文献速递儿童口腔

ICDAS-Ⅱ与WHO标准在低龄儿童龋检测中的比较研究

[A comparative study on early childhood caries detection by using international caries detection and assessment system-Ⅱ and WHO criteria].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi · 2018-01-01

该研究对北京市4所幼儿园449名3岁儿童分别采用ICDAS-Ⅱ系统和WHO标准进行龋病检查。ICDAS-Ⅱ在D1、D2水平检测的患龋率显著高于WHO标准,显示其检测早期龋损更敏感,对低龄儿童龋的早期预防具有指导价值。

要点

  • ICDAS-Ⅱ在D1水平患龋率76.6%,显著高于WHO标准的48.8%。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D1、D2水平下颌磨牙面患龋最多,D3、D4水平上颌前牙邻面最多。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ能检测早期釉质脱矿,对龋病早期预防更具指导意义。

核心结论

  • ICDAS-Ⅱ系统比WHO标准更敏感,能检测出早期釉质脱矿情况。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ对低龄儿童龋的早期预防具有特定指导价值。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入北京市4所幼儿园共449名3岁小班儿童。
  • 分别采用ICDAS-Ⅱ系统和WHO标准进行口腔检查并记录。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ设D1至D4四个 cut-off 点区分健康与龋齿,用SPSS分析差异显著性。

主要发现

  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D1至D4患龋率分别为76.6%(344/449)、71.3%(320/449)、52.8%(237/449)和46.1%(207/449)。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D1至D4龋均分别为4.95±4.85、4.41±4.77、2.54±3.69和1.97±3.10。
  • WHO标准患龋率为48.8%(219/449),龋均为2.27±3.54。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D1、D2水平患龋率显著高于WHO标准(P=0.00),D3、D4与WHO差异无统计学意义(P=0.23,P=0.42)。
  • D1、D2水平下颌磨牙面患龋最多,D3、D4水平上颌前牙邻面患龋最多。

关键数值与推荐

  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D1:0级为健康,1~6级为龋齿。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D2:0~1级为健康,2~6级为龋齿。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D3:0~2级为健康,3~6级为龋齿。
  • ICDAS-Ⅱ D4:0~3级为健康,4~6级为龋齿。

临床怎么用

  • 在低龄儿童龋流行病调查中可优先使用ICDAS-Ⅱ以发现早期釉质脱矿。
  • 对D1、D2水平检出的早期龋应加强预防干预。
  • 关注下颌磨牙面及上颌前牙邻面等高风险牙面。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To investigate and compare the sensitivities of early childhood caries detection by using international caries detection and assessment system (ICDAS)-Ⅱ and WHO criteria. Methods: A total of 449 3-year-old children from four day care kindergartens in Beijing were enrolled in this study. Both ICDAS-Ⅱ and WHO criteria were used to assess the prevalence of caries in the given subjects. The decayed, missing, and filled teeth (dmft) index scores were calculated. In ICDAS-Ⅱ system, four cut-off points (D1, D2, D3 and D4) were employed to differentiate sound and decayed teeth: D1 (score 0 as sound, scores 1-6 as caries); D2 (0-1 sound, 2-6 caries); D3 (0-2 sound, 3-6 caries) and D4 (0-3 sound, 4-6 caries). SPSS software was used to analyze the data to decide the significance of differences. Results: The caries prevalence using ICDAS-Ⅱ were 76.6% (344/449), 71.3% (320/449), 52.8% (237/449) and 46.1% (207/449) for D1 to D4, respectively; the corresponding mean dmft scores were 4.95±4.85, 4.41±4.77, 2.54±3.69 and 1.97±3.10. The sites with highest caries prevalence were occlusal surface of mandibular molars in groups of D1 and D2 and proximal surface of maxillary anterior teeth in groups D3 and D4. In contrast, the caries prevalence was 48.8% (219/449) and the mean dmft was 2.27±3.54 when using WHO criteria, significantly lower than the detection rates by using ICDAS-Ⅱ (D1-D2) (P=0.00). This suggested that ICDAS-Ⅱ system was a more sensitive method in detecting early childhood caries. Conclusions: ICDAS-Ⅱ system might be superior in detection of incipient caries and be of specific value in prevention of early childhood caries. 目的: 比较国际龋病检查和评估系统(international caries detection and assessment system,ICDAS)-Ⅱ与WHO检查方法在低龄儿童龋流行病调查中的应用,评估ICDAS-Ⅱ在指导儿童口腔疾病预防与治疗中的意义。 方法: 对北京市4所幼儿园共449名小班儿童(3岁)分别采用ICDAS-Ⅱ系统和WHO标准进行口腔检查记录。对ICDAS-Ⅱ的检查结果进行龋分级比较:D1(0级为健康,1~6级为龋齿);D2(0~1级为健康,2~6级为龋齿);D3(0~2级为健康,3~6级为龋齿);D4(0~3级为健康,4~6级为龋齿)。对两种龋病评估系统得到的患龋率、龋均及各牙面患龋情况进行统计学分析与比较。 结果: ICDAS-Ⅱ中D1~D4患龋率分别为76.6%(344/449)、71.3%(320/449)、52.8%(237/449)和46.1%(207/449);龋均分别为:4.95±4.85、4.41±4.77、2.54±3.69和1.97±3.10;牙面患龋情况显示:在D1、D2水平下颌磨牙区■面患龋最多,D3、D4水平上颌前牙区邻面患龋最多。WHO方法检测的患龋率为48.8%(219/449),龋均为2.27±3.54,患龋率显著低于ICDAS-Ⅱ系统检测中D1、D2标准(P=0.00),与D3、D4水平的患龋率相比差异均无统计学意义(P=0.23,P=0.42)。 结论: ICDAS-Ⅱ龋病评估系统与传统的WHO标准相比能检测出早期釉质脱矿情况,对龋病的早期预防更具有指导意义。.

来源:Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sun P, Chen W, Yi X, et al. [A comparative study on early childhood caries detection by using international caries detection and assessment system-Ⅱ and WHO criteria]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2018. PMID: 30419651. doi:10.3760/cma.j.issn.1002-0098.2018.11.002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。