三种钛基台在Straumann组织水平种植体上的种植体-基台连接处微形态差异及体外载荷测试
本研究比较三种市售钛基台(Straumann Variobase、EBI best Duo、Implant Direct)在Straumann RN种植体上的微形态差异,每组5个单元,通过微型CT和扫描电镜观察,其中每组2个单元经2000,000次循环加载(30–300 N,2 Hz)后再次检测。结果显示三种基台存在主要形态差异及紧密接触范围不同,体外加载2百万次未见明显并发症,但存在微形态变化。作者指出结果需在小样本量和特定体外测试设置的局限下解读。
要点
- 三种钛基台在Straumann RN种植体上呈现主要形态差异及紧密接触范围不同。
- 体外2000,000次循环加载(30–300 N,2 Hz)后未见明显并发症,但观察到微形态变化。
- 作者指出结果需在小样本量和特定体外测试设置的局限下解读。
核心结论
- examined implant-abutment units presented with major morphological differences.
- Two million cycles of in vitro loading did not appear to affect the stability of the units despite the micromorphological changes.
- These results need to be interpreted under the limitations of the small sample size and the specific set-up of the in vitro testing.
研究设计与样本
- Three groups of titanium abutments (A: Straumann Variobase n=5, B: EBI best Duo n=5, C: Implant Direct n=5) were torqued on Straumann RN implants according to each manufacturer's instructions.
- Implant-abutment units were scanned with Micro-CT; three units per group were sliced and photographed under Scanning Electron Microscope at 10×–500×.
- Six units (two per group) were restored with cement-retained crowns, subjected to 2000,000 load cycles with loads between 30 and 300 N at 2 Hz, examined through Micro-CT and finally sliced and photographed as described above.
主要发现
- Major morphological differences were identified between the three units, as well as differences in the extent of tight contact in all areas examined.
- Despite the morphological differences, the 2M cycles of loading via in vitro test did not result in any noticeable complications although some changes in the micromorphology were observed.
局限性
- The results need to be interpreted under the limitations of the small sample size and the specific set-up of the in vitro testing.
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to investigate the micromorphological differences among three commercially available titanium abutments on Straumann implants. Furthermore, the possible impact of functional loading on the micromorphology and potential complications was investigated with the use of in vitro testing. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Three groups of Titanium abutments (A: Straumann Variobase n = 5, B: EBI best Duo n = 5, and C: Implant Direct n = 5) were torqued on Straumann RN implants, as according to each of the manufacturer's instructions. The implant-abutment units were scanned with Micro-CT. Three units of each group were directly sliced in the microtome and photographed under different magnifications (10×-500×) through a Scanning Electron Microscope. Six units (two from each group) were restored with cement-retained crowns, subjected to 2000,000 load cycles with loads between 30 and 300 N at 2 Hz, examined through Micro-CT and finally sliced and photographed as described above. The micromorphology of each unit was studied, and the total length of tight contact (<3 μm) was calculated between the implant, abutment and screw contact areas. RESULTS: Major morphological differences were identified between the three units, as well as differences in the extent of tight contact in all areas examined. Despite the morphological differences, the 2M cycles of loading via in vitro test did not result in any noticeable complications although some changes in the micromorphology were observed. CONCLUSION: The examined implant-abutment units presented with major morphological differences. Two million cycles of in vitro loading did not appear to affect the stability of the units despite the micromorphological changes. These results need to be interpreted however under the limitations of the small sample size and the specific set-up of the in vitro testing.
引用
- Mattheos N, Larsson C, Ma L, et al. Micromorphological differences of the implant-abutment junction and in vitro load testing for three different titanium abutments on Straumann tissue level implants. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2017. PMID: 28397298. doi:10.1111/clr.13021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。