文献速递儿童口腔

昆士兰州社区饮水氟化的有效性:2008年政策变化后基于人群的因果分析

Effectiveness of Community Water Fluoridation in Queensland: A Population-Based Causal Analysis Following the 2008 Policy Change.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent Res · 2026-10-28

该研究采用重复横断面、基于人群的因果框架和双重差分法,分析昆士兰州5至14岁儿童饮水氟化与龋病的关系。2010-2012年纳入5,407名儿童、2022-2024年纳入7,718名儿童。新氟化区儿童乳牙龋经验较对照区多下降1.40倍,恒牙下降较小且置信区间跨1。

要点

  • 新氟化区儿童乳牙龋经验较未氟化区多下降1.40倍(95%CI 1.08-1.80)。
  • 乳牙龋流行率多下降1.28倍(95%CI 1.00-1.67),相当于降低10.8%。
  • 恒牙龋经验下降1.32倍(95%CI 0.95-1.84),流行率下降1.04倍(95%CI 0.81-1.33)。

核心结论

  • 饮水氟化在疾病水平低且其他预防项目可及的情况下仍能有效预防儿童龋病。
  • 该受控双重差分研究为饮水氟化对龋病的影响提供了稳健的当代科学证据,强化了其作为公共卫生政策的地位。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用因果框架的重复横断面、基于人群的研究,随机选取昆士兰州5至14岁儿童。
  • 2010-2012年收集5,407名儿童数据,2022-2024年收集7,718名儿童数据。
  • 主要暴露为饮水氟化可及性,分为新氟化区(2010年以来新氟化)、从未氟化区(对照)和长期氟化区。
  • 结局为乳牙和恒牙的龋经验(龋、失、补牙面)和龋流行率,由两阶段统一培训校准的检查者收集。
  • 采用双重差分估计量,通过多变量回归模型估计新氟化区与对照区结局变化的差异,并用逆概率治疗权重控制地区和个体社会经济混杂因素。

主要发现

  • 新氟化区儿童龋病相对对照组持续下降。
  • 乳牙列:新氟化区儿童龋经验多下降1.40倍(95%CI 1.08至1.80),龋流行率多下降1.28倍(95%CI 1.00至1.67),相当于减少1.1个受累牙面和降低10.8%的流行率。
  • 恒牙列:龋经验多下降1.32倍(95%CI 0.95至1.84),龋流行率多下降1.04倍(95%CI 0.81至1.33)。

临床怎么用

  • 在疾病水平低且其他预防项目可及的环境中,饮水氟化仍可作为有效的儿童龋病预防公共卫生措施。
  • 恒牙列获益幅度小于乳牙列,且置信区间跨1,解读恒牙结果时需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Water fluoridation (WF) is an important preventive program against dental caries. Recent Cochrane reviews reported only limited new scientific evidence of WF. This research aimed to provide contemporary evidence on the causal relationship between WF and oral health. A causal framework was used to ensure methodological rigour in repeated cross-sectional, population-based studies of randomly selected 5 to 14 y old children in Queensland, thereby enabling controlled difference-in-differences (DiD) analyses. The primary exposure was access to WF, defined as newly fluoridated (New-WF; areas that became fluoridated since 2010), never fluoridated (No-WF), or long-term fluoridated areas (Long-WF). The outcomes were dental caries experience (decayed, missing, or filled tooth surfaces) and prevalence in the primary and permanent dentition, collected by dental examiners who were uniformly trained and calibrated during both phases. The DiD estimands were the differences in changes in outcomes between New-WF and the control (No-WF), estimated from multivariable regression models. Data of 5,407 children during 2010-2012 and 7,718 children during 2022-2024 were collected. Variations in key confounders (area and individual socioeconomic factors) were controlled for using inverse probability of treatment weights. Dental caries among children in New-WF had consistently declined relative to the control groups. In the primary dentition, the New-WF children had a 1.40-fold (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.08 to 1.80) reduction in caries experience and a 1.28-fold (1.00 to 1.67) reduction in caries prevalence, equivalent to 1.1 fewer affected tooth surfaces and a 10.8% lower prevalence. In the permanent dentition, reductions were smaller: a 1.32-fold (0.95 to 1.84) reduction in caries experience and a 1.04-fold (0.81 to 1.33) reduction in prevalence. These findings show that WF is effective in preventing dental caries in children when disease levels are low and other preventive programs are available. This controlled DiD study provides robust contemporary scientific evidence of the effects of WF on dental caries, strengthening WF as a public health policy.

来源:J Dent Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Do LG, Spencer AJ, Roberts-Thomson K, et al. Effectiveness of Community Water Fluoridation in Queensland: A Population-Based Causal Analysis Following the 2008 Policy Change. J Dent Res. 2026. PMID: 42952099. doi:10.1177/00220345261491339

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。