第五届EAO共识会议第4组:种植修复生物力学共识声明
本文报告第五届EAO共识会议第4组对五篇系统综述的讨论与共识,涵盖冠根比、悬臂梁重建、倾斜种植体并发症及种植体与天然牙共存影响。共识认为冠根比0.9-2.2的单冠修复可行,悬臂梁重建存活率高但并发症常见,倾斜种植体无更高失败率但证据偏倚风险高。
要点
- 冠根比0.9-2.2不影响单冠修复的生物学或技术并发症。
- 悬臂梁重建存活率高,但5-10年内饰面材料相关并发症常见。
- 倾斜种植体失败率和边缘骨吸收未显示更高,但证据偏倚风险高。
核心结论
- 冠根比0.9-2.2的单冠修复可视为可行治疗方案。
- 全口及部分无牙颌悬臂梁多单位重建是可行治疗方案,但并发症常见且主要与树脂饰面材料相关。
- 倾斜种植体可能影响种植体及周围骨稳定性,但软组织及修复体行为报告不足。
- 天然牙与种植修复体间位置变化频繁,应告知患者长期可能需相关治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 第五届EAO共识会议第4组对五篇系统综述进行讨论、评估、修正并形成共识声明。
主要发现
- 冠根比0.9-2.2不影响单冠修复的生物学或技术并发症。
- 悬臂梁重建全口及部分无牙颌种植体和重建存活率高,但5-10年观察期并发症率高,尤其饰面材料相关。
- 倾斜种植体与直种植体相比无更高失败率及边缘骨吸收增加的证据。
- 天然牙与种植修复体间频繁发生位置变化,年轻个体更明显,随年龄减少但成人仍存在。
关键数值与推荐
- 冠根比范围0.9-2.2。
- 悬臂梁重建观察期5-10年。
临床怎么用
- 单冠修复可考虑冠根比0.9-2.2。
- 悬臂梁重建需告知患者并发症常见,尤其树脂饰面相关。
- 倾斜种植体需谨慎考虑,因软组织和修复体行为报告不足。
- 应告知患者天然牙与种植修复体间位置变化可能需长期治疗。
局限性
- 主要数据来自高偏倚风险研究。
- 单种植体修复数据少。
- 支持倾斜种植体结论的数据偏倚风险高且常报告不完整。
- 位置变化的患者潜在影响不明确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The aim of the present publication was to report on the EAO Workshop group-4 discussions and consensus statements on the five reviews previously prepared. These reviews provided the scientific evidence on the effect of crown-to-implant ratio, on reconstructions with cantilevers in fully and partially edentulous patients, on biological and technical complications of tilted in comparison with straight implants, and on the effects of osseointegrated implants functioning in a residual dentition. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The group discussed, evaluated, corrected where deemed appropriate, and made recommendations to the authors regarding the following five reviews submitted: (a) Is there an effect of crown-to-implant ratio on implant treatment outcomes?; (b) Implant-supported cantilevered fixed dental rehabilitations in fully edentulous patients; (c) and in partially edentulous patients; (d) Biological and technical complications of tilted implants in comparison with straight implants supporting fixed dental prostheses; (e) What are the adverse effects of osseointegrated implants functioning among natural teeth of a residual dentition? Based on the five manuscripts and the discussion among the group as well as the plenum members, the major findings were summarized, consensus statements were formulated, clinical recommendations were proposed, and areas of future research were identified. RESULTS: Crown-to-implant ratios ranging from 0.9 to 2.2 did not influence the occurrence of biological or technical complications also in single-tooth restorations. Reconstructions with cantilevers for the rehabilitation of fully and partially edentulous jaws showed high implant and reconstruction survival rates. In contrast, the rate of complications-in particular associated with veneering material-was high during the observation period of 5-10 years. The data reported were primarily derived from studies with high risk of bias. The data for single-implant reconstructions were small. There was no evidence that distally tilted implants were associated with higher failure rates and increased amounts of marginal bone loss. The data supporting these findings, however, were at high risk of bias and frequently incompletely reported. Frequent positional changes occurred between the natural teeth and the implant-supported restorations. These changes were more pronounced in younger individuals, and even though they were reduced with age, they still occurred in adult patients. Even though these changes were frequent, potential implications for the patient are unclear. CONCLUSIONS: The use of single-tooth restorations with crown-to-implant ratio in between 0.9 and 2.2 may be considered a viable treatment option. Multiunit reconstructions with cantilevers are a viable treatment option in fully and partially edentulous patients. Clinicians and patients should be aware, however, that complications are frequent and primarily related to resin material used for veneering. There is some evidence that tilting an implant does affect stability of the implant and the surrounding bone. Treatment options to tilted implants should carefully be considered, as the effect on soft tissues and on prosthesis behavior is poorly reported for tilted implants. Positional changes in the dentition in relation to implant-supported restorations occur frequently. The patient should be informed about the possible need for a treatment related to these changes in the long term.
引用
- Hämmerle CHF, Cordaro L, Alccayhuaman KAA, et al. Biomechanical aspects: Summary and consensus statements of group 4. The 5th EAO Consensus Conference 2018. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2018. PMID: 30306690. doi:10.1111/clr.13284
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。