文献速递牙体牙髓病

器械分离后的牙体保存:管理策略对根折抵抗力和结构结局的影响

Preserving tooth structure after instrument separation: Effects of management strategy on root fracture resistance and structural outcomes related to tooth preservation.
PubMed 文献 · J Endod · 2026-10-30

本文为叙述性综述,综合临床研究、系统评价、生物力学实验和专家共识,分析非手术取出、旁路通过、留滞和手术管理对根折抵抗力、愈合及牙保留的影响。结论认为分离器械是管理问题而非必然取出指征,尚无策略在长期牙保留上显示优越性,应权衡进入根尖区的生物学价值与结构代价。

要点

  • 分离器械不一定需要取出,留滞在无根尖周炎时未一致显示愈合更差。
  • 激进取出可去除大量牙本质,尤其碎片位于根尖或弯曲根管内时。
  • 术前疾病状态是比碎片留滞更强的预后因素。

核心结论

  • 分离器械是管理问题,不是自动取出指征。
  • 尚无管理策略在长期牙保留上显示优越性。
  • 应权衡获得根尖进入的生物学价值与结构及操作代价。

研究设计与样本

  • 叙述性综述,综合临床研究、系统评价、生物力学实验室研究和近期专家共识。

主要发现

  • 激进取出可去除大量牙本质,尤其碎片位于根尖或弯曲根管内时。
  • 无根尖周炎时,留滞碎片未一致与更差愈合相关;术前疾病状态是更强预后因素。
  • 根折被报告为取出后晚期失败原因,但现有队列数据未确立取出导致这些骨折。
  • 尚无策略在对照比较研究中显示对长期牙生存更优。

关键数值与推荐

  • 碎片位置、根管弯曲度、感染状态、根管预备阶段、剩余牙本质和消毒可行性应决定取出、旁路、留滞或手术的选择。

临床怎么用

  • 根据碎片位置、根管弯曲、感染状态、剩余牙本质和消毒可行性个体化选择管理策略。
  • 避免为取出碎片而过度牺牲牙本质,尤其根尖或弯曲根管病例。
  • 将术前根尖周状态纳入预后判断。

局限性

  • 临床证据主要为观察性研究。
  • 旁路通过和手术取出的特异性证据有限。
  • 实验室根折抵抗力数据与观察性愈合数据终点不同,不能等同。
  • 现有队列数据未确立取出与后续根折的因果关系。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: A separated endodontic instrument can limit cleaning apical to the fragment. However, removal may require substantial sacrifice of radicular dentin. This narrative review examined how nonsurgical retrieval, bypass, retention, and surgical management affect fracture resistance, healing, and tooth retention. METHODS: Clinical studies, systematic reviews, biomechanical laboratory studies, and recent expert consensus were synthesized with emphasis on residual dentin, fracture resistance, periapical status, healing, and tooth retention. RESULTS: Aggressive retrieval can remove substantial dentin, particularly when fragments lie apically or within curved canals. Clinical evidence is mainly observational. Retained fragments are not consistently associated with poorer healing when apical periodontitis is absent; pre-operative disease status is a stronger prognostic factor. Evidence specific to successful bypass and surgical removal of separated instruments is limited. Root fracture has been reported as a late cause of failure after retrieval, although available cohort data do not establish that retrieval caused those fractures. No strategy has been shown superior for long-term tooth survival in controlled comparative studies; laboratory fracture-resistance data and observational healing data address different endpoints and cannot be equated. CONCLUSIONS: A separated instrument is a management problem, not an automatic indication for removal. No management strategy has demonstrated superiority in long-term tooth retention on the basis of controlled comparative clinical evidence. Management should balance the biological value of gaining apical access against the structural and procedural cost of doing so recognizing that this balance is a clinically reasonable principle rather than a comparatively validated outcome. Fragment position, canal curvature, infection status, stage of canal preparation, residual dentin, and feasibility of disinfection should determine whether retrieval, bypass, retention, or surgery is selected.

来源:J Endod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Elashiry MM, Zeitoun R, Tay F, et al. Preserving tooth structure after instrument separation: Effects of management strategy on root fracture resistance and structural outcomes related to tooth preservation. J Endod. 2026. PMID: 42962853. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2026.10.013

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。