技术增强学习在牙髓病学教育中的效果:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述纳入13项随机对照研究,比较技术增强学习(TEL)与传统教学法在牙髓病学教育中的效果。Meta分析显示,在知识获取(学习域)上TEL与传统方法无显著差异(SMD 0.14,95%CI -0.10至0.39,I2=62.7%),行为域表现也无差异,反应域态度结果不一。结论认为TEL与传统教学法效果相当。
要点
- TEL与传统教学在牙髓病学知识获取上无显著差异。
- 仅3项研究评为低偏倚风险,证据质量有限。
- 反应域和行为域因数据不足未能进行Meta分析。
核心结论
- 基于现有证据,技术增强学习(TEL)与传统学习方法在牙髓病学教育中效果相当。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索PubMed和Scopus截至2018年5月,纳入13项随机对照研究。
- 两名作者独立完成研究筛选、数据提取和偏倚风险评估。
- 采用Kirkpatrick四级培训评估模型评价学习效果,Meta分析用随机效应模型估计标准化均数差(SMD)。
主要发现
- 知识获取(学习域)上TEL与传统方法无显著差异(SMD 0.14,95%CI -0.10至0.39,I2=62.7%)。
- 表现(行为域)上未观察到差异。
- 态度(反应域)上结果不一。
- 仅3项研究被评为低偏倚风险。
- 反应域和行为域无法进行Meta分析。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准为已发表的英文随机对照研究,干预为任何使用TEL的教学方法,对照为传统方法。
- 效果评价采用Kirkpatrick四级模型:反应、学习、行为、结果。
临床怎么用
- 在牙髓病学教学中,TEL可作为传统教学法的等效替代方案。
- 选择教学方法时可考虑TEL,但需结合具体教学目标和资源条件。
局限性
- 仅3项研究为低偏倚风险,整体证据质量有限。
- 反应域和行为域数据不足,未能进行Meta分析。
- 检索截止2018年5月,未纳入之后发表的研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The aim of the present systematic review was to evaluate the effectiveness of technology-enhanced learning (TEL) in the field of Endodontics to improve educational outcomes compared to traditional learning methods. Randomized controlled studies published in English were identified from two electronic databases (PubMed and Scopus) up to May 2018. Two authors independently performed study selection, data extraction and assessed the risk of bias (ROB). Any teaching method using TEL was considered as the intervention, and this was compared to traditional methods. The outcome measuring the effectiveness of learning activities was evaluated by Kirkpatrick's four-level training evaluation model. The four levels of training outcomes are as follows: Reaction, Learning, Behaviour and Results. A meta-analysis was performed to estimate the standardized mean difference (SMD) by the random effects model. In total, 13 studies were included in the systematic review. Only three studies were assessed as 'low' ROB. A meta-analysis could not be performed in the domains of Reaction and Behaviour. No significant difference was observed in knowledge gain (Learning domain) between TEL and traditional methods (SMD, 0.14 (95% CI -0.10 to 0.39) I2 = 62.7%). Similarly, no difference was observed in performance (Behaviour domain). A variable response was found in attitude (Reaction domain). From the available evidence, it can be concluded that TEL is equally as effective as traditional learning methods.
引用
- Nagendrababu V, Pulikkotil SJ, Sultan OS, et al. Effectiveness of technology-enhanced learning in Endodontic education: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Int Endod J. 2018. PMID: 30099740. doi:10.1111/iej.12995
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。