二硅酸锂(Empress 2)牙支持冠、种植支持冠与固定局部义齿的十年生存率及并发症率
该前瞻性研究纳入73例患者共184个二硅酸锂(IPS Empress 2)修复体,最终分析87个牙支持冠、17个种植支持冠和27个固定局部义齿。10年生存率牙支持冠86.1%、种植支持冠93.8%、固定局部义齿51.9%,种植支持冠与牙支持冠生存率均显著高于固定局部义齿,无崩瓷率组间差异未达显著。
要点
- 二硅酸锂牙支持冠10年生存率86.1%,略低于单冠通常预期。
- 种植支持冠10年生存率93.8%、无崩瓷率94.1%,结局良好。
- 固定局部义齿10年生存率仅51.9%,失败占主导。
核心结论
- 牙支持冠的结局略低于单冠通常可预期的水平;种植支持冠结局良好;固定局部义齿以失败为主。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,1997年至1999年间在73例患者中放置184个二硅酸锂(IPS Empress 2)修复体,包括106个牙支持冠、32个种植支持冠、33个固定局部义齿和13个其他修复体。
- 最终数据集包括87个牙支持冠(37例患者,平均观察时间11.4±3.8年)、17个种植支持冠(12例患者,平均观察时间13.3±2.3年)和27个固定局部义齿(19例患者,平均观察时间8.9±5.4年)。
主要发现
- 10年生存率/无崩瓷率:牙支持冠86.1%/83.4%,种植支持冠93.8%/94.1%,固定局部义齿51.9%/90.8%。
- 种植支持冠与固定局部义齿生存率比较:两项检验均p=0.001;牙支持冠与固定局部义齿生存率比较:p=0.001和p=0.005。
- 无崩瓷率组间差异未达统计学显著。
- 粘接方式(粘接 vs. 传统粘固)及修复体位置(前牙 vs. 后牙)对生存率均无影响。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To prospectively evaluate the clinical long-term outcome of tooth-supported crowns (SCs), implant-supported crowns (ISCs), and fixed dental prostheses (FDPs) made of a lithium-disilicate glass-ceramic framework material (IPS Empress 2). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Between 1997 and 1999, a total of 184 restorations (106 SCs, 32 ISCs, 33 FDPs, and 13 diverse restorations) were placed in 73 patients. Kaplan-Meier estimation was applied for survival and chipping-free rates. Inter-group comparison of both rates was realized by a log rank test and a 2×2 contingency table. Also, SCs and FDPs were compared regarding adhesive vs. conventional cementation, and anterior vs. posterior positioning, for impact on survival. RESULTS: Due to 14 dropouts (34 restorations) and reasonable exclusion of 19 other restorations, the final dataset included: i) 87 SCs [37 patients, mean observation time 11.4 (±3.8)years]; ii) 17 ISCs [12 patients, mean observation time 13.3 (±2.3)years; and iii) 27 FDPs [19 patients, mean observation time 8.9 (±5.4)years]. The 10-year survival rate/chipping-free rate for SCs were 86.1%/83.4%, for ISCs 93.8%/94.1%, and for FDPs were 51.9%/90.8%. Both ISCs and SCs had a significantly higher survival than FDPs (ISCs vs. FDPs: both tests p=0.001; SCs vs. FDPs: p=0.001 and p=0.005). Differences in the chipping-free rates did not reach significance. Also, neither the cementation mode nor positioning of the restoration had an impact on survival. CONCLUSIONS: SCs had a slightly lower outcome than can generally be expected from single crowns. In contrast, ICSs had a favorable outcome and the FDPs predominantly failed. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The practitioner's choice of dental materials is based (at best) on long-term experience. The present 10-year results are based on comprehensive data analyses and show the high potential of lithium-disilicate as a reliable material, especially for single-unit restoration.
引用
- Teichmann M, Göckler F, Weber V, et al. Ten-year survival and complication rates of lithium-disilicate (Empress 2) tooth-supported crowns, implant-supported crowns, and fixed dental prostheses. J Dent. 2016. PMID: 27984088. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2016.10.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。