文献速递牙体牙髓病

牙髓治疗抗生素处方:英国卡迪夫牙科学生与执业牙医比较调查

Antibiotic prescribing for endodontic therapies: a comparative survey between general dental practitioners and final year Bachelor of Dental Surgery students in Cardiff, UK.
PubMed 文献 · Int Endod J · 2018-02-08

该横断面在线问卷调查研究了卡迪夫大学76名牙科五年级学生和卡迪夫地区55家牙科诊所的执业牙医,比较其对牙髓疾病抗生素处方的认知与选择。结果显示学生均知晓抗生素过度使用的后果,约60%知晓相关指南,临床情景应答总体符合理想答案;执业牙医仅28%知晓指南,对过度使用后果认知较低,部分应答不符合指南。

要点

  • 牙科五年级学生均知晓抗生素过度使用后果,但约三分之一不知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南。
  • 执业牙医仅28%知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南,对过度使用后果认知低于学生。
  • 学生在急性根尖脓肿情景中64%认为需用抗生素,与理想答案有差距。

核心结论

  • 牙科五年级学生知晓抗生素耐药危机,但约三分之一不知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南,其临床情景应答总体符合指南。
  • 执业牙医对过度使用抗生素的后果及指南存在认知不足,部分临床情景应答与牙髓治疗抗生素指南不符。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面在线问卷调查研究,问卷含12个定性与定量问题。
  • 调查对象为卡迪夫大学76名牙科五年级学生和英国卡迪夫地区55家牙科诊所的执业牙医。
  • 问卷含6个一般信息问题及一系列假设临床情景,询问是否处方抗生素。
  • 数据分析使用SPSS第23版,进行描述性统计、列联表、卡方检验、Fisher精确检验和相对风险计算。
  • 应答率为60%(n=79)。

主要发现

  • 所有牙科五年级学生均知晓抗生素过度使用的后果;约60%的应答者知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南;83%仅对有限患者(如伴全身并发症者)使用抗生素。
  • 牙科五年级学生对临床情景的应答总体与理想答案相当,但急性根尖脓肿情景中64%认为需用抗生素。
  • 多数执业牙医知晓抗生素过度使用后果,但仅28%知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南。
  • 执业牙医的应答显示抗生素处方比例为:全身并发症78%、急性根尖脓肿72%、有症状性根尖周炎28%。
  • 临床情景显示牙科五年级学生相比执业牙医,在无全身并发症的坏死牙髓伴症状性根尖周炎(错误答案)更可能处方抗生素,而在其他情景(如风湿热史的无症状根尖周炎、症状性不可逆/可逆性牙髓炎、麻醉失败、糖尿病患者的慢性根尖脓肿)更少处方;执业牙医对扩散感染征象的抗生素处方认知更明显。

关键数值与推荐

  • 约60%的应答者知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南。
  • 83%的应答者仅对有限患者(如伴全身并发症者)使用抗生素。
  • 执业牙医中仅28%知晓牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南。
  • 执业牙医抗生素处方比例:全身并发症78%、急性根尖脓肿72%、有症状性根尖周炎28%。
  • 牙科五年级学生在急性根尖脓肿情景中64%认为抗生素有指征。

临床怎么用

  • 口腔科智能体应提示牙医关注并遵循牙髓治疗抗生素使用指南,减少不必要处方。
  • 对无全身并发症的坏死牙髓伴症状性根尖周炎等情景,应避免错误处方抗生素。
  • 对伴全身并发症、扩散感染等情景,应识别抗生素使用指征并合理处方。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIM: To evaluate the views of final year dental surgery students (BDS; G1) at Cardiff University and general dental practitioners (GDPs; G2) within the geographic area of Cardiff, Wales, on antibiotic prescribing for endodontic conditions, and investigate the potential differences between the two groups. METHODS: A cross-sectional online questionnaire-based survey of 12 qualitative and quantitative questions was distributed to 76 final year BDS Cardiff University students and 55 dental practices within Cardiff, UK. Six questions recorded general information, and the remaining questions included a series of hypothetical clinical scenarios, where the participants were asked to state whether they would or would not prescribe antibiotics. The data were analysed using spss version 23 to produce descriptive statistics, contingency tables and to run chi-square (χ²) tests, Fisher's exact tests and relative risk calculations. RESULTS: The response rate was 60% (n = 79). All G1 participants were aware of the consequences of antibiotic overuse. Approximately 60% of responders were aware of guidelines for antibiotic use in endodontic therapies, and 83% would only use antibiotics for a limited selection of patients (e.g. patients with systemic complications). G1 responses to clinical scenarios indicated overall that they were comparable to the ideal answers except for acute apical abscess (64% believed that antibiotics were indicated). The majority of G2 were aware of the consequences of antibiotic overuse. Only 28% of G2 were aware of guidelines for antibiotic use in endodontic therapies. Overall responses revealed that antibiotics would be prescribed for: systemic complications (78%), acute apical abscess (72%) and symptomatic apical periodontitis (28%). The clinical scenarios revealed G1 were more likely to prescribe antibiotics compared to G2 for cases of necrotic pulp with symptomatic apical periodontitis without systemic complications (incorrect answer) and less likely to other clinical scenarios such as necrotic pulp and asymptomatic apical periodontitis for patients with a history of rheumatic fever (ideal answers), symptomatic irreversible/reversible pulpitis, failure to achieve anaesthesia, chronic apical abscess for patients with diabetes. The recognition of antibiotic prescription for cases with signs of spreading infection was more evident in G2. CONCLUSION: Final year undergraduate students were aware of the antibiotic resistance crisis, although a third was not aware of guidelines for use of antibiotics in endodontic conditions; their responses to clinical scenario were generally compatible with the guidelines. General dentists were less aware of the implications of overuse of antibiotics and the existence of guidelines, and their responses were occasionally incompatible with antibiotic guidelines for endodontic therapies.

来源:Int Endod J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Al Masan AA, Dummer PMH, Farnell DJJ, et al. Antibiotic prescribing for endodontic therapies: a comparative survey between general dental practitioners and final year Bachelor of Dental Surgery students in Cardiff, UK. Int Endod J. 2018. PMID: 29319894. doi:10.1111/iej.12887

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。