根面龋预防治疗的成本效果分析
本研究采用马尔可夫模型模拟患者10年,比较无治疗、每日225-800ppm氟漱口、氯己定涂漆(每年2次)、二胺氟化银涂漆(每年2次)四种根面龋预防策略,基于系统评价网络Meta分析推断相对效力,以2016年德国医疗体系混合支付方视角估算成本,健康结局为无根面龋牙年。在16颗患牙且牙水平风险低的人群中,无治疗成本最低(130欧元)但效果最差(144牙年),二胺氟化银涂漆成本较高(180欧元)但效果更好(151牙年),支付方愿为每无根面龋牙年投入8.30欧元时二胺氟化银涂漆最具成本效果,氯己定涂漆和氟漱口不具成本效果;在患牙更多且牙水平风险高的人群中,二胺氟化银涂漆效果最好且成本最低。
要点
- 在16颗患牙且牙水平风险低的人群中,无治疗成本130欧元、144牙年,二胺氟化银涂漆成本180欧元、151牙年。
- 支付方愿为每无根面龋牙年投入8.30欧元时,二胺氟化银涂漆最具成本效果,氯己定涂漆和氟漱口不具成本效果。
- 在患牙更多且牙水平风险高的人群中,二胺氟化银涂漆效果最好且成本最低。
核心结论
- 根面龋预防治疗(如二胺氟化银涂漆)有效,在高风险人群中甚至可能节省成本。
研究设计与样本
- 采用马尔可夫模型对患者进行10年模拟,比较无治疗、每日225-800ppm氟漱口、氯己定涂漆(每年2次)、二胺氟化银涂漆(每年2次)四种策略。
- 数据来自系统评价并提交网络Meta分析以推断相对效力,采用2016年德国医疗体系混合公私支付方视角,成本从费用项目目录或市场价格估算。
- 模拟了不同牙齿数量和牙水平风险的人群,并执行蒙特卡洛微观模拟、单变量和概率敏感性分析。
主要发现
- 在16颗患牙且牙水平风险低的人群中,无治疗成本最低(130欧元)但效果最差(144牙年),二胺氟化银涂漆成本较高(180欧元)但效果更好(151牙年)。
- 支付方愿为每无根面龋牙年投入8.30欧元时,二胺氟化银涂漆最具成本效果,氯己定涂漆和氟漱口不具成本效果。
- 在患牙更多且牙水平风险高的人群中,二胺氟化银涂漆效果最好且成本最低。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议,对于根面龋高风险患者,可推荐应用二胺氟化银涂漆作为预防根面龋的成本节省治疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: With a growing number of individuals retaining their teeth lifelong, often with periodontitis-induced root surface exposure, there is the need for cost-effective management strategies for root caries lesions. The present study aimed to assess the cost-effectiveness of root caries preventive treatments. METHODS: Patients were simulated over 10 years using a Markov model. Four treatments were compared: No treatment, daily 225-800ppm fluoride rinses, chlorhexidine (CHX) varnish (2×/year), silver diamine fluoride (SDF) varnish (2×/year). Data from a systematic review were submitted to network meta-analysis for inferring relative efficacies of treatments. The health outcome was years of teeth being free of root caries. A mixed public-private payer perspective within 2016 German healthcare was taken, with costs being estimated from fee item catalogues or based on market prices. Populations with different numbers of teeth and tooth-level risks were modelled. Monte-Carlo microsimulations, univariate- and probabilistic sensitivity analyses were performed. RESULTS: In populations with 16 teeth at risk and low tooth-level risk for root caries, providing no preventive treatment was least costly, but also least effective (130 Euro, 144 years). SDF ranked next, being more costly (180 Euro), but also more effective (151 years). Payers willing to invest 8.30 Euro per root caries-free tooth-year found SDF most cost-effective. CHX varnish and fluoride rinse were not cost-effective. In populations with more teeth and high tooth-level risk, SDF was the most effective and least costly option. CONCLUSIONS: Root caries preventive treatments (like SDF) are effective and might even be cost-saving in high risk populations. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Application of SDF can be recommended as a cost-saving treatment for prevention of root caries in patients with high risk of root caries.
引用
- Schwendicke F, Göstemeyer G. Cost-effectiveness of root caries preventive treatments. J Dent. 2016. PMID: 27984089. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2016.10.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。