近红外透照与高动态范围成像检测邻面龋
本研究建立体外模型验证近红外透照(NIRT)检测邻面龋,并用高动态范围成像(HDRI)增强NIRT,以微计算机断层扫描(µCT)为参考标准比较两种方法。53颗健康或龋坏恒牙的邻面经Diagnocam(DC)和NIRT-HDRI检查,由2名训练有素的检查者两次评估。NIRT-HDRI对健康表面和釉质龋敏感性更高,对牙本质龋特异性更高,但HDRI未显著改善诊断。
要点
- NIRT-HDRI对健康表面和釉质龋的敏感性高于DC,对牙本质龋的特异性更高。
- HDRI可扩大亮度范围、减少曝光过度或不足,但未显著提升诊断准确性。
- NIRT难以区分已处理的脱矿釉质与牙本质病变,HDRI无法弥补此局限。
核心结论
- NIRT-HDRI在检测健康表面和釉质龋时敏感性高于DC,在牙本质龋时特异性更高。
- HDRI虽改善图像亮度范围,但未显著提升诊断性能。
- 区分脱矿釉质与牙本质病变是NIRT的固有难题,HDRI无法解决。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,纳入53颗健康或龋坏恒牙,检查其邻面。
- 以µCT为参考标准,比较Diagnocam(DC)与NIRT-HDRI。
- 2名训练有素检查者两次评估,计算Kappa统计量。
主要发现
- 检查者间信度(加权Kappa)DC为0.90,NIRT-HDRI为0.96。
- DC与NIRT-HDRI总体一致性(加权Kappa)为0.85。
- 各分类(0至4)简单Kappa从几乎完美(分类4)到中等(分类1和2)再到显著(分类0和3)。
- 健康表面、釉质龋和牙本质龋的敏感性和特异性范围为0.57至0.99,两种方法在不同分类中相似。
- NIRT-HDRI对健康表面和釉质龋敏感性更高,对牙本质龋特异性更高。
临床怎么用
- NIRT-HDRI可作为邻面龋检测的辅助手段,尤其对釉质龋敏感性较高。
- HDRI图像可提供更宽亮度范围的细节,但不应期望其显著提高诊断准确性。
- 对脱矿釉质与牙本质病变的鉴别需谨慎,NIRT可能难以区分。
局限性
- 本研究为体外研究,结果需临床验证。
- 样本量为53颗牙,可能限制统计效力。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The purpose of this study was to develop an in vitro model for the validation of near-infrared transillumination (NIRT) for proximal caries detection, to enhance NIRT with high-dynamic-range imaging (HDRI), and to compare both methods, using micro-computed tomography (µCT) as a reference standard. Both proximal surfaces of 53 healthy or decayed permanent human teeth were examined using the Diagnocam (DC) (KaVo) and NIRT with HDRI (NIRT-HDRI). NIRT was combined with HDRI to improve the diagnostic performance by reducing under- and overexposed image areas. For NIRT-HDRI, an exposure series was captured and merged into a single HDR image. A classification was applied according to lesion depth. All surfaces were assessed twice by 2 trained examiners, and additionally with µCT for validation. The Kappa statistic was used to calculate inter-rater reliability and agreement between DC and NIRT-HDRI. Inter-rater reliability (weighted Kappa, wκ) showed very good agreement for the DC (0.90) and NIRT-HDRI (0.96). The overall agreement (wκ) was almost perfect (0.85). In the individual categories (0 to 4), the agreement (simple Kappa) ranged from almost perfect (category 4) to moderate (1 and 2) to substantial (categories 0 and 3). Sensitivity and specificity of sound surfaces, enamel, and dentin caries ranged from 0.57 to 0.99 and were similar for both methods in the different categories. NIRT-HDRI had a higher sensitivity for sound surfaces and enamel caries, as well as a higher specificity for dentin caries. Regarding the obtained images, HDRI allowed for the detection of caries within a greater range of luminance levels, resulting in a more detailed visualization of structures without under- or overexposure. However, HDRI this did not improve the diagnostics significantly. Distinguishing between a processed demineralized enamel and dentin lesions appears to be a problem specific to NIRT and cannot be balanced using HDRI.
引用
- Lederer A, Kunzelmann KH, Hickel R, et al. Transillumination and HDR Imaging for Proximal Caries Detection. J Dent Res. 2018. PMID: 29481761. doi:10.1177/0022034518759957
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。