离体前磨牙根尖三角洲检测:根尖片、CBCT与显微CT对比研究
该离体研究以显微CT为金标准,比较根尖片与CBCT对110颗人前磨牙(120个根管)根尖三角洲的检出效能。根尖三角洲存在于40个根管(33.3%),CBCT各项诊断指标均优于根尖片(P<.05),但两者敏感性均很低(根尖片0.07、CBCT 0.35),且CBCT倾向于低估根尖孔数量(P<.05)。
要点
- CBCT检出根尖三角洲的效能优于根尖片,但两者敏感性均很低
- CBCT倾向于低估根尖孔数量,不能可靠评估根尖孔数目
- 显微CT作为金标准发现根尖三角洲存在于33.3%的根管中
核心结论
- CBCT检出根尖三角洲的效能优于根尖片,但两者与金标准相比均低估其存在。
- CBCT通常不能可靠评估根尖孔数量。
研究设计与样本
- 离体研究,纳入110颗人前磨牙(120个根管)。
- 根尖片与CBCT图像由两名口腔放射科医师采用5点量表评估根尖三角洲,并以显微CT为金标准。
- 采用McNemar检验比较诊断效能,配对t检验比较根尖孔数目检测(α≤0.05)。
主要发现
- 显微CT显示根尖三角洲存在于40个根管(33.3%)。
- 根尖片与CBCT检出根尖三角洲均与金标准存在显著差异(P<.05)。
- CBCT各项诊断指标均高于根尖片(P<.05)。
- 根尖片准确度为0.62、CBCT为0.73,但敏感性分别仅为0.07和0.35。
- CBCT倾向于低估根尖孔数量(P<.05)。
临床怎么用
- 临床识别根尖三角洲时不应仅依赖根尖片或CBCT阴性结果,两者敏感性低易漏诊。
- CBCT可用于辅助评估根尖三角洲,但根尖孔数目不宜以CBCT作为可靠依据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Imaging methods are essential for the correct identification of root canal anatomy, which is a key factor for successful endodontic therapy. This study aimed to evaluate the performance of periapical radiography (PR) and cone-beam computed tomographic (CBCT) imaging in identifying the apical delta (AD) using micro-computed tomographic imaging as the gold standard. METHODS: PR and CBCT images of 110 human premolars (120 root canals) were obtained using the VistaScan digital intraoral system (Durr Dental, Beitigheim-Bissinger, Germany) and the 3D Accuitomo CBCT unit (J Morita, Kyoto, Japan), respectively. Two oral radiologists assessed the PR and CBCT images for the presence of ADs using a 5-point scale. Additionally, in the CBCT images, the number of apical foramina was also evaluated. The gold standard was established by means of micro-computed tomographic imaging. The diagnostic values related to PR and CBCT imaging were compared using the McNemar test. The detection of the number of foramina was compared using the paired t test (α ≤ 0.05). RESULTS: ADs were present in 40 root canals (33.3%). Both PR and CBCT images differed significantly from the gold standard (P < .05) in the detection of ADs. CBCT imaging showed higher values than PR for all diagnostic tests (P < .05). Despite the moderate accuracy of PR (0.62) and CBCT imaging (0.73), these methods presented very low sensitivity values (0.07 and 0.35 for PR and CBCT, respectively). CBCT imaging had a tendency of underestimating the number of foramina (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: CBCT imaging showed better performance than PR in the detection of ADs; both imaging modalities underestimate its presence when compared with the gold standard. In general, the number of apical foramina cannot be reliably assessed using CBCT imaging.
引用
- Nascimento EHL, Abrahão Elias MR, Vasconcelos VHF, et al. Ex Vivo Detection of Apical Delta in Premolars: A Comparative Study Using Periapical Radiography, Cone-beam Computed Tomography, and Micro-computed Tomography. J Endod. 2019. PMID: 30954279. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2019.02.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。