全景片对未治疗根尖周炎的诊断准确性
本研究以CBCT为参考标准,评估全景片(OPT)检测临床/手术确认的未治疗根尖周炎(AP)的诊断准确性。纳入120例无牙髓治疗史的AP患者和120例健康对照,结果显示OPT敏感性34.2、特异性95.8、诊断准确性65.0,与CBCT一致性仅为一般(k=0.30),尤其在前牙区准确性差。
要点
- OPT检测未治疗AP的敏感性低(34.2),阴性预测值59.3,诊断准确性65.0。
- OPT特异性高(95.8),阳性预测值89.1,但观察者间信度仅为中等(k=0.71)。
- OPT与CBCT一致性一般(k=0.30),前牙区检出最差,下颌磨牙区最好。
核心结论
- OPT对未治疗根尖周炎具有高特异性和阳性预测值,但总体诊断准确性不足,尤其在前牙区。
研究设计与样本
- 以CBCT为参考标准的诊断准确性研究,纳入120例未经牙髓治疗的AP患者(按病变大小2-4.5 mm和4.6-7 mm及解剖区域分组)和120例健康对照,均先行OPT后40天内行CBCT。
主要发现
- OPT的敏感性为34.2,特异性为95.8,阳性预测值为89.1,阴性预测值为59.3,诊断准确性为65.0。
- OPT观察者间信度k=0.71,OPT与CBCT之间的一致性k=0.30。
- 检出最好的区域为下颌磨牙区,最差的区域为上/下前牙区。
临床怎么用
- OPT特异性高可用于排除未治疗AP,但敏感性低,阴性结果不能可靠排除病变。
- 对于疑似未治疗AP尤其前牙区,建议结合CBCT进一步确认。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of orthopantomography (OPT) for the detection of clinically/surgically confirmed apical periodontitis (AP) without endodontic treatment using cone-beam computed tomographic (CBCT) imaging as the reference standard. METHODS: One hundred twenty patients without endodontically treated AP (diseased group) were detected via CBCT imaging using the periapical index system. They were divided into groups of 10 each according to the size of the lesion (2-4.5 mm and 4.6-7 mm) and the anatomic area (incisor, canine/premolar, and molar) in both the upper and lower arches. Another 120 patients with a healthy root and periapex (healthy group) were selected. Each diseased and healthy patient underwent OPT first and a CBCT scan within 40 days of the OPT. The periapical index system was also used to assess AP by OPT. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, and diagnostic accuracy for OPT images with respect to CBCT imaging were analyzed. The k value was calculated to assess both the interobserver reliability for OPT and the agreement between OPT and CBCT imaging. RESULTS: OPT showed low sensitivity (34.2), negative predictive value (59.3), and diagnostic accuracy (65.0) and high specificity (95.8) and positive predictive value (89.1). Interobserver reliability for OPT was substantial (k = 0.71), and agreement between OPT and CBCT imaging was fair (k = 0.30). The best and worst identified AP were located in the lower molar area and the upper/lower incisor area, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: OPT showed high specificity and positive predictive value. However, overall, it was not an accurate imaging technique for the detection of untreated AP, especially in the incisor area.
引用
- Nardi C, Calistri L, Pradella S, et al. Accuracy of Orthopantomography for Apical Periodontitis without Endodontic Treatment. J Endod. 2017. PMID: 28807372. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2017.06.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。