根管治疗中放射影像指南:系统综述聚焦治疗后复查影像
该研究系统检索并评估了根管治疗后放射学复查影像的指南,使用AGREE II工具评价其质量并分析推荐证据。共纳入7部指南,推荐内容尤其是首次复查影像时机差异较大,多数指南方法学描述不足且部分缺乏证据支持。
要点
- 根管治疗后复查影像的指南推荐不一致,首次复查时机差异明显。
- 多数指南未清晰描述证据获取方法,部分推荐缺乏证据支持。
- 建议指南制定组使用AGREE II工具提升指南质量。
核心结论
- 根管治疗后放射学复查影像的指南推荐存在差异。
- 多数指南对科学证据的获取方法描述不充分。
- 指南制定应参考AGREE II工具以提高质量。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE和EMBASE等数据库及网站,最终检索日期为2016年6月26日。
- 使用AGREE II工具评估指南质量和科学证据。
主要发现
- 7部纳入指南中仅2部使用并清晰描述了获取科学证据的方法。
- 推荐内容存在差异,尤其体现在首次复查放射影像的时机上。
- 部分指南缺乏支持其推荐的证据。
临床怎么用
- 临床参考根管治疗后复查影像指南时需注意推荐差异。
- 应关注指南是否清晰描述证据来源及方法学质量。
局限性
- 多数指南方法学描述不足,影响推荐可靠性。
- 部分指南缺乏证据支持,推荐强度受限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To identify guidelines on endodontics which make recommendations relating to post-root canal treatment radiological review imaging, to make an objective assessment of their quality using the AGREE tool and to examine the evidence cited in support of their recommendations. METHODOLOGY: The primary sources to identify published guidelines were MEDLINE (Ovid® ) and EMBASE. The search aim was to identify guidelines pertaining to the post-root canal treatment follow-up recommendations published from 1946 with the final search date being 26 June 2016. The primary search was supplemented by searching Internet search engines and several websites that might have guidelines. The guidelines obtained from the search end-result were assessed for quality and scientific evidence using the AGREE II instrument. Similarities and differences in the recommendations were identified. RESULTS: Thirty guidelines were identified, seven of which met the inclusion criteria. Two guidelines used and clearly described the methods for obtaining scientific evidence from which the recommendations were set. The recommendations varied, particularly as regards the timing of the first review radiograph. Some guidelines lacked supporting evidence. CONCLUSIONS: The recommendations for post-root canal treatment radiographic follow-up varied amongst the identified guidelines. However, the methodology for obtaining the scientific evidence was poorly described in most of the guidelines. Guideline development groups should use the AGREE II instrument as a guide to produce higher quality guidelines.
引用
- Mahasneh SA, Horner K, Cunliffe J, et al. Guidelines on radiographic imaging as part of root canal treatment: a systematic review with a focus on review imaging after treatment. Int Endod J. 2017. PMID: 28881396. doi:10.1111/iej.12857
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。