自体骨移植位点与天然骨位点种植体5-16年临床与患者报告结局的病例对照研究
这项病例对照研究比较了自体骨移植位点与天然骨位点种植体的影像学边缘骨水平及患者报告结局。38例患者共67枚种植体,随访5-16年,天然骨组边缘骨水平显著更高,两组种植体存留率及软组织参数相似,患者满意度均高。
要点
- 天然骨位点种植体边缘骨水平显著优于自体骨移植位点(p=0.0411)。
- 两组种植体存留率及牙周/种植体周围参数相似,患者满意度均高。
- 自体骨取骨后约三分之一患者发生并发症,但多为暂时性。
核心结论
- 自体骨移植位点与天然骨位点种植体在5-16年后均表现出健康的种植体周围组织。
- 天然骨位点种植体的边缘骨水平显著高于自体骨移植位点。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照研究,纳入38例患者,均分为自体骨块移植组(AB)和天然骨组(NB),共植入67枚种植体。
- 随访为种植体植入后至少5年,平均随访时间AB组10.2年(范围6-13年),NB组8.3年(范围5-16年)。
- 采用非参数混合模型比较两组,以考虑数据的聚类性。
主要发现
- 随访时NB组中位边缘骨水平为1.15 mm(Q1: 0.50 mm/Q3: 1.83 mm),AB组为1.58 mm(Q1: 1.01 mm/Q3: 2.40 mm),差异显著(p=0.0411)。
- NB组1枚种植体失败,存留率97.5%;AB组无失败,存留率100%。
- 两组探诊深度、探诊出血和退缩值相似。
- 患者报告结局显示两组视觉模拟量表评分均高,即满意度高。
- 初次增量术后,供区观察到6例主要并发症(伤口裂开、急性牙髓炎、口内和口外感觉异常)。
临床怎么用
- 对于需要种植修复的患者,天然骨位点种植体长期边缘骨水平可能更优,但需考虑自体骨移植的适应证。
- 自体骨移植取骨后应警惕供区并发症,尽管多为暂时性。
- 两组患者满意度均高,提示两种方式均可获得良好的患者报告结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To compare the radiographic marginal bone levels of implants placed in sites previously augmented with autogenous bone grafts and implants placed in native bone. Secondary outcomes included: implant survival, periodontal/peri-implant parameters as well as short- and long-term patient-reported outcome measures. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study was designed as a case-control study including 38 patients equally distributed into two groups (previously augmented with autogenous bone blocks [AB] and implants placed in native bone [NB]). In total, 67 implants were placed. Clinical, radiographic and patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), and complication rates were assessed based on a chart review and at a follow-up examination (≧5 years after implant placement). Nonparametric mixed models were applied for the comparison of the two groups because of the clustered data. The data were analyzed descriptively, and p-values were calculated using nonparametric mixed models to account for the clustered data. RESULTS: The mean follow-up time was 10.2 years (range 6-13 years; AB) and 8.3 years (range 5-16 years; NB). One implant was lost in group NB (97.5% survival rate) and none in group AB (100%). Following primary augmentation, six major complications (wound dehiscences, acute pulpitis, intra- and extraoral sensitivity disturbances) were observed at the donor sites. At time of implant placement, only minimal complications occurred and only in group NB. Median marginal bone levels at the follow-up were significantly higher in group NB (1.15; Q1: 0.50 mm/Q3: 1.83 mm) than in group AB (1.58; Q1: 1.01 mm/Q3: 2.40 mm; p = 0.0411). Probing depth, bleeding on probing and recession values were similar in both groups. PROMs revealed high visual analog scale values (i.e., high satisfaction) for both procedures. CONCLUSIONS: Dental implants placed in sites augmented with autogenous bone or in native bone revealed healthy peri-implant tissues after 5-16 years. Marginal bone levels were significantly higher for implant placed in native bone. Complications following primary augmentation encompassed every third patient but were mostly transient.
引用
- Thoma DS, Maggetti I, Waller T, et al. Clinical and patient-reported outcomes of implants placed in autogenous bone grafts and implants placed in native bone: A case-control study with a follow-up of 5-16 years. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2019. PMID: 30698868. doi:10.1111/clr.13410
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。