根管冲洗剂与药物在牙髓病医疗过失案例中的作用:全国纵向观察
该研究基于芬兰患者保险中心2002-2006年(n=521)和2011-2013年(n=449)验证的牙髓病损伤案例,分析根管冲洗剂和药物的作用。共970例损伤中,69例(7.1%)与冲洗剂/药物相关,全部由次氯酸钠和氢氧化钙引起,其中87%可避免。次氯酸钠/氢氧化钙损伤总体发生率为每年每10万牙髓病患者4.3例,且2011-2013年较2002-2006年风险增加5倍以上(OR=5.6)。
要点
- 次氯酸钠和氢氧化钙相关损伤占验证牙髓病损伤的7.1%,87%可避免。
- 次氯酸钠/氢氧化钙损伤总体发生率为每年每10万牙髓病患者4.3例。
- 2011-2013年较2002-2006年次氯酸钠/氢氧化钙损伤风险增加5倍以上(OR=5.6)。
核心结论
- 次氯酸钠和氢氧化钙相关损伤在牙髓病医疗过失中占7.1%,且87%可避免,应用时需极度谨慎。
研究设计与样本
- 研究材料包括芬兰患者保险中心2002-2006年验证的全部牙髓病损伤(n=521)和2011-2013年验证的全部牙髓病损伤(n=449),由2名牙髓病专家审查患者文档。
主要发现
- 验证损伤共970例,其中635例(65%)可避免,335例(35%)不可避免。
- 冲洗剂/药物相关损伤69例,占全部验证损伤的7.1%,全部由次氯酸钠和氢氧化钙引起,87%可避免。
- 次氯酸钠/氢氧化钙损伤总体发生率为每年每10万牙髓病患者4.3例。
- 与其他损伤相比,次氯酸钠/氢氧化钙损伤更可能可避免(OR=3.8),且2011-2013年较2002-2006年风险增加5倍以上(OR=5.6)。
临床怎么用
- 在根管内使用次氯酸钠和氢氧化钙时应极度谨慎,以避免增加有害后果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The aim of this study was to assess the role of root canal irrigants and medicaments in endodontic injuries verified in Finland and to estimate the rate of such events over time. METHODS: The study material comprised all endodontic injuries verified by the Patient Insurance Centre in 2002 to 2006 (n = 521) and 2011 to 2013 (n = 449). The data, based on patient documents scrutinized by 2 specialists in endodontics, included patients' and dentists' sex and age and the service sector. We recorded the use of root canal irrigants and medicaments, each as a dichotomy. Furthermore, we dichotomized the injuries as those related to root canal irrigants/medicaments and any other injuries. The injuries were also dichotomized as avoidable (could have been avoided by following good clinical practice) or unavoidable (normal treatment-related risks). Statistical evaluation used chi-square tests and t tests; logistic regression produced odds ratios (ORs). RESULTS: The verified injuries (N = 970) comprised 635 (65%) avoidable and 335 (35%) unavoidable injuries. The number of irrigant-/medicament-related injuries was 69, accounting for 7.1% of all verified injuries; all resulted from sodium hypochlorite and calcium hydroxide, and 87% were avoidable. The overall rate of sodium hypochlorite/calcium hydroxide injuries was 4.3 cases per 100,000 endodontic patients per year. Compared with other injuries, sodium hypochlorite/calcium hydroxide injuries were more likely avoidable (OR = 3.8) and more than 5-fold likely in 2011 to 2013 than in 2002 to 2006 (OR = 5.6). CONCLUSIONS: Extreme care is needed when applying sodium hypochlorite and calcium hydroxide into root canals to avoid increasing harmful consequences.
引用
- Swanljung O, Vehkalahti MM. Root Canal Irrigants and Medicaments in Endodontic Malpractice Cases: A Nationwide Longitudinal Observation. J Endod. 2018. PMID: 29459149. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2018.01.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。