文献速递口腔修复与种植

自由手、先锋钻导板与全导板种植手术精度随机对照研究

A randomized controlled study on the accuracy of free-handed, pilot-drill guided and fully guided implant surgery in partially edentulous patients.
PubMed 文献 · J Clin Periodontol · 2018-05-10

本研究将需在后上颌植入≥2颗种植体的部分缺牙患者随机分为自由手(FH)、先锋钻导板(PG)和全导板(FG)三组,比较实际种植体位置与理想位置的偏差。结果显示FG手术最精确(平均AGD 0.97 mm),PG次之(1.43 mm),FH偏差最大(2.11 mm);当需要完美种植体定位时,FG手术应被视为金标准。

要点

  • 全导板种植手术精度最高,平均 apical global deviation 为0.97 mm。
  • 自由手种植手术偏差最大,平均 apical global deviation 达2.11 mm。
  • 全导板组无种植体需改为粘接固位,自由手组26颗中5颗需改为粘接固位。

核心结论

  • 当需要完美种植体定位时,全导板(FG)手术应被视为金标准方法。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机对照研究,纳入部分缺牙需在后上颌植入≥2颗种植体的患者,随机分为自由手(FH)、先锋钻导板(PG)和全导板(FG)三组。
  • FH组11例患者(平均年龄57岁,3男8女,共26颗种植体),PG组11例(平均年龄53岁,4男7女,共24颗种植体),FG组10例(平均年龄60岁,4男6女,共21颗种植体)。
  • 主要结局为根尖全局偏差(AGD),次要结局包括角度偏差(AD)、冠部全局偏差(CGD)等。

主要发现

  • FG手术最精确,平均AGD为0.97 mm,最大AGD为1.98 mm。
  • PG手术平均AGD为1.43 mm,最大AGD为2.72 mm。
  • FH手术偏差最大,平均AGD为2.11 mm,最大AGD为4.84 mm。
  • 多数次要结局变量的结果排序与主要结局一致。
  • 尽管所有种植体计划采用螺丝固位修复,FH组26颗中5颗、PG组24颗中1颗不得不改为粘接固位修复。

关键数值与推荐

  • 全导板手术平均AGD 0.97 mm,最大AGD 1.98 mm。
  • 先锋钻导板手术平均AGD 1.43 mm,最大AGD 2.72 mm。
  • 自由手手术平均AGD 2.11 mm,最大AGD 4.84 mm。

临床怎么用

  • 在后上颌部分缺牙患者中,若需精确植入多颗种植体,优先选择全导板手术。
  • 自由手手术偏差较大,可能导致修复方式由螺丝固位改为粘接固位。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To compare the accuracy of free-handed (FH), pilot-drill guided (PG) and fully guided (FG) implant surgery. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Partially edentulous patients in need of ≥2 implants in the posterior maxilla were randomly allocated to one of the following treatment groups: FH, PG and FG. Ideal implant positions were determined in designated software following the fusion of bony information (CBCT data in DICOM format) to the prosthetic wax-up (optical scan data in STL format). The position of every implant as surgically realized was compared to its "ideal position". The apical global deviation (AGD) was the primary outcome of the study. Secondary outcome variables were angular deviation (AD), coronal global deviation (CGD), coronal lateral deviation (CLD), coronal vertical deviation (CVD), apical lateral deviation (ALD) and apical vertical deviation (AVD). RESULTS: Eleven patients (mean age 57; three males; eight females; altogether 26 implants) were treated by FH surgery, 11 (mean age 53; four males; seven females; altogether 24 implants) by PG surgery and 10 (mean age 60; four males; six females; altogether 21 implants) by FG surgery. FG surgery was most accurate (mean AGD: 0.97 mm; maximum AGD: 1.98 mm) followed by PG surgery (mean AGD: 1.43 mm; maximum AGD: 2.72 mm). FH surgery resulted in huge deviation from the ideal position (mean AGD: 2.11 mm; maximum AGD: 4.84 mm). The results on most secondary outcome variables followed the same order. Although screw-retained restorations were planned for all implants, five of 26 in the FH group and one of 24 in the PG group had to be restored by means of a cement-retained restoration. CONCLUSION: When perfect implant positioning is required, FG surgery should be considered the gold standard approach.

来源:J Clin Periodontol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Younes F, Cosyn J, De Bruyckere T, et al. A randomized controlled study on the accuracy of free-handed, pilot-drill guided and fully guided implant surgery in partially edentulous patients. J Clin Periodontol. 2018. PMID: 29608793. doi:10.1111/jcpe.12897

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。