四种生物陶瓷材料与双固化复合树脂的剪切粘接强度比较
研究比较了White ProRoot MTA、Biodentine、EndoSequence Root Repair Material Fast Set Putty和NeoMTA四种生物陶瓷材料与ClearFil DC Core Plus双固化复合树脂的剪切粘接强度。结果显示Biodentine与White ProRoot MTA粘接强度最高且相近,NeoMTA次之,EndoSequence最低,所有值均低于典型的牙本质-复合树脂粘接强度。结论认为再生手术中选择生物陶瓷材料不应基于其与冠部树脂的粘接强度。
要点
- 四种生物陶瓷与双固化树脂的剪切粘接强度范围为4.47-9.18 MPa。
- Biodentine和White ProRoot MTA粘接强度最高且无统计学差异。
- 所有生物陶瓷-树脂粘接强度均低于典型牙本质-复合树脂粘接。
核心结论
- 再生手术中选择生物陶瓷材料应基于其他因素而非其与冠部树脂的粘接强度。
研究设计与样本
- 材料按厂商说明固化后,表面使用ClearFil SE Bond处理,再用ClearFil DC Core Plus树脂修复。
- 使用万能试验机以0.5 mm/min横梁速度进行剪切粘接强度测试直至断裂。
主要发现
- ClearFil DC Core Plus与White ProRoot MTA的平均剪切粘接强度为7.96 MPa。
- 与Biodentine的平均剪切粘接强度为9.18 MPa。
- 与EndoSequence Root Repair Material Fast Set Putty的平均剪切粘接强度为4.47 MPa。
- 与NeoMTA的平均剪切粘接强度为5.72 MPa。
- White ProRoot MTA和Biodentine粘接强度统计学相似且高于NeoMTA,NeoMTA显著高于EndoSequence Root Repair Material。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有生物陶瓷材料与树脂的粘接强度值均低于典型的牙本质-复合树脂粘接强度。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择生物陶瓷材料时,不应将它与冠部树脂的粘接强度作为主要决策依据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Bioceramic materials have shown biologic and physical properties favorable for regenerative treatment. A key to treatment success is an adequate restoration to prevent microleakage; however, research is limited regarding the bond strength between restorative and bioceramic materials used in regenerative procedures. This study compared the bond strength between 4 bioceramic materials and a dual-cure composite resin. METHODS: Eighty wells in Teflon (ePlastics, San Diego, CA) blocks were filled with bioceramic materials representing 4 groups: White ProRoot mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) (Dentsply Tulsa Dental, Tulsa, OK), Biodentine (Septodont, Saint Maur des Fosses, France), EndoSequence Root Repair Material Fast Set Putty (Brasseler USA, Savannah, GA), and NeoMTA (Avalon Biomed Inc, Houston, TX). After allowing samples to set according to the manufacturers' instructions, exposed surfaces of the bioceramic materials were prepared using ClearFil SE Bond (Kuraray America, Inc., New York, NY) followed by restoration with ClearFil DC Core Plus (Kuraray America, Inc.). To test shear bond strength, each block was secured in a universal testing machine, and the crosshead was advanced at 0.5 mm/min until fracture. Newton peak force was recorded and megapascals calculated followed by data comparison. RESULTS: The mean shear bond strengths between ClearFil DC Core Plus and the bioceramic materials were as follows: White ProRoot MTA, 7.96 MPa; Biodentine, 9.18 MPa; EndoSequence Root Repair Material Fast Set Putty, 4.47 MPa; and NeoMTA, 5.72 MPa. White ProRoot MTA and Biodentine were statistically similar, with a higher stress bond strength than NeoMTA, which had a statistically greater bond strength than EndoSequence Root Repair Material. All these values were lower than typical bond strengths shown for dentin-composite resin bonding. CONCLUSIONS: The choice of which bioceramic material to use in regenerative procedures should be based on factors other than the bond between that material and the overlying coronal resin restoration.
引用
- Hursh KA, Kirkpatrick TC, Cardon JW, et al. Shear Bond Comparison between 4 Bioceramic Materials and Dual-cure Composite Resin. J Endod. 2019. PMID: 31492579. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2019.07.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。