储存条件对种植体周围软组织仿真模型尺寸稳定性的影响:一项体外研究
该体外研究基于1例前牙美学区单牙种植患者的数据,用光固化3D打印制作24个种植体周围软组织仿真模型,分为透光与避光储存组,在0至90天多个时间点扫描评估尺寸稳定性。结果显示储存时间和储存条件均显著影响穿龈轮廓尺寸稳定性,透光储存加剧偏差,避光储存有利于维持稳定性。
要点
- 储存时间和储存条件均显著影响仿真牙龈穿龈轮廓的尺寸稳定性。
- 两组模型从储存5天起三维偏差显著增长,至90天仍未稳定。
- 透光储存加剧尺寸偏差,避光储存有利于维持尺寸稳定性。
核心结论
- 光固化3D打印的种植体周围软组织仿真模型尺寸形变呈时间依赖性,早期变化尤为明显。
- 透光储存可加剧穿龈轮廓区域的尺寸偏差,避光储存则有利于维持模型的尺寸稳定性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究选取2020年10月空军军医大学口腔医院口腔种植科1例前牙美学区单牙种植术后戴用临时修复体拟行正式修复的患者,经数字化印模制作24个上颌牙弓及仿真牙龈模型。
- 模型分为透光组(n=12)和避光组(n=12),储存时间设定为0、3、5、7、14、28、60、90天,用模型扫描仪获取扫描数据并以穿龈轮廓为感兴趣区域分析二维偏差和三维偏差(RMSE)。
主要发现
- 二维偏差分析显示储存时间(F=32.89,P<0.001)和储存条件(F=18.76,P<0.001)对穿龈轮廓尺寸稳定性均有显著影响。
- 两组模型储存5天起三维偏差(RMSE值)出现显著增长(P<0.05),且至90天时仍未达到稳定状态。
- 储存90天时透光组和避光组三维偏差(RMSE值)均为最大值,分别为(55.6±2.5)μm和(51.1±5.5)μm。
临床怎么用
- 临床制作种植体周围软组织仿真模型后宜避光储存,以减缓穿龈轮廓区域的尺寸偏差。
- 模型储存5天起即出现显著三维偏差增长,应关注储存时间对尺寸稳定性的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To investigate the effects of storage conditions on the dimensional stability of peri-implant soft tissue (PIST) replicas, and to identify both the time-dependent deformation and the clinically acceptable storage duration. Methods: A patient who had received single dental implant and temporary prosthesis in the anterior aesthetic region undergoing final restoration was selected in October 2020 from Department of Oral Implantation, School of Stomatology, The Fourth Military Medical University. Based on digital impression, twenty-four maxillary die-trimmed arch and PIST replicas were fabricated by a digital light projection three-dimensional (3D) printer, followed by implant-level assembly. The combined models were enrolled into different groups according to storage conditions: light-exposed (n=12); and dark-stored (n=12). Storage times were divided into 0, 3, 5, 7, 14, 28, 60, 90 d. 3D model scanner was performed to obtain standard tessellation language (STL) files of the combined models within 24 h of printing completion, while models saved under experimental conditions were scanned to generate the ".stl" dataset. The dataset of N-Lit/Box-Tx was then pairwise aligned with the reference file (N-T0) using surface-matching software of Geomagic Control X, with the emergence profile defined as the region of interest (ROI). Root mean square error (RMSE) was used to conduct the dimensional stability of PIST replicas. Results: Two-dimensional deviation analysis using three-way ANOVA revealed that storage time (F=32.89, P<0.001) and storage condition (F=18.76, P<0.001) significantly influenced the dimensional stability of the emergence profile. The 3D RMSE increased significantly from day 5 onward (P<0.05) and did not reach a stable state by 90 d. At 90 d, the RMSE values in both groups reached their maxima, with (55.6±2.5) μm in the light-exposed group and (51.1±5.5) μm in the dark-stored group. Conclusions: The 3D-printed PIST replicas exhibited time-dependent deformation, with early changes being most pronounced. Light exposure accelerated instability in the emergence profile, while dark storage preserved dimensional stability. 目的: 探讨储存条件对仿真牙龈穿龈轮廓尺寸稳定性的影响,以确定其尺寸变化规律和临床可接受的储存期限。 方法: 选取2020年10月就诊于空军军医大学口腔医院口腔种植科的前牙美学区单牙种植术后戴用临时修复体拟行正式修复的患者1例,数字化间接方法获取印模数据。光固化三维打印机分别打印24个上颌牙弓及仿真牙龈,24 h内组装,使用模型扫描仪获取扫描数据。储存条件分为透光组和避光组。储存时间设定为0、3、5、7、14、28、60、90 d。使用模型扫描仪获取相应储存条件和时间模型的扫描数据。使用逆向工程软件将储存0 d的扫描数据分别与同组其他时间点扫描数据拟合对齐,将穿龈轮廓处设为感兴趣区域,通过分析二维偏差和三维偏差[均方根误差(RMSE)]评估两组各时间点尺寸稳定性。 结果: 二维偏差分析显示,储存时间(F=32.89,P<0.001)和储存条件(F=18.76,P<0.001)对穿龈轮廓尺寸稳定性均有显著影响。两组模型储存5 d起三维偏差(RMSE值)出现显著增长(P<0.05),且至90 d时仍未达到稳定状态。储存90 d时,透光组和避光组三维偏差(RMSE值)均为最大值,分别为(55.6±2.5)μm和(51.1±5.5)μm。 结论: 光固化三维打印的仿真牙龈模型的尺寸形变呈时间依赖性,早期变化尤为明显。透光储存可加剧穿龈轮廓区域的尺寸偏差,避光储存则有利于维持模型的尺寸稳定性。.
引用
- Han JY, Yu Z, Wu YL, et al. [Impact of storage conditions on the dimensional stability of peri-implant soft tissue replicas: an in vitro study]. Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2026. PMID: 42811707. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112144-20260508-00292
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。