空军牙科服务1960例后牙根管治疗回顾性影像学结局评估
本研究回顾性评估2011年完成的1960例后牙初次根管治疗的影像学结局,比较空军与民用牙医及不同培训背景的疗效。结果显示空军牙医的根尖周病变愈合率(91.5%)高于转诊民用牙医(85.7%),牙髓专科医生生存率最高(94.4%),未额外培训的民用全科牙医最低(78.4%)。遵循循证实践和研究生培训可改善治疗结局。
要点
- 空军牙医根尖周病变愈合率91.5%,高于转诊民用牙医的85.7%。
- 牙髓专科医生生存率94.4%,未额外培训民用全科牙医仅78.4%。
- 充填质量合格率达96.0%,但2.7%的牙尖覆盖修复不合格。
核心结论
- 遵循空军牙科服务循证实践和经认证的研究生培训可改善后牙根管治疗结局。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性影像学分析,评估2011年完成的2262例后牙初次根管治疗,其中1960例符合至少一个评估类别的纳入标准。
主要发现
- 充填质量评估1810例,96.0%合格。
- 牙尖覆盖修复评估1856例,2.7%修复不合格。
- 根尖周病变愈合率:空军牙医91.5%,转诊民用牙医85.7%。
- 生存率:牙髓专科医生94.4%,有额外培训的空军全科牙医95.3%,无额外培训的空军全科牙医87.9%,民用全科牙医78.4%。
- 总体生存率94.1%,随访期最长47个月,平均27个月。
临床怎么用
- 后牙根管治疗应遵循循证标准,包括三维充填、牙尖覆盖修复和橡皮障使用。
- 经认证的研究生培训与更好的治疗结局相关,支持专科培训价值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The Air Force Dental Service has established evidence-based treatment standards for endodontics, including 3-dimensional filling of the canal system, cuspal coverage restoration of endodontically treated posterior teeth, and use of rubber dam. The purpose of this retrospective study was to determine the effect of these standards on outcomes of initial posterior root canal treatments (RCTs) completed by Air Force (AF) and civilian dentists with and without accredited postgraduate training. METHODS: Treatment and follow-up radiographs of AF members who had an initial posterior RCT completed in 2011 were evaluated. A survey of all radiographs was performed to determine the (1) RCT obturation quality, (2) healing of periapical pathosis, and (3) presence and quality of cuspal coverage restorations. RESULTS: A total of 2262 RCTs were examined, with 1960 RCTs meeting inclusion criteria for at least 1 evaluation category. For RCT obturation quality, 1810 RCTs were evaluated, and 96.0% were considered adequate. For cuspal coverage restorations, 1856 RCTs were evaluated, and of these 2.7% were inadequately restored. Healing of periapical pathosis was 91.5% and 85.7% for AF and referred civilian providers, respectively. Survivability was 94.4% for endodontists, 95.3% for AF general dentists with additional training, 87.9% for AF general dentists without additional training, and 78.4% for civilian general dentists. Overall, survivability was 94.1% for a follow-up period ranging up to 47 months, with a mean of 27 months. CONCLUSIONS: In this retrospective, radiographic analysis, evidence-based practices as followed in the Air Force Dental Service and accredited postgraduate training resulted in improved treatment outcomes.
引用
- Ramey K, Yaccino J, Wealleans J, et al. A Retrospective, Radiographic Outcomes Assessment of 1960 Initial Posterior Root Canal Treatments Performed by Endodontists and Dentists. J Endod. 2017. PMID: 28578887. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2017.03.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。