种植体-基台连接处微形态差异及其临床意义研究:一项先导研究
本先导研究用扫描电镜观察3种基台(1个原厂、2个兼容)拧紧于原厂Straumann RN种植体后的连接处微形态,并用有限元分析计算应力、应变和变形。结果显示兼容基台内部连接及抗旋转元件就位严重受损,等效应力与应变远高于原厂基台,截面几何差异可影响修复体长期稳定性。
要点
- 兼容基台内部连接和抗旋转元件就位严重受损,1个兼容基台基台螺丝就位也受损。
- 有限元分析中兼容基台的等效应力和应变远高于原厂基台。
- 原厂与兼容基台预载施加过程的变形模式不同,可能具有严重临床意义。
核心结论
- 兼容基台与原厂基台相比可存在关键形态差异,截面几何差异导致整体接触面积在质量和数量上差异很大,可能对修复体长期稳定性产生严重影响。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为一项先导研究,将3个基台(1个原厂、2个兼容)按各自厂家说明拧紧于原厂Straumann RN种植体上。
- 种植体-基台单元经切片后在扫描电镜下以10×-500×不同放大倍数拍照,并依据扫描电镜精确测量重建各单元有限元分析模型。
- 使用ANSYS Workbench v13计算3种基台的应力、应变和变形差异。
主要发现
- 3个单元所有研究接触区之间均发现重大尺寸差异。
- 种植体肩部的紧密接触在3个单元中相似,但兼容基台的内部连接尤其是抗旋转元件就位严重受损。
- 1个兼容基台还表现出基台螺丝就位受损。
- 有限元分析中等效应力和应变在兼容基台中远高于原厂基台。
- 预载施加顺序评估显示原厂与兼容基台之间变形模式存在差异,可能具有严重临床意义。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: The aim of this pilot study was to investigate the morphological micro-features of three commercially available implant-abutment joints, using compatible and original prosthetic components. Furthermore, possible correlations between the micromorphology and potential functional complications were investigated with the use of finite element analysis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Three abutments (one original and two compatibles) were torqued on original Straumann RN implants, as according to each of the manufacturer's instructions. The implant-abutment units were sliced in the microtome and photographed under different magnifications (10×-500×) through a scanning electron microscope. Finite element analysis models were reconstructed for each of the implant-abutment units using the precise measurements from the SEM. Differences in stress, strain and deformation for the three different abutments were then calculated using ANSYS Workbench v13. RESULTS: Major dimensional differences were identified between all studied contact areas of the three units. The tight contact in the implant shoulder was similar in all three units, but engagement of the internal connection and, in particular, the anti-rotation elements was seriously compromised in the compatible abutments. One compatible abutment demonstrated compromised engagement of the abutment screw as well. Equivalent stress and strain in the FEA were much higher for the compatible abutments. An evaluation of the sequence of preload application revealed differences in the pattern of deformation between the original and compatible abutments, which can have serious clinical implications. CONCLUSION: Compatible abutments can present critical morphological differences from the original ones. The differences in the cross-sectional geometry result in large differences in the overall contact areas, both in terms of quality and quantity which could have serious implications for the long-term stability of the prosthesis.
引用
- Mattheos N, Li X, Zampelis A, et al. Investigating the micromorphological differences of the implant-abutment junction and their clinical implications: a pilot study. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2015. PMID: 25754471. doi:10.1111/clr.12578
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。