治或不治:全科牙医开展或回避根管治疗决策的定性系统评价与Meta聚合
研究识别78条定性发现并聚合为7个类别、3个综合发现,涵盖临床与心理维度、专业准备与学习、外部与系统层面影响。全科牙医开展或回避根管治疗受临床复杂性、心理负担、教育经验不足及报酬、时间、转诊等组织因素共同影响,综合发现置信度为中等。
要点
- 全科牙医根管治疗决策受临床复杂性、心理负担、教育经验及组织因素共同影响。
- 教育课程和继续职业发展应针对上述因素设计,以提升根管治疗参与度。
- 综合发现置信度为中等,证据来自5项高质量定性研究、87名全科牙医。
核心结论
- 全科牙医开展或回避根管治疗由临床、心理、教育和组织因素共同塑造。
- 理解这些因素有助于指导根管治疗课程开发和牙医继续职业发展活动。
研究设计与样本
- 定性系统评价与Meta聚合,遵循JBI证据合成手册,以计划行为理论为理论基础。
- 最终纳入5项定性或混合方法研究,共87名来自英国、瑞典和新西兰的全科牙医。
- 所有纳入研究JBI方法学质量评分为8-10/10,整体质量高。
- 采用ConQual方法评估综合发现置信度,所有综合发现均为中等置信度。
主要发现
- 共识别78条定性发现,经Meta聚合归为7个类别,进而形成3个综合发现。
- 综合发现一为「根管实践的临床与心理维度」。
- 综合发现二为「专业准备、动机与学习」。
- 综合发现三为「外部与系统层面对决策的影响」。
- 全科牙医决策受感知临床复杂性、心理负担、教育和临床经验局限以及报酬、时间限制、转诊路径等组织因素影响。
临床怎么用
- 根管治疗课程设计可参考临床复杂性、心理负担、教育经验及组织因素等影响维度。
- 继续职业发展活动可针对全科牙医的根管治疗决策障碍进行优化。
局限性
- 仅纳入5项研究,样本来自英国、瑞典和新西兰三个国家,地理覆盖有限。
- 所有综合发现置信度均为中等,证据确定性有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To synthesise qualitative evidence on the factors influencing general dental practitioners' (GDPs) decisions to perform or avoid endodontic treatment. METHODS: The Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Manual for Evidence Synthesis guided the methodology, underpinned by the Theory of Planned Behaviour. The PICo framework was formulated to define inclusion criteria. A comprehensive search of six online databases (PubMed, Scopus, Embase, Web of Science, MEDLINE via EBSCOhost, and Google Scholar for grey literature) was conducted for articles published between January 2000 and December 2025. Two authors independently performed title and abstract screening and methodological quality appraisal, with full-text eligibility assessment and data extraction subsequently reviewed and disagreements resolved through discussion. Only primary qualitative or mixed-methods studies containing extractable GDP-specific data were included. Rayyan software was used to manage screening and remove duplicates. Methodological quality was appraised using the JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist. Data were synthesised using qualitative meta-aggregation, whereby findings were grouped into categories and further aggregated into synthesised findings. Confidence in the synthesised findings was assessed using the Confidence in Qualitative Synthesis (ConQual) approach. RESULTS: The search identified 951 records, of which 442 duplicates were removed. After screening, 23 full texts were assessed, with 18 excluded, leaving five studies that met eligibility criteria, including 87 GDPs from the United Kingdom, Sweden, and New Zealand. All studies demonstrated high methodological quality (JBI scores 8-10/10). A total of 78 qualitative findings were identified and synthesised through meta-aggregation into seven categories, which informed three synthesised findings: (1). 'Clinical and Psychological Dimensions of Endodontic Practice'; (2). 'Professional Preparation, Motivation, and Learning'; and (3) 'External and System-Level Influences on Decision-Making'. Overall, GDPs' decisions to perform or avoid endodontic treatment were influenced by perceived clinical complexity, psychological burden, limitations in education and clinical experience, and organisational factors such as remuneration, time constraints, and referral pathways. All synthesised findings were rated as having moderate confidence. CONCLUSION: GDPs' engagement with endodontic treatment is shaped by a combination of clinical, psychological, educational, and organisational influences. Understanding these factors can help to inform endodontic curriculum development and continuing professional development activities for dentists. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO [ID: CRD420251084935].
引用
- Lin GSS, Chandler NP, Duncan HF, et al. To Treat or Not to Treat: A Qualitative Systematic Review and Meta-Aggregation of General Dental Practitioners' Decisions to Perform or Avoid Endodontic Treatment. Int Endod J. 2026. PMID: 42866924. doi:10.1111/iej.70291
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。