部分口记录方案下牙周病错误分类机制评估
基于VA牙科纵向研究640名参与者的数据,以CDC/AAP牙周炎定义为全口参考标准,评估不同部分口记录(PMR)方案的敏感性和特异性。结果显示PMR方案下疾病分类敏感性取决于观察牙数和位点数及病例定义,修正病例定义可提高敏感性但降低特异性。PMR错误分类非随机,优化敏感性会以严重程度均值偏倚为代价。
要点
- PMR方案敏感性取决于观察牙数、位点数及所用病例定义。
- 修正病例定义以适应PMR观察牙数减少可提高敏感性但降低特异性。
- PMR错误分类非随机,优化敏感性伴随严重程度均值偏倚。
核心结论
- PMR方案对牙周病的错误分类并非随机,即使观察位点为随机选取。
- PMR方案可被选择或修改以最大化敏感性,但会以严重程度均值测量偏倚为代价。
研究设计与样本
- 基于VA牙科纵向研究640名参与者的数据,比较牙特异性和位点特异性临床测量。
- 以CDC/AAP牙周炎定义为全口参考标准,计算不同PMR方案的敏感性和特异性。
主要发现
- 在该队列中,牙周炎表现为泛发性疾病,临床严重程度测量不因位点、口腔象限或颌骨而存在有意义差异。
- PMR方案下疾病分类的敏感性是观察牙数和位点数及所应用病例定义的函数。
- 当修正病例定义以考虑PMR方案观察牙数较少时,敏感性增加但特异性降低。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用CDC/AAP牙周炎定义作为全口参考标准。
- 评估了考虑观察牙数减少的PMR替代病例定义。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择PMR方案时需权衡敏感性与严重程度均值偏倚。
- 可修正PMR病例定义以适应观察牙数减少,但需注意特异性下降。
局限性
- 基于VA牙科纵向研究队列,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To evaluate the assumptions underlying the use of partial-mouth recording (PMR) protocols and the associated mechanisms of potential misclassification of periodontal disease. METHODS: Using data from 640 participants in the VA Dental Longitudinal Study, we compared tooth-specific and site-specific clinical measures and calculated sensitivity and specificity of different PMR protocols by applying the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in collaboration with the American Academy of Periodontology definitions for periodontitis as the full-mouth reference standard. Additionally, we evaluated alternative case definitions for PMR protocols that accounted for the reduction in numbers of teeth under observation. RESULTS: In this cohort, periodontitis presented as a generalized condition in that measures of clinical severity did not differ meaningfully according to site measured, oral quadrant or jaw. Sensitivity of disease classification under PMR protocols was a function of the number of teeth and sites under observation and the case definition applied. Sensitivity increased when case definitions were modified to account for the smaller number of teeth under observation with PMR protocols. However, specificity was reduced. CONCLUSIONS: Misclassification of periodontal disease by PMR protocols is not random, even if sites under observation are randomly selected. PMR protocols can be selected/modified to maximize sensitivity, but they do so at the expense of bias in mean measures of severity.
引用
- Heaton B, Sharma P, Garcia RI, et al. Evaluating periodontal disease misclassification mechanisms under partial-mouth recording protocols. J Clin Periodontol. 2018. PMID: 29385644. doi:10.1111/jcpe.12874
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。