淀粉对口腔健康的影响:为WHO指南提供依据的系统综述
该系统综述评估总膳食淀粉及用慢消化淀粉(SDS)替代快消化淀粉(RDS)对口腔健康结局的影响,以更新WHO碳水化合物摄入指南。纳入33篇文献(28项研究)比较RDS与SDS,23篇文献(22项研究)评估总淀粉。GRADE评估显示低质量证据提示总淀粉摄入与龋齿风险无关,但RDS摄入可能显著增加龋齿风险;极低质量证据提示总淀粉与口腔癌风险无关,低质量证据提示SDS降低口腔癌风险。
要点
- 低质量证据提示总淀粉摄入与龋齿风险无关,RDS摄入可能增加龋齿风险。
- 低质量证据提示SDS可能降低口腔癌风险,RDS与口腔癌风险关系不确定。
- 极低质量数据提示全谷物淀粉(SDS)对牙周炎有保护作用。
核心结论
- 最佳现有证据提示仅RDS对口腔健康有不良影响。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述遵循PRISMA声明,证据质量采用GRADE评估。
- 从6080篇文献中纳入33篇(28项研究)比较RDS与SDS,23篇(22项研究)评估总淀粉。
主要发现
- RDS与SDS比较:15篇(14项研究)评估龋齿,16篇(12项研究)评估口腔癌,2篇研究牙周病。
- 总淀粉评估:22篇评估龋齿,1篇评估口腔癌。
- GRADE评估为低质量证据,提示总淀粉摄入与龋齿风险无关,RDS摄入可能显著增加龋齿风险。
- 极低质量证据提示总淀粉与口腔癌风险无关,低质量证据提示SDS降低口腔癌风险。
- RDS与口腔癌风险数据不确定;极低质量数据提示全谷物淀粉(SDS)对牙周炎有保护作用。
临床怎么用
- 基于低质量证据,减少RDS摄入可能有助于降低龋齿风险。
- SDS(如全谷物淀粉)可能对口腔癌和牙周炎有保护作用,但证据质量低至极低。
局限性
- GRADE评估显示证据质量普遍为低或极低。
- RDS与口腔癌风险数据不确定。
- 牙周病相关数据极低质量且研究数量少。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
A systematic review was conducted to update evidence on the effect of total dietary starch and of replacing rapidly digestible starches (RDSs) with slowly digestible starches (SDSs) on oral health outcomes to inform updating of World Health Organization guidance on carbohydrate intake. Data sources included MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, LILACS, and Wanfang. Eligible studies were comparative and reported any intervention with a different starch content of diets or foods and data on oral health outcomes relating to dental caries, periodontal disease, or oral cancer. Studies that reported total dietary starch intake or change in starch intake were included or where comparisons or exposure included diets and foods that compared RDSs and/or SDSs. The review was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-analyses) statement, and evidence was assessed with the GRADE Working Group guidelines. From 6,080 papers identified, 33 (28 studies) were included in the RDS versus SDS comparison: 15 (14 studies) assessed the relationship between SDS and/or RDS and dental caries; 16 (12 studies) considered oral cancer; and 2 studied periodontal disease. For total starch, 23 papers (22 studies) were included: 22 assessed the effects on dental caries, and 1 considered oral cancer. GRADE assessment indicated low-quality evidence, suggesting no association between total starch intake and caries risk but that RDS intake may significantly increase caries risk. Very low-quality evidence suggested no association between total starch and oral cancer risk, and low-quality evidence suggested that SDS decreases oral cancer risk. Data on RDS and oral cancer risk were inconclusive. Very low-quality data relating to periodontitis suggested a protective effect of whole grain starches (SDS). The best available evidence suggests that only RDS adversely affects oral health.
引用
- Halvorsrud K, Lewney J, Craig D, et al. Effects of Starch on Oral Health: Systematic Review to Inform WHO Guideline. J Dent Res. 2018. PMID: 30074866. doi:10.1177/0022034518788283
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。