牙髓病学临床病例报告质量报告指南:PRICE制定方案
该方案旨在制定并传播牙髓病学病例报告首选报告条目(PRICE)指南,以帮助作者采用最高报告标准。项目由指导委员会通过五阶段共识流程开发PRICE清单和流程图,包括30人德尔菲专家组(PDG)和20人面对面会议组(PFMG),最终清单将出版并传播。
要点
- PRICE指南旨在规范牙髓病学病例报告的报告质量。
- 制定采用五阶段共识流程,包括德尔菲法和面对面会议。
- 最终清单将发表并通过学术机构和国家牙髓病学会传播。
核心结论
- 项目旨在制定并传播牙髓病学病例报告首选报告条目(PRICE)指南,以帮助作者采用最高报告标准。
研究设计与样本
- 项目负责人(PD和VN)成立由另外六名成员组成的指导委员会,采用五阶段共识流程制定PRICE指南。
- 指导委员会将确定源自CAse REport指南和临床与实验室图像出版原则的相关条目,形成PRICE清单和流程图。
关键数值与推荐
- 指导委员会将组建由30名成员(包括学者、从业者和公众成员)组成的PRICE德尔菲专家组(PDG)。
- PDG基于9点Likert量表评估PRICE清单的各个条目,仅纳入70%或以上成员评分在7至9分之间的条目进入草案清单。
- 德尔菲过程将持续到达成共识,最终条目由PDG成员同意。
- 随后成立由20名成员组成的PRICE面对面会议组(PFMG)以达成最终共识。
- 最终共识清单和流程图将由PDG和PFMG选定的成员评估和批准。
临床怎么用
- 批准的PRICE指南将发表在相关期刊上,并通过学术机构和国家牙髓病学会的联系传播,以及在科学/临床会议上展示。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Case reports are used to communicate interesting, new or rare condition/s, innovative treatment approaches or novel techniques. Apart from informing readers, such information has the potential to contribute towards further scientific studies and the development of newer management modalities. In that context, it is important that case reports are presented accurately and deliver all the necessary and pertinent information to the reader. Reporting guidelines are used to inform authors of the quality standards required to ensure their manuscripts are accurate, complete and transparent. The aim of this project is to develop and disseminate new guidelines - Preferred Reporting Items for Case reports in Endodontics (PRICE). The primary aim is to aid authors when constructing case reports in the field of Endodontics to ensure the highest possible reporting standards are adopted. The project leaders (PD and VN) formed a steering committee comprising six additional members. Subsequently, a five-phase consensus process will be used. The steering committee will develop the PRICE guidelines (PRICE checklist and flow chart) by identifying relevant items (quality standards) derived from the CAse REport guidelines and Clinical and Laboratory Images in Publications principles, focussing on the content of case reports. Following this, the steering committee will identify a PRICE Delphi Group (PDG) consisting of 30 members including academicians, practitioners, and members of the public. The individual items (components) of the PRICE checklist will be evaluated by the PDG based on a 9-point Likert scale. Only items scored between 7 and 9 by 70% or more members will be included in the draft checklist. The Delphi process will be continued until a consensus is reached and a final set of items agreed by the PDG members. Following this, a PRICE Face-to-Face meeting group (PFMG) will be formed with 20 members to achieve a final consensus. The final consensus-based checklist and flow chart will be evaluated and approved by selected members of the PDG and PFMG. The approved PRICE guidelines will be published in relevant journals and disseminated via contacts in academic institutions and national endodontic societies, as well as being presented at scientific/clinical meetings.
引用
- Nagendrababu V, Chong BS, McCabe P, et al. Guidelines for reporting the quality of clinical case reports in Endodontics: a development protocol. Int Endod J. 2019. PMID: 30586165. doi:10.1111/iej.13067
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。