学校口腔筛查与不筛查对改善儿童口腔健康效果的系统综述与随机对照试验Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入5项整群随机对照试验(共28442名3-18岁儿童),比较学校口腔筛查与不筛查对口腔健康的效果。在组内相关系数为0.030时,两组牙科就诊率无统计学显著差异(RR 1.11,95%CI 0.97,1.27),异质性较大。仅1项研究报告龋坏乳牙和恒牙的患病率及平均龋牙数,两组无显著差异。
要点
- 学校口腔筛查与不筛查相比,牙科就诊率无统计学显著差异(RR 1.11,95%CI 0.97,1.27)。
- 仅1项研究报告龋坏乳牙和恒牙的患病率及平均龋牙数,筛查组与不筛查组无显著差异。
- 目前无证据支持或反驳口腔筛查的临床获益或危害,证据质量存在很大不确定性。
核心结论
- 目前无证据支持或反驳口腔筛查的临床获益或危害。
- 常规口腔筛查可能不会增加学龄儿童牙科就诊率,但该发现因证据质量存在很大不确定性。
- 综述证据提示学校口腔筛查在改善儿童口腔健康方面无临床获益,但该发现因证据质量存在很大不确定性。
- 需要开展设计良好、包含强化随访组和成本效果分析的试验。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与随机对照试验Meta分析,检索MEDLINE、EMBASE、Web of Science及其他来源截至2016年4月,无语言限制,纳入已发表和未发表研究。
- 共纳入5项整群随机对照试验,偏倚风险不明确或高,包含28442名3-18岁儿童。
- 采用Cochrane偏倚风险评估标准。
- 系统综述注册号CRD42016038828(PROSPERO数据库)。
主要发现
- 在组内相关系数为0.030时,接受口腔筛查与未接受口腔筛查的儿童牙科就诊率无统计学显著差异(RR 1.11,95%CI 0.97,1.27)。
- 卡方异质性检验和Higgin's I2值提示异质性较大。
- 仅1项研究报告龋坏乳牙和恒牙的患病率及平均龋牙数,筛查组与不筛查组无显著差异。
局限性
- 纳入的5项整群随机对照试验偏倚风险不明确或高。
- 牙科就诊率分析异质性较大。
- 仅1项研究报告龋坏乳牙和恒牙的患病率及平均龋牙数。
- 证据质量存在很大不确定性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: The current study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of school-based dental screening versus no screening on improving oral health in children aged 3-18 years by a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. SOURCES AND STUDY SELECTION: Three sets of independent reviewers searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science and other sources through April 2016 to identify published and nonpublished studies without language restrictions and extracted data. DATA: Primary outcomes included prevalence and mean number of teeth with caries, incidence of dental attendance and harms of screening. Cochrane's criteria for risk of bias assessment were used. RESULTS: A total of five cluster RCTs (of unclear or high risk of bias), including 28,442 children, were meta-analysed. For an intracluster correlation coefficient of 0.030, there was no statistically significant difference in dental attendance between children who received dental screening and those who did not receive dental screening (RR 1.11, 95% 0.97, 1.27). The Chi-square test for heterogeneity and the Higgin's I2 value indicated a substantial heterogeneity. Only one study reported the prevalence and mean number of deciduous and permanent teeth with dental caries and found no significant differences between the screening and no screening groups. CONCLUSIONS: There is currently no evidence to support or refute the clinical benefits or harms of dental screening. Routine dental screening may not increase the dental attendance of school children, but there is a lot of uncertainty in this finding because of the quality of evidence. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Evidence from the reviewed trials suggests no clinical benefit from school-based screening in improving children's oral health. However, there is a lot of uncertainty in this finding because of the quality of evidence. There is a need to conduct a well-designed trial with an intensive follow-up arm and cost-effectiveness analysis. SYSTEMATIC REVIEW REGISTRATION NUMBER: CRD42016038828 (PROSPERO database).
引用
- Joury E, Bernabe E, Sabbah W, et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials on the effectiveness of school-based dental screening versus no screening on improving oral health in children. J Dent. 2016. PMID: 27884719. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2016.11.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。