低剂量CBCT对种植体周围骨缺损的体外诊断准确性
结果显示三种方法检测准确性均近乎完美,分类准确性高清CBCT优于低剂量CBCT且均优于口内放射线,低剂量CBCT对缺损宽度测量与高清CBCT一致性高,对深度一致性低。
要点
- 低剂量CBCT检测种植体周围骨缺损的准确性近乎完美。
- 分类准确性高清CBCT(敏感度0.96/特异度0.99)优于低剂量CBCT(0.93/0.98),均优于口内放射线(0.71/0.95)。
- 低剂量CBCT与高清CBCT测量缺损宽度的ICC为0.911,深度仅0.342。
核心结论
- 口内放射线可用于检测种植体周围骨缺损,低剂量CBCT能提供缺损几何形态的额外信息。
- 高清CBCT诊断准确性更高,但其辐射剂量是低剂量CBCT的14倍,需权衡使用。
研究设计与样本
- 采用低剂量CBCT、高清CBCT和口内放射线三种成像技术,由四名观察者随机顺序两次评估数据集。
- 通过计算敏感度和特异度评估诊断准确性,采用McNemar检验(显著性水平0.05),并用组内相关系数(ICC)评估缺损尺寸的绝对一致性。
主要发现
- 三种技术检测缺损的诊断准确性和可靠性均近乎完美。
- 分类不同缺损类型的敏感度/特异度:高清CBCT(0.96/0.99)>低剂量CBCT(0.93/0.98)>口内放射线(0.71/0.95)。
- 两种CBCT技术间无显著差异,其性能均优于口内放射线。
- 缺损尺寸绝对一致性:低剂量CBCT与高清CBCT的ICC(95%CI)为深度0.342(0.181-0.625),宽度0.911(0.775-0.963)。
临床怎么用
- 口内放射线可作为种植体周围骨缺损的初步检测工具。
- 需了解缺损几何形态时可选低剂量CBCT,其分类准确性高于口内放射线且辐射剂量远低于高清CBCT。
- 高清CBCT分类准确性最高,但应权衡其14倍于低剂量CBCT的辐射剂量。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the in vitro diagnostic accuracy of low-dose cone-beam computed tomography (LD-CBCT) for the detection, classification, and measurement of peri-implant bone lesions. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Titanium dental implants with all-ceramic single crowns (n = 24) were inserted into bovine bone. At twelve implants, four types of peri-implant bone lesions were created. Radiographic imaging was performed using three techniques: LD-CBCT, high-definition CBCT (HD-CBCT), and intraoral radiography (IR). The datasets were presented twice to four observers in a random order. Diagnostic accuracy was measured by calculating sensitivity and specificity, and analyzed using the McNemar's test at a significance level of 0.05. Absolute agreement between the defect sizes was assessed by means of intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). RESULTS: For all three techniques, diagnostic accuracy and reliability for the detection of defects were almost perfect. The following order was found for classification of the different defect types (sensitivity/specificity): HD-CBCT (0.96/0.99) > LD-CBCT (0.93/0.98) > IR (0.71/0.95). No significant difference was found between the two CBCT techniques. Their performance was superior to that of IR. With regard to absolute agreement of defect size, LD-CBCT agreement with HD-CBCT (ICC, 95% confidence interval) was slight for defect depth (0.342, 0.181-0.625) and substantial for defect width (0.911, 0.775-0.963). CONCLUSION: Intraoral radiography is useful for detecting peri-implant bone lesions. LD-CBCT provides additional information regarding the geometry of defects. The even higher diagnostic accuracy of the HD-CBCT protocol tested needs to be carefully weighed against its radiation dose, which is 14 times higher than that of LD-CBCT.
引用
- Schwindling FS, Hilgenfeld T, Weber D, et al. In vitro diagnostic accuracy of low-dose CBCT for evaluation of peri-implant bone lesions. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2019. PMID: 31505065. doi:10.1111/clr.13533
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。