全景片检测根管治疗后无症状根尖周炎的准确性
本研究以CBCT为参考标准,评估全景片对根管治疗后临床/手术确认的根尖周炎的诊断准确性。纳入240例病变患者和240例健康对照,按病变大小和解剖区域分组。全景片灵敏度低(48.8)、特异度高(93.8)、诊断准确率71.3%,观察者间信度和与CBCT一致性均为中等。
要点
- 全景片检测根管治疗后根尖周炎灵敏度低(48.8),易漏诊。
- 全景片特异度高(93.8),阳性预测值高(88.6)。
- 下颌尖牙/前磨牙及磨牙区检出最佳,上下颌切牙及上颌磨牙区最差。
核心结论
- 全景片对根管治疗后根尖周炎诊断准确率良好、特异度高但灵敏度低。
研究设计与样本
- 以CBCT为参考标准,纳入240例经CBCT确认的根管治疗后根尖周炎患者(病变组)和240例根管充填后根尖周健康者(健康组)。
- 病变组按病变大小(2-4.5 mm和4.6-7 mm)及解剖区域(切牙、尖牙/前磨牙、磨牙,上下颌)各分20例组。
- 所有患者先接受全景片检查,并在40天内接受CBCT扫描,采用根尖周指数系统评估。
主要发现
- 全景片灵敏度48.8,阴性预测值64.7,诊断准确率71.3,阳性预测值88.6,特异度93.8。
- 全景片观察者间信度中等(k=0.58),全景片与CBCT一致性中等(k=0.42)。
- 检出最佳部位为下颌尖牙/前磨牙区和磨牙区,最差部位为上下颌切牙区和上颌磨牙区。
临床怎么用
- 全景片可作为根管治疗后根尖周炎的初步筛查工具,但阴性结果不能排除病变。
- 对全景片阴性但临床怀疑根尖周炎者,建议进一步行CBCT检查。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of panoramic radiography (PAN) for the detection of clinically/surgically confirmed apical periodontitis (AP) in root canal-treated teeth using cone-beam computed tomographic (CBCT) imaging as the reference standard. METHODS: Two hundred forty patients with endodontically treated AP (diseased group) were detected via CBCT imaging using the periapical index system. They were divided into groups of 20 each according to lesion size (2-4.5 mm and 4.6-7 mm) and anatomic area (incisor, canine/premolar, and molar) in both the upper and lower arches. Another 240 patients with root filling and a healthy periapex (healthy group) were selected. All diseased and healthy patients underwent PAN first and a CBCT scan within 40 days. The periapical index system was also used to assess AP using PAN. Sensitivity, specificity, diagnostic accuracy, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for PAN images with respect to CBCT imaging were analyzed. The k value was calculated to assess both the interobserver reliability for PAN and the agreement between PAN and CBCT. RESULTS: PAN showed low sensitivity (48.8), mediocre negative predictive value (64.7), good diagnostic accuracy (71.3), and high positive predictive value (88.6) and specificity (93.8). Both interobserver reliability for PAN and agreement between PAN and CBCT were moderate (k = 0.58 and 0.42, respectively). The best identified AP was located in the lower canine/premolar and molar areas, whereas the worst identified AP was located in the upper/lower incisor area and upper molar area. CONCLUSIONS: PAN showed good diagnostic accuracy, high specificity, and low sensitivity for the detection of endodontically treated AP.
引用
- Nardi C, Calistri L, Grazzini G, et al. Is Panoramic Radiography an Accurate Imaging Technique for the Detection of Endodontically Treated Asymptomatic Apical Periodontitis? J Endod. 2018. PMID: 30154006. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2018.07.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。