文献速递口腔修复与种植牙周病

氧化锆与钛种植体在有无颊侧骨开裂时的组织整合:一项组织学与影像学临床前研究

Tissue integration of zirconia and titanium implants with and without buccal dehiscence defects-A histologic and radiographic preclinical study.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Oral Implants Res · 2019-05-12

在六只犬下颌骨随机植入五种种植体,比较氧化锆(改性表面Z1、标准表面Z2)与钛种植体在有无颊侧骨开裂(3 mm高)时的软组织与硬组织整合。结果显示,存在颊侧骨开裂时钛种植体组(T_D)种植体周围黏膜高度随时间显著丧失(-1.45 mm),而改性表面氧化锆种植体组(Z1_D)无显著变化;Z1的骨-种植体接触高于Z2和T。所有组影像学边缘骨水平变化均小于1 mm。

要点

  • 颊侧骨开裂时钛种植体周围黏膜高度显著丧失,改性表面氧化锆无此显著变化。
  • 改性表面氧化锆种植体的骨-种植体接触高于标准表面氧化锆和钛种植体。
  • 所有组影像学边缘骨水平变化均小于1 mm。

核心结论

  • 存在颊侧骨开裂时,钛种植体较改性表面氧化锆种植体出现显著的种植体周围黏膜高度丧失,源于黏膜边缘更明显的根向移位。
  • 改性氧化锆表面可增强骨整合。

研究设计与样本

  • 在六只犬的下颌骨两侧随机植入五种种植体:Z1(改性表面氧化锆)、Z2(标准表面氧化锆)、T(钛)、Z1_D(Z1伴颊侧骨开裂,3 mm高、宽度与种植体体部相同)、T_D(钛伴颊侧骨开裂)。
  • 每侧半下颌分别进行2周愈合和6个月负载。

主要发现

  • 所有组黏膜边缘中位水平随时间向根方移动,Z1_D组为-0.52 mm,T_D组为-1.26 mm,均为临界统计学显著性。
  • Z1_D和T_D组种植体周围黏膜中位高度在2周和6个月时最大,但仅T_D组随时间线性变化有统计学显著性(-1.45 mm)。
  • Z1组骨-种植体接触高于Z2和T组。
  • 所有组影像学边缘骨水平变化均小于1 mm。

临床怎么用

  • 颊侧骨开裂条件下,改性表面氧化锆种植体可能比钛种植体更有利于维持种植体周围黏膜高度。
  • 改性氧化锆表面可能促进骨整合,但需进一步临床验证。

局限性

  • 临床前犬模型研究,样本量小(六只犬),结果外推至人类需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To histologically and radiographically evaluate soft (primary outcome) and hard tissue integration of two-piece titanium and zirconia dental implants with/without buccal dehiscence defects. MATERIALS & METHODS: In six dogs, five implants were randomly placed on both sides of the mandible: (a) Z1: a zirconia implant (modified surface) within the bony housing, (b) Z2: a zirconia implant (standard surface) within the bony housing, (c) T: a titanium implant within the bony housing, (d) Z1_D: a Z1 implant placed with a buccal bone dehiscence (3 mm in height, identical width to implant body), and (e) T_D: a titanium implant placed with a buccal bone dehiscence. Two weeks of healing and 6 months of loading were applied on each hemi-mandible, respectively. RESULTS: The median level of the margo mucosae shifted more apically over time in all groups (borderline statistical significance in groups Z1_D: -0.52 mm and T_D: -1.26 mm). The median height of the peri-implant mucosa in groups Z1_D and T_D was greatest at 2 weeks and 6 months, but the linear change in the peri-implant mucosa was statistically significant only for group T_D over time (-1.45 mm). Z1 demonstrated a higher bone-to-implant contact compared to Z2 and T. Minimal change of radiographic marginal bone levels in all groups was observed (<1 mm). CONCLUSION: When buccal dehiscence was presented, titanium implants presented significant loss of peri-implant mucosal height compared to zirconia implants with a modified surface, due to greater apical shift of the margo mucosae. A modified zirconia surface enhanced osseointegration.

来源:Clin Oral Implants Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Thoma DS, Lim HC, Paeng KW, et al. Tissue integration of zirconia and titanium implants with and without buccal dehiscence defects-A histologic and radiographic preclinical study. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2019. PMID: 31038788. doi:10.1111/clr.13451

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。