不同种植体角度下种植体支持覆盖义齿的固位:Locator与球帽附着体的比较
本研究通过体外模拟疲劳5.5年(相当于10,000次义齿摘戴循环),比较Locator与球帽附着体在平行(0°)和发散(20°)种植体角度下的固位力变化。结果显示两种附着体在两种角度下固位力均显著下降;种植体角度变化仅使球帽附着体固位力显著降低,但测试结束时球帽附着体固位力仍高于Locator;Locator在两种角度下固位力丧失速率均显著更快。
要点
- 模拟疲劳后,Locator与球帽附着体在平行和发散角度下固位力均显著下降。
- 种植体角度变化仅使球帽附着体固位力显著降低,但终末固位力仍高于Locator。
- Locator在两种角度下固位力丧失速率均显著快于球帽附着体。
核心结论
- 两种附着体在平行和发散角度下经模拟疲劳后固位力均显著下降。
- 种植体角度变化仅使球帽附着体固位力显著降低,但测试结束时球帽附着体固位力仍高于Locator。
- Locator在两种角度下固位力丧失速率均显著更快。
- 作者认为,临床上这可能提示球帽附着体在发散种植体情况下表现可能更好。
研究设计与样本
- 体外研究,构建两个测试模型(模型1和模型2)模拟双种植体下颌覆盖义齿设计,使用丙烯酸树脂块支撑种植体替代体。
- 种植体替代体置于尖牙区,种植体间距22 mm;模型1种植体平行(与垂直轴成0°),模型2种植体发散(与垂直轴成20°)。
- 在两种模型上测试Locator和球帽附着体系统,模拟疲劳5.5年,相当于10,000次义齿摘戴循环。
- 固位值在基线、每500次循环至4000次循环、之后每1000次循环测量。
主要发现
- 模拟疲劳后,Locator系统在平行模型下固位力从108.9 N降至20.2 N,在发散模型下从82.3 N降至17.3 N。
- 球帽系统在平行模型下固位力从56.2 N降至46 N,在发散模型下从45.7 N降至40.7 N。
- 种植体角度变化仅使球帽附着体固位力显著降低,但测试结束时球帽附着体固位力仍高于Locator。
- Locator在两种模型下固位力丧失速率均显著更快。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,临床上这可能提示球帽附着体在发散种植体情况下表现可能更好。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the effect of implant angulation on the retention of two different attachment systems for implant-supported overdentures after a simulated fatigue period of 5.5 years. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Two test set-ups were constructed. A two-implant mandibular implant-supported overdenture design was simulated using acrylic resin blocks to support implant replicas (Model 1 and Model 2). The replicas were set up in the canine regions (22-mm inter-implant distance). In Model 1, the implants were parallel (0° to the vertical axis) and in Model 2 they were divergent (20° to the vertical axis). The Locator and the ball attachment systems were tested at both set-ups. A simulated fatigue period of 5.5 years that equated to 10,000 cycles of insertion and removal of the denture was used. Retention values for each attachment system at each angulation set-up were measured at baseline, every 500 cycles until 4000 cycles and then every 1000 cycles. RESULTS: After simulated fatigue, the retention for both systems at both set-ups reduced. The Locator system reduced from 108.9 to 20.2 N in the parallel set-up and from 82.3 to 17.3 N in the divergent set-up. For the ball system, the retention reduced from 56.2 to 46 N when parallel and from 45.7 to 40.7 N when divergent. CONCLUSION: Both attachment systems showed a significant reduction in retention after simulated fatigue at both parallel and divergent set-ups. The change in implant angulation caused a significant reduction in retention for the ball attachment system only, although this was still higher at the end of testing than the Locator attachment system. The Locators also had a significantly faster rate of loss of retention at both set-ups. Clinically, this may indicate that the ball attachments may perform better with divergent implants.
引用
- Sultana N, Bartlett DW, Suleiman M, et al. Retention of implant-supported overdentures at different implant angulations: comparing Locator and ball attachments. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2017. PMID: 28191678. doi:10.1111/clr.13003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。