再生牙髓治疗的临床证据:即刻与延迟诱导的比较
针对年轻患者未成熟恒牙牙髓坏死,设计临床试验比较即刻与延迟血凝块诱导的再生牙髓治疗成功率。延迟组15颗牙按AAE指南用氢氧化钙,即刻组13颗牙首诊诱导血凝块。25例患者(28颗牙)中19颗完成12个月随访,延迟组成功率71%,即刻组33%。作者认为目前下结论尚早,需更多数据。
要点
- 延迟诱导组12个月成功率71%,即刻诱导组33%,但样本量小且未达所需样本量。
- 所有成功病例牙根发育均始于Nolla第9期,多数表现为愈合类型2。
- 创伤是大多数病例(79%)的病因,牙根形成阶段和病因可能是治疗决策的关键因素。
核心结论
- 目前尚不能得出或建议任何一种再生牙髓治疗诱导方案的结论,需要更多数据以满足样本量要求。
研究设计与样本
- 临床试验,将牙髓坏死确诊后的年轻患者随机分组,延迟组15颗牙按美国牙髓病医师协会指南用氢氧化钙作为根管内药物,即刻组13颗牙首诊诱导血凝块。
- 共招募25例患者(28颗牙),其中19颗牙完成12个月随访,由3名独立评估者评估根尖周愈合。
主要发现
- 延迟诱导组成功率为71%,即刻诱导组成功率为33%。
- 大多数病例(79%)的病因是创伤。
- 所有成功病例的牙根发育均始于Nolla第9期,且多数表现为愈合类型2。
关键数值与推荐
- 延迟组15颗牙按美国牙髓病医师协会指南使用氢氧化钙作为根管内药物。
- 即刻组13颗牙在首诊时诱导血凝块。
- 在1、3和12个月时评估牙齿,采用Pearson卡方检验或Fisher精确检验比较两组成功率。
临床怎么用
- 确定牙根形成阶段和病因可能是任何治疗决策的关键因素。
- 鉴于目前证据尚不充分,临床选择即刻或延迟诱导方案时应谨慎,并需更多数据支持。
局限性
- 目前仅19颗牙完成12个月随访,样本量未达到所需样本量要求,结论尚早。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Clinicians face many challenges when treating immature permanent teeth in young patients. Immediate blood clot induction can be a successful option as described by some case reports. No experimental studies or clinical trials have addressed this question. We have designed a clinical trial in which we hypothesized that there is no difference in success between immediate or delayed induction protocols. After confirmation of pulpal necrosis, patients were randomized. In the delayed group, 15 teeth were treated following the American Association of Endodontists guidelines, and calcium hydroxide was used as the intracanal medication. In the immediate group, 13 teeth had a blood clot inducted at the first appointment. The teeth were evaluated after 1, 3, and 12 months. Three independent evaluators assessed the periapical healing. The Pearson chi-square test or the Fisher exact test was used to compare the success rates between the 2 groups. Currently, of the 25 recruited patients (28 teeth), 19 have completed their 12-month follow-up. The group with delayed induction had a 71% success rate, and the group with immediate induction had a 33% success rate. In most cases (79%), trauma was the etiology. All successful cases started at stage 9 of root development (Nolla), and the majority showed healing type 2. Determination of the stage of root formation and etiology are possible critical factors for any therapeutic decision. In summary, it is early to conclude or suggest any of the protocols. Clearly, much more data are needed before sample size requirements can be met.
引用
- Botero TM, Tang X, Gardner R, et al. Clinical Evidence for Regenerative Endodontic Procedures: Immediate versus Delayed Induction? J Endod. 2017. PMID: 28844307. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2017.07.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。