锥形束CT在临床牙髓病中的应用:观察者间检测根尖周病变的变异性
本临床研究比较3名牙髓科教师、3名牙髓科住院医师和3名牙科学生对22颗上颌磨牙锥形束CT(CBCT)图像中根尖周病变的判读,并与2名经验丰富的口腔颌面放射科医师的共识意见对照。结果显示,经验水平似乎与正确诊断根尖周疾病的能力相关,且经验带来更好的评分者间信度;两方面的信度均未达到优秀。
要点
- 牙髓科教师与放射科医师共识的平均加权kappa值为0.49,牙髓科住院医师为0.35,牙科学生为0.32。
- 牙髓科教师组内信度平均加权kappa值最高为0.68,其次为牙髓科住院医师0.48和牙科学生0.28。
- 经验水平似乎与CBCT图像中根尖周病变的正确诊断能力相关,且经验带来更好的评分者间信度。
核心结论
- 临床医生的经验水平似乎与正确诊断CBCT图像中根尖周疾病的能力相关。
- 经验带来更好的评分者间信度;两方面的信度均未达到优秀,提示可进一步改善不同经验水平临床医生的CBCT判读技能。
研究设计与样本
- 临床研究,由3名牙髓科教师、3名牙髓科住院医师和3名牙科学生判读22颗上颌磨牙的CBCT图像,并与2名经验丰富的口腔颌面放射科医师的共识意见比较。
- 观察者使用5点Likert量表判断每颗牙根是否存在根尖周透射影。
主要发现
- 与放射科医师相比,牙髓科教师的平均加权kappa值为0.49,牙髓科住院医师为0.35,牙科学生为0.32。
- 组内信度方面,牙髓科教师平均加权kappa值最高为0.68,其次为牙髓科住院医师0.48和牙科学生0.28。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The accurate interpretation of a cone-beam computed tomographic (CBCT) volume is critical in identifying the presence of disease correctly and consistently. The aim of this clinical study was to determine the effect of experience level on the detection of periapical lesions in CBCT volumes. METHODS: CBCT volumes of 22 maxillary molars were interpreted by 3 endodontic faculty, 3 endodontic residents, and 3 dental students. These groups were compared with the consensus opinion of 2 experienced oral and maxillofacial radiologists. The observers determined the presence or absence of apical radiolucencies for each root using a 5-point Likert scale. RESULTS: Compared with the radiologists, the average weighted kappa value for endodontic faculty was 0.49, for endodontic residents it was 0.35 and for dental students it was 0.32. Intrarater reliability for each group showed endodontic faculty having the highest average weighted kappa value of 0.68 followed by endodontic residents (0.48) and dental students (0.28). CONCLUSIONS: Clinicians' experience level appears to be correlated with their ability to correctly diagnose periapical disease in CBCT volumes. In addition, experience leads to better inter-rater reliability. In neither of these 2 categories was agreement found to be excellent, suggesting that more can be done to improve the CBCT interpretation skills of clinicians at various levels of experience.
引用
- Parker JM, Mol A, Rivera EM, et al. Cone-beam Computed Tomography Uses in Clinical Endodontics: Observer Variability in Detecting Periapical Lesions. J Endod. 2016. PMID: 28024758. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2016.10.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。