取消龋风险评估要求并纳入3年回顾期以识别已封闭、缺失或修复的磨牙。
核心结论
- 窝沟封闭剂测量指标的信度和效度需提升,测量错分可导致质量改进目标、绩效改进项目或按质付费项目制定不准确。
研究设计与样本
- 使用牙科索赔数据检验牙科质量联盟儿童窝沟封闭剂测量的信度与效度,研究在德克萨斯州和佛罗里达州实际使用条件下进行。
- 信度通过检查测量中龋风险评估组分的可靠性;效度通过3年回顾期识别因已封闭、缺失或修复牙齿而被错误纳入分母的儿童。
主要发现
- 2017年德州高风险儿童比例为85%,佛州为39%,各州识别的高风险儿童存在差异。
- 德州31%纳入分母的儿童因已封闭、缺失或修复牙齿而不符合接受封闭剂条件,该比例随年龄增加,9岁时达40%。
- 佛州观察到类似结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 德州2017年高风险儿童比例为85%,佛州为39%。
- 德州31%分母儿童不符合封闭剂条件,9岁时该比例为40%。
临床怎么用
- 临床及质量改进中需注意窝沟封闭剂测量指标的错分问题,避免因分母纳入不符合条件儿童而影响质量改进目标、绩效改进项目或按质付费项目的准确性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The authors examined the reliability and validity of the Dental Quality Alliance childhood sealant measure under actual use conditions in Texas and Florida. The 2 states provide care for almost 20% of children in Medicaid nationally. METHODS: The authors used dental claims data to examine the reliability of the caries risk assessment component of the measure. They examined validity using a 3-year look-back period to identify children who were inaccurately included in the measure denominator as sealant eligible when they were not owing to already sealed, missing, or restored teeth. RESULTS: The children identified at elevated risk varied between the states, with 85% at elevated risk in Texas and 39% in Florida in 2017. Different methods can be used to calculate risk, raising questions about reliability. In Texas, 31% of children included in the denominator were not eligible to receive sealants owing to already sealed, missing, or restored teeth. The magnitude of the underestimation increased with age, so by the time children were 9 years old, 40% were not measure eligible yet included in the denominator. Similar results were observed for Florida. CONCLUSIONS: The authors propose eliminating the caries risk assessment requirement and incorporating a 3-year look-back period to identify already sealed, missing, or restored molars. PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS: The reliability and validity of the sealant measure needs to be enhanced. Measure misspecification in which children are not correctly identified as needing sealants can contribute to inaccurate development of quality improvement goals, performance improvement projects, or pay-for-quality programs.
引用
- Shenkman E, Tomar S, Manning D, et al. Feasibility and usability of measuring receipt of sealants in 2 states. J Am Dent Assoc. 2019. PMID: 31561760. doi:10.1016/j.adaj.2019.05.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。