文献速递牙体牙髓病

不同执业群体对牙髓治疗失败病例治疗计划决策的7年长期评估

Long-term Evaluation of Treatment Planning Decisions for Nonhealing Endodontic Cases by Different Groups of Practitioners.
PubMed 文献 · J Endod · 2017-12-16

该研究对宾夕法尼亚州牙医进行网络调查,2009年纳入262名参与者(76.7%为全科牙医),2016年对其中104人重测,评估对根尖周炎且曾行牙髓治疗牙齿的治疗计划选择。结果显示群体层面治疗选择无显著时间变化,但个体决策一致性低(改变原决策概率47.8%,95%CI 45.2%-50.4%),且不同执业群体间差异显著。

要点

  • 群体层面7年间保牙与拔牙替换的治疗计划选择无显著变化(P=.520)。
  • 个体层面决策一致性低,改变原决策的概率为47.8%(95%CI 45.2%-50.4%)。
  • 不同执业群体改变决策的倾向存在显著差异(全科>其他专科>牙髓专科,P<.05)。

核心结论

  • 在群体层面,牙髓再治疗保牙与拔牙后修复/种植的决策在7年间无显著变化(P=.520)。
  • 个体执业者的治疗计划决策随时间缺乏一致性,近半数会改变原决策。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于网络的问卷调查,2009年向宾夕法尼亚州牙医发放14个非愈合根尖周病变且修复体完整无继发龋的病例。
  • 2009年共262名牙医参与:全科牙医201名(76.7%)、牙髓专科医师26名(9.9%)、其他专科医师35名(13.4%)。
  • 2016年对2009年参与者重测同一问卷,104人完成(占原参与者39.7%):全科69名(66.3%)、牙髓专科15名(14.0%)、其他专科20名(19.7%)。

主要发现

  • 2009年全样本中,拔牙种植、非手术再治疗和手术再治疗被选择的比例大致相当,但不同执业群体间差异显著(χ2=173.49,P<.05)。
  • 104人亚组中,2009年(χ2=95.536,P<.05)和2016年(χ2=109.8889,P<.05)不同执业群体间比较均显著不同。
  • 组内可靠性分析显示,2009年至2016年所有执业者(全科、牙髓、其他专科)的整体治疗计划选择无显著差异。
  • 个体层面决策改变概率为47.8%(95%CI 45.2%-50.4%),且三组间差异显著(全科>其他专科>牙髓专科,χ2=11.2792,P<.05)。
  • 保牙与替换治疗选项的决策无显著变化(P=.520)。

临床怎么用

  • 临床决策中应意识到个体牙医对同类病例的治疗计划可能随时间不一致,需加强决策标准化。
  • 不同执业群体对非愈合牙髓病例的治疗选择偏好存在差异,多学科沟通时可参考此差异。

局限性

  • 仅纳入宾夕法尼亚州牙医,地理范围有限。
  • 2016年重测仅104人完成,占原参与者39.7%,可能存在失访偏倚。
  • 基于问卷的病例选择,非真实临床决策,外推需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: The aim of this study was to investigate changes in treatment planning decisions among different practitioner groups over 7 years for teeth with apical periodontitis and a history of endodontic treatment. METHODS: A Web-based survey was sent to dentists in Pennsylvania in 2009 consisting of 14 cases with nonhealing periapical lesions and intact restorations without evidence of recurrent caries. Participants selected among 5 treatment options: wait and observe, nonsurgical retreatment (NSRTX), surgical retreatment (SRTX), extraction and fixed partial denture, or extraction and implant (EXIMP). In 2016, the identical survey was resent to the original 2009 participants. RESULTS: In 2009, 262 dentists participated in the survey. Two hundred one participants were general practitioners (GPs: 76.7%), 26 endodontists (ENDOs: 9.9%), and 35 other specialists (prosthodontics, periodontics, and oral surgery [SPECs]: 13.4%) (n = 262). EXIMP, NSRTX, and SRTX were fairly equally selected but with great variation between practitioner groups (χ2 = 173.49, P < .05). A subset group of 104 participants (SUB) (39.7% of the original participants) retook the survey in 2016 (69 GPs [66.3%], 15 ENDOs [14.0%], and 20 SPECs [19.7%]). Comparisons among practitioner groups were significantly different in SUB (n = 104) for 2009 (χ2 = 95.536, P < .05) and 2016 (χ2 = 109.8889, P < .05). Intragroup reliability between 2009 and 2016 revealed no significant differences between the overall treatment planning choices for all practitioners (GPs, ENDOs, or SPECs). Intrapractitioner reliability showed many treatment planning decision changes on an individual level. Chances that individuals changed their original decision were 47.8% (95% confidence interval, 45.2%-50.4%) and were significantly different among the 3 practitioner groups (GPs > SPECs > ENDOs [χ2 = 11.2792, P < .05]). No significant changes were observed in the decision for tooth saving versus replacement treatment options (P = .520). CONCLUSIONS: No significant differences were noted between current and past treatment planning decisions in regard to tooth preservation by endodontic retreatment versus tooth extraction and replacement. However, individual practitioners lacked consistency in their decision making over time.

来源:J Endod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Burns LE, Visbal LD, Kohli MR, et al. Long-term Evaluation of Treatment Planning Decisions for Nonhealing Endodontic Cases by Different Groups of Practitioners. J Endod. 2017. PMID: 29254814. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2017.09.004

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。