文献速递牙体牙髓病

牙髓器械疲劳抗力研究中的对照选择:一项网络分析

Comparator Choice in Studies Testing Endodontic Instrument Fatigue Resistance: A Network Analysis.
PubMed 文献 · J Endod · 2019-04-03

结果显示比较多沿器械用途进行,形成3个独立子网络,部分器械成为枢纽节点,传统镍钛合金最常用,近年测试多样性增加。

要点

  • CFR研究比较多沿器械用途(疏通、成形、再治疗)进行,形成三个独立子网络。
  • ProTaper Universal和Mtwo等器械为枢纽节点,可能作为金标准。
  • 传统镍钛合金是最常测试的合金,少数制造商主导网络。

核心结论

  • CFR比较通常沿器械用途进行,部分器械和合金(传统镍钛)主导网络。
  • 对照选择导致的总体偏倚风险似乎为中等,但较少测试器械的证据可能不稳健。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述通过Medline和Embase检索1986-2017年文献。
  • 纳入分析≥2种引擎驱动器械在人工弯曲根管系统中CFR的体外研究。
  • 采用社交网络分析技术分析研究网络。

主要发现

  • 器械网络密度低(0.19),高度聚集(0.71),形成3个独立子网络(疏通、成形、再治疗)。
  • ProTaper Universal和Mtwo等器械为枢纽节点,可能作为金标准。
  • 传统镍钛合金是最常使用的合金,少数制造商主导网络。
  • 近年来测试的器械、合金和制造商多样性增加。

临床怎么用

  • 解读CFR研究时需考虑对照选择可能带来的偏倚,尤其对较少测试的器械。
  • 临床选择器械时可参考网络中的枢纽器械作为比较基准,但需注意证据稳健性。

局限性

  • 对照选择导致的总体偏倚风险为中等,但较少测试器械的证据可能不稳健。
  • 网络几何形状的潜在因素(如赞助)有待探索。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: Endodontic instruments are frequently compared against each other for their cyclic fatigue resistance (CFR). It is unclear what drives the comparator choice in CFR studies, and how comparators and comparisons have evolved over time. We aimed at evaluating CFR study networks, hypothesizing that indications and instrument properties (alloy, manufacturer) drive comparisons. METHODS: A systematic review was performed via Medline and Embase (1986-2017). In vitro studies analyzing the CFR of ≥2 engine-driven instruments in an artificial curved root canal system were included. We classified instruments according to name, alloy, and manufacturer. Study networks were analyzed using social network analysis techniques. RESULTS: Eighty-five studies on 56 different instruments (9 alloys, 17 manufacturers) were included. For instruments, a low-density (0.19), highly clustered (0.71) network with 3 separate subnetworks (for glide path, shaping, and retreatment instruments) emerged. Certain instruments (ProTaper Universal [Dentsply Maillefer, Ballaigues, Switzerland], Mtwo [VDW Dental, Munich, Germany]) served as hub nodes and possible gold standards. Conventional Nickel-Titanium was the most frequently used alloy. Few manufacturers dominated the network. The diversity of tested instruments, alloys, and manufacturers increased in recent years. CONCLUSIONS: Comparisons of CFR were usually made along indications. Some instruments and alloys (conventional Nickel-Titanium) dominated the networks. Overall risk of bias by comparator choice seems moderate; however, the evidence on certain, less often tested instruments may not be robust. Factors underlying the network geometry (eg, sponsorship) should be explored.

来源:J Endod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Herbst SR, Krois J, Schwendicke F, et al. Comparator Choice in Studies Testing Endodontic Instrument Fatigue Resistance: A Network Analysis. J Endod. 2019. PMID: 30952371. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2019.02.015

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。