慢性牙周炎非手术治疗临床实践指南纳入研究的网络Meta分析
该网络Meta分析基于临床实践指南中74项研究的36项间接比较,比较了九种辅助治疗在临床附着水平获得上的差异。结果显示所有辅助治疗两两之间差异的置信区间均较宽,无统计学显著优势; publication bias明显,小效应研究少于预期,使治疗效应被高估约20%。与单纯刮治和根面平整相比,辅助治疗在6-12个月内使临床附着水平获得增加约三分之一毫米。
要点
- 九种辅助治疗之间两两比较均无统计学显著差异,置信区间宽。
- 发表偏倚使观察到的治疗效应被高估约20%。
核心结论
- 与单纯SRP相比,辅助治疗在6-12个月内使CAL获得增加约三分之一毫米,但各辅助治疗之间无显著差异。
- CAL是临床医生测量的物理指标而非患者导向结局,该获得对患者感知的益处尚不明确。
- 发表偏倚使观察到的治疗效应被高估。
研究设计与样本
- 基于临床实践指南中74项研究的九种辅助治疗,进行星形网络Meta分析,包含36项间接比较。
主要发现
- 所有两两差异均伴有宽置信区间,没有任何辅助治疗显著优于另一种。
- 局部多西环素hyclate和二极管激光光动力疗法分别具有排名第一和第二的最高概率。
- 发表偏倚明显,小效应研究少于预期,这些研究的缺乏使治疗效应估计被高估约20%。
局限性
- 所有两两差异均伴有宽置信区间。
- 发表偏倚明显,小效应研究少于预期,使治疗效应被高估约20%。
- CAL是临床医生测量的物理指标而非患者导向结局,患者感知的益处尚不明确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: The recent ADA-commissioned Clinical Practice Guideline on the nonsurgical treatment of chronic periodontitis has provided the most exhaustive library of clinical trials on scaling and root planing (SRP) with or without adjuncts. This network meta-analysis (NMA) compared the adjuncts against each other. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A star-shaped NMA was performed based on 36 indirect comparisons of clinical attachment-level (CAL) gains among nine adjuncts in 74 studies from the Clinical Practice Guideline. RESULTS: All pairwise differences were accompanied by wide confidence intervals, and none of the adjuncts were statistically significantly superior to another. Local doxycycline hyclate and photodynamic therapy with a diode laser had the highest probabilities for ranking first and second, respectively. Publication bias was evident, with fewer than expected studies with small effects. The lack of these studies inflated the treatment effects by an estimated by 20%. CONCLUSIONS: Adjuncts improve CAL gain by about a third of a mm over 6-12 months compared with SRP alone, but no significant differences were found among the adjuncts. The patient-perceived benefit of this gain is unclear because CAL is a physical measure made by the clinician and not a patient-oriented outcome. Publication bias inflated the observed treatment effects.
引用
- John MT, Michalowicz BS, Kotsakis GA, et al. Network meta-analysis of studies included in the Clinical Practice Guideline on the nonsurgical treatment of chronic periodontitis. J Clin Periodontol. 2017. PMID: 28370333. doi:10.1111/jcpe.12726
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。