口腔修复学随机对照试验摘要报告质量改进:CONSORT摘要指南发布前后系统评价
该研究比较了口腔修复学领域随机对照试验摘要于CONSORT摘要指南发布前后的报告质量,共纳入131篇摘要。结果显示,CONSORT发布后平均CONSORT评分从5.20升至6.11,但仅标题、结论和试验注册三项有显著改善,多数摘要对招募和结局报告不足。报告质量与期刊影响因子较高、结构化格式及CONSORT发布后发表相关。
要点
- CONSORT摘要指南发布后口腔修复学RCT摘要质量有所改善。
- 仅标题、结论和试验注册三项报告有显著变化。
- 招募和结局报告严重不足,报告率低于3%。
核心结论
- 口腔修复学RCT摘要质量随时间改善,但对CONSORT摘要指南的依从性仍不理想。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价检索PubMed中2001-2007年(pre-CONSORT)和2010-2016年(post-CONSORT)发表于六本口腔修复学期刊的RCT摘要。
- 纳入131篇RCT摘要,采用t检验比较两时期总体质量,并采用单因素和多因素线性回归识别报告质量相关因素,显著性水平P<0.05。
主要发现
- pre-CONSORT和post-CONSORT样本的平均总体CONSORT评分分别为5.20和6.11。
- 仅标题、结论和试验注册三个条目的报告有显著变化。
- 大多数摘要充分报告了干预、目的和结论(>90%),但结果部分招募和结局报告不足(<3%)。
- 两个时期均未报告资助情况。
- 报告质量与较高的影响因子、结构化格式及CONSORT发布后发表相关。
关键数值与推荐
- CONSORT摘要指南发布后平均总体CONSORT评分为6.11,发布前为5.20。
- 干预、目的和结论的充分报告率>90%,招募和结局报告率<3%。
临床怎么用
- 口腔科医生阅读RCT摘要时应注意招募和结局信息可能报告不足。
- 撰写RCT摘要时应遵循CONSORT摘要指南,尤其加强招募和结局报告。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to compare the reporting quality of randomized controlled trial (RCT) abstracts in prosthodontics before and after the publication of Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) guideline for abstracts and identify the characteristics associated with better reporting quality. SOURCES: PubMed was searched for RCT abstracts published from 2001 to 2007 (pre-CONSORT period) and from 2010 to 2016 (post-CONSORT period) in six leading prosthodontic journals. STUDY SELECTION: After applying the inclusion/exclusion criteria, 131 RCT abstracts were selected. The t test was performed to compare the overall quality between the two periods. Univariable and multivariable linear regressions were used to identify any factors relating to the reporting quality. The level of significance was set at P < 0.05. DATA: The investigators extracted data and scored the abstracts independently based on CONSORT. The mean overall CONSORT score was 5.20 and 6.11 in the pre- and post-CONSORT samples, respectively. Significant changes were observed in reporting for only three items: title, conclusions, and trial registration. Most abstracts adequately reported interventions, objectives, and conclusions (>90%), but failed to report recruitment and outcome in the results section (<3%). Funding was not reported in both periods. The reporting quality was related to a higher impact factor, structured format, and published after CONSORT. CONCLUSIONS: The quality of RCT abstracts in prosthodontics improved over time, but adherence to the CONSORT guideline for abstracts was still suboptimal.
引用
- Chen J, Li Z, Liu B, et al. Quality improvement in randomized controlled trial abstracts in prosthodontics since the publication of CONSORT guideline for abstracts: a systematic review. J Dent. 2018. PMID: 29742449. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2018.04.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。