文献速递口腔修复与种植

显微CT评估犬种植体-骨结合率的可行性与有效性研究

[Research on feasibility and effectiveness of the bone-implant contact evaluation in dogs by micro-CT].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2019-01-01

本研究以6只比格犬双侧下颌植入种植体,对比显微CT与光学显微镜评估种植体-骨结合率(BIC)的可行性和有效性。结果显示显微CT检测更快、建模成功率更高,以距种植体表面50 μm为分析区域时与光镜结果高度一致。

要点

  • 显微CT评估单个样本BIC约90分钟,远快于光镜法的14天。
  • 显微CT建模成功率100.0%,光镜磨片制作成功率92.4%。
  • 距种植体表面50 μm分析区域时,显微CT与光镜BIC无显著差异且相关性高。

核心结论

  • 显微CT检测BIC较光镜观察法更快速、简便,且建模成功率更高。
  • 选择距种植体表面50 μm为分析区域时,显微CT法BIC结果与光镜观察法一致性较高。

研究设计与样本

  • 选用6只雄性比格犬,拔除下颌双侧第二前磨牙至第一磨牙,愈合3个月后每侧植入4枚种植体。
  • 术后2、4、8周分别处死2只动物,每个时间点制取16个含种植体骨样本。
  • 先用显微CT扫描分析距种植体表面25、50、100 μm内的骨量并计算BIC,再制作不脱钙磨片用光镜观察BIC。

主要发现

  • 显微CT评估单个样本BIC耗时约90分钟,远低于光镜法的14天。
  • 显微CT建模成功率均为100.0%(48/48),总成功率100.0%(144/144);光镜磨片制作成功率2、4、8周分别为89.6%(43/48)、93.8%(45/48)、93.8%(45/48),总成功率92.4%(133/144)。
  • 术后2、4、8周显微CT(25)组BIC均显著小于同时点光镜组(P<0.05);显微CT(50)组和显微CT(100)组与光镜组差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。
  • 显微CT(25)、(50)、(100)组BIC与光镜组BIC的相关系数r分别为0.680、0.892、0.713(P均<0.001),误差偏倚分别为-19.4%、-0.9%、3.0%,95%一致性界限内概率均为97.9%(47/48)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 显微CT分析区域选择距种植体表面50 μm时,BIC与光镜观察法一致性较高(r=0.892,误差偏倚-0.9%)。
  • 显微CT(50)组和显微CT(100)组BIC与光镜组差异无统计学意义(P>0.05)。

临床怎么用

  • 显微CT可作为快速、简便评估种植体-骨结合率的方法,推荐分析区域选择距种植体表面50 μm。
  • 显微CT建模成功率高于光镜磨片制作,可提高科研和临床前研究的效率。

局限性

  • 研究仅基于6只比格犬的动物实验,样本量有限。
  • 原文未报告其他局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To discuss the feasibility and effectiveness of using micro-CT in bone-implant contact (BIC) evaluation in dogs, and to provide reference for clinical and scientific research. Methods: Bilateral mandibular second premolar and first molar of six male Beagle dogs were extracted. After 3 months' healing, eight implants were placed in bilateral mandible of each dog, four on each side. Dogs were sacrificed at 2 weeks, 4 weeks and 8 weeks after implant placement, two on each time point. Samples were scanned with micro-CT and digitally reconstructed. Bone-implant interface was analyzed at different analysis regions (25, 50 and 100 μm from implants' surface), different detection range models were obtained (each time point consists 48 models), and BIC was evaluated, and the results were counted as micro-CT(25), micro-CT(50), and micro-CT(100) groups. Then undecalcified slides were made (three slides for each sample) and stained with toluidine blue for observation and analysis of BIC using an optical microscope, and the results were counted as optical microscope groups. The advantages and disadvantages, evaluation efficiency and BIC of different methods were analyzed. Results: To evaluate BIC of single sample, it took about 90 minutes by micro-CT, which was much lower than the time of 14 days by optical microscope. The success rates of modeling of micro-CT(25), micro-CT(50), and micro-CT(100) groups all were 100.0% (48/48), and total success rate of micro-CT group was 100.0% (144/144). For optical microscope groups, the success rates of making slides 2, 4, 8 weeks were 89.6% (43/48), 93.8% (45/48) and 93.8% (45/48), respectively, and total success rates of optical microscope group was 92.4% (133/144). At 2, 4,8 weeks after implantation, BIC in micro-CT(25) group was significantly smaller than that in optical microscope group at the same time point (P<0.05). However, at 2, 4,8 weeks after implantation, BIC of the micro-CT(50) and micro-CT(100) groups showed no significant difference with optical microscope groups at the same time point (P>0.05). A significant correlation (P<0.001, each) was seen between slides and micro-CT (25, 50, 100 μm groups) concerning BIC (r=0.680, r=0.892, r=0.713), and error bias was -19.4%, -0.9%, 3.0%, respectively. The probability within the 95% limits of agreement were 97.9%. Conclusions: Micro-CT is a faster, simpler and more efficient way to analyze BIC at the implant-bone interface than optical microscope observation. BIC analysis by selecting 50 μm from implants' surface as analysis region using micro-CT is in consistent with that using the optical microscope. 目的: 探讨显微CT评估犬种植体-骨结合率(bone-implant contact,BIC)的可行性和有效性,为临床和科研提供参考。 方法: 选用纯系健康雄性比格犬6只,拔除下颌双侧第二前磨牙至第一磨牙;自然愈合3个月后每只犬下颌每侧植入4枚种植体。种植术后2、4、8周分别处死2只动物,每个时间点制取16个含种植体的骨样本。先用显微CT扫描骨样本,分别分析每枚种植体表面外延25、50、100 μm内的骨量,得到不同检测范围模型(每个时间点48个),并计算BIC,结果计为显微CT(2)5组、显微CT(50)组、显微CT(100)组;再将骨样本制成不脱钙磨片(每个骨样本制备3个磨片),使用光学显微镜观察分析BIC(%),结果计为光镜组。对比两种方法的优缺点、检测效率以及BIC的相关性和一致性。 结果: 评估单个骨样本BIC,显微CT法从扫描重建到得出结果耗时约90 min,远低于光镜观察法耗时(从磨片制作到得出结果的时间为14 d)。术后2、4、8周显微CT法检测范围模型的建模成功率均为100.0%(48/48),总体建模成功率为100.0%(144/144)。术后2、4、8周光镜观察法磨片的制作成功率分别为89.6%(43/48)、93.8%(45/48)和93.8%(45/48),总体磨片制作成功率为92.4%(133/144)。术后2、4、8周显微CT(25)组BIC均显著小于相同时间点光镜组(P<0.05)。术后2、4、8周显微CT(50)组和显微CT(100)组BIC与相同时间点光镜组BIC的差异均无统计学意义(P>0.05)。显微CT(25)组、显微CT(50)组、显微CT(100)组BIC与光镜组BIC的相关系数r值分别为0.680、0.892和0.713(P均<0.001),误差偏倚分别为-19.4%、-0.9%和3.0%,95%一致性界限内概率均为97.9%(47/48)。 结论: 使用显微CT检测BIC较光镜观察法更快速、简便,且建模成功率更高,检测范围为50 μm时显微CT法检测结果与光学观察法一致性较高。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bai JY, Meng FH, Shao XX, et al. [Research on feasibility and effectiveness of the bone-implant contact evaluation in dogs by micro-CT]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2019. PMID: 30955297. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.1002-0098.2019.04.008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。