四种配准策略在任务自主机器人颌面截骨中的配准精度、时间与截骨结果比较
本研究在颌面模型上比较四种配准策略(夹板标志点、牙标志点、牙表面、骨表面)用于任务自主机器人截骨。所有策略平均目标配准误差均小于0.8 mm,表面配准在部分下颌截骨精度指标上表现更优,但牙表面与骨表面之间无一致差异。
要点
- 四种配准策略均实现亚毫米级目标配准误差。
- 表面配准在部分下颌截骨精度指标上优于或相当于标志点配准。
- 夹板标志点配准时间最短,但截骨精度因区域而异。
核心结论
- 配准策略显著影响目标配准误差、配准时间及下颌截骨精度结果。
- 所有四种策略均达到亚毫米级目标配准误差。
- 表面配准(骨表面和牙表面)的目标配准误差低于或相当于标志点配准(夹板标志点和牙标志点),并在部分下颌截骨精度指标上表现良好。
- 牙表面配准与骨表面配准之间未发现一致的精度差异。
研究设计与样本
- 基于影像数据构建颌面模型,上颌和下颌分别采用四种配准策略:夹板标志点配准、牙标志点配准、牙表面配准和骨表面配准。
- 在三个截骨区域测量目标配准误差并记录配准时间,随后使用任务自主机器人系统进行截骨。
- 比较实际与计划截骨面,采用均方根偏差、平均符号偏差和角度偏差进行评估。
主要发现
- 所有四种策略的平均目标配准误差均小于0.8 mm。
- Le Fort I 区域:骨表面配准的目标配准误差低于夹板标志点配准(0.398 ± 0.126 mm vs. 0.580 ± 0.098 mm;P = 0.0045)。
- 下颌目标配准误差存在显著的策略与区域交互作用(P = 0.0031);颏成形区域,牙表面配准和骨表面配准的目标配准误差低于夹板标志点配准和牙标志点配准。
- 下颌角区域:牙表面配准的目标配准误差低于夹板标志点配准和牙标志点配准;骨表面配准的目标配准误差低于牙标志点配准。
- 夹板标志点配准在上颌和下颌均具有最短的配准时间。
关键数值与推荐
- 所有四种策略平均目标配准误差均小于0.8 mm。
- Le Fort I 区域骨表面配准目标配准误差为 0.398 ± 0.126 mm,夹板标志点配准为 0.580 ± 0.098 mm(P = 0.0045)。
- 下颌目标配准误差策略与区域交互作用 P = 0.0031。
临床怎么用
- 表面配准可在牙列或骨面可充分暴露时支持精确的机器人辅助截骨。
- 夹板标志点配准时间最短,但截骨精度因区域而异,需权衡时间与精度。
- 牙表面配准与骨表面配准之间无一致精度差异,可根据临床可及性选择。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To compare four registration strategies for task-autonomous robotic maxillofacial osteotomy. METHODS: A maxillofacial model was constructed from imaging data. The maxilla and mandible were registered separately using splint-based landmark registration (SL), dental-landmark registration (DL), dental-surface registration (DS), and bone-surface registration (BS). The target-registration error (TRE) was measured in three osteotomy regions, and registration time was recorded. Osteotomies were then performed using a task-autonomous robotic system. The actual and planned osteotomy surfaces were compared using the root mean square (RMS) deviation, mean signed deviation, and angular deviation. RESULTS: All four strategies achieved mean TREs of less than 0.8 mm. In the Le Fort I region, TRE was lower for BS than for SL (0.398 ± 0.126 vs. 0.580 ± 0.098 mm; P = 0.0045). Mandibular TREs showed a significant strategy-by-region interaction (P = 0.0031); in the genioplasty region, DS and BS yielded lower TREs than SL and DL. In the mandibular angle region, DS yielded lower TREs than SL and DL, and BS yielded lower TREs than DL. SL had the shortest registration time for both jaws. In the genioplasty region, DL resulted in greater RMS and angular deviations than the other strategies, whereas in the mandibular angle region, DS resulted in lower angular deviation than SL and DL. CONCLUSIONS: Registration strategy significantly influenced TRE, registration time, and mandibular osteotomy accuracy outcomes. All four strategies achieved submillimetric TREs. Overall, surface-based registration (BS and DS) yielded TREs that were lower than or comparable to those of landmark-based registration (SL and DL) and showed favorable performance for selected mandibular osteotomy accuracy outcomes. However, no consistent difference in accuracy was identified between DS and BS. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Surface-based registration may support accurate robot-assisted osteotomy when adequate dentition or bony surfaces are accessible.
引用
- Song S, Liu H, Liu C, et al. Registration accuracy, time, and osteotomy outcomes across four strategies for task-autonomous robotic maxillofacial osteotomy. J Dent. 2026. PMID: 42956986. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2026.107143
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。