文献速递牙体牙髓病牙周病

3D口内扫描仪检测龋病、氟牙症及酸蚀性牙磨损的诊断一致性研究

Assessing 3D intraoral scanning for the detection of caries, fluorosis, and erosive tooth wear across smooth tooth surfaces and locations.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent · 2026-09-25

本研究评估了3D口内扫描仪与视觉检查在龋病、酸蚀性牙磨损及氟牙症诊断中的一致性,共完成4620个牙面评估。结果显示IOS与视觉检查在ICDAS上一致性极好(加权κ=0.89),BEWE(加权κ=0.75)和TFI(加权κ=0.74)一致性也较高,支持IOS可作为牙体硬组织状况评估的辅助工具。

要点

  • IOS与视觉检查在龋病评估中一致性极好(加权κ=0.89)
  • IOS对酸蚀性牙磨损和氟牙症评估一致性分别为加权κ=0.75和0.74
  • 前牙和舌侧表面一致性更高,后牙颊侧一致性相对较低但仍可接受

核心结论

  • 3D口内扫描仪在龋病、酸蚀性牙磨损和氟牙症评估中与视觉检查一致性高,可作为辅助评估工具。

研究设计与样本

  • 共进行4620个牙面评估,其中ICDAS对应2351个、BEWE对应1280个、TFI对应989个,采用全口IOS扫描与视觉评分。

主要发现

  • ICDAS评估中IOS与视觉检查一致性极好(κ=0.82;加权κ=0.89;97%一致性;ρ=0.87),前牙(加权κ=0.91)优于后牙(加权κ=0.86),舌侧一致性最高。
  • BEWE评估中一致性较高(κ=0.69;加权κ=0.75;79%一致性;ρ=0.78),前牙和后牙一致性相似(分别为81%和78%)。
  • TFI评估中一致性较高(κ=0.67;加权κ=0.74;84%一致性;ρ=0.78),前牙舌侧表现最佳(99%一致性),后牙颊侧一致性最低但仍可接受。
  • 不一致主要发生在中度病变阶段。

关键数值与推荐

  • ICDAS评估的加权κ=0.89,BEWE的加权κ=0.75,TFI的加权κ=0.74。
  • ICDAS总体一致性97%,BEWE总体一致性79%,TFI总体一致性84%。
  • TFI前牙舌侧一致性99%,后牙颊侧一致性最低。

临床怎么用

  • IOS技术可辅助临床决策,便于纵向监测,并提高涉及釉质健康研究方案的标准化。

局限性

  • 不一致主要出现在中度病变阶段,后牙颊侧一致性相对较低。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the diagnostic agreement between a 3D intraoral scanner (IOS) and standard visual examinations for the assessment of dental hard-tissue conditions, including caries and erosive tooth wear (ETW) and enamel fluorosis. METHODS: A total of 4,620 surfaces assessments were performed using three indices, corresponding to 2,351, 1,280, and 989 surfaces, respectively. Assessments were conducted using full-mouth IOS scans and visual scoring using the International Caries Detection and Assessment System - ICDAS for caries; Basic Erosive Wear Examination - BEWE for ETW and Thylstrup-Fejerskov- TF index for enamel fluorosis. Agreement was examined overall and by tooth location (anterior/posterior) and surface (buccal, lingual, incisal). Statistical analyses included Cohen's κ, weighted κ, percent absolute agreement, and Spearman correlation coefficients for ordinal consistency. RESULTS: For ICDAS, IOS demonstrated excellent agreement with visual examination (κ=0.82; weighted κ=0.89; 97% agreement; ρ=0.87). Anterior teeth (weighted κ=0.91) showed greater agreement than posterior teeth (weighted κ=0.86), with highest agreement on lingual surfaces. Discrepancies occurred mainly within intermediate lesion stages. For BEWE, agreement was substantial overall (κ=0.69; weighted κ=0.75; 79% agreement; ρ=0.78). Anterior and posterior surfaces exhibited similar agreement (81% and 78% agreement, respectively). For TFI, similar substantial agreement was observed (κ=0.67; weighted κ=0.74; 84% agreement; ρ=0.78). Anterior-lingual surfaces demonstrated the strongest performance (99% agreement), while posterior-buccal surfaces showed the lowest, though still acceptable, agreement. CONCLUSION: The 3D IOS showed promising performance across all three dental conditions and surface types evaluated. Agreement with visual examination was consistently high, supporting IOS may serve as a useful adjunct tool for the assessment of dental hard-tissue conditions. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: IOS technology may enhance clinical decision-making, facilitate longitudinal monitoring, and improve standardization in research protocols involving enamel health.

来源:J Dent,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Valdivia-Tapia AC, Lara JS, Martinez-Mier EA, et al. Assessing 3D intraoral scanning for the detection of caries, fluorosis, and erosive tooth wear across smooth tooth surfaces and locations. J Dent. 2026. PMID: 42790724. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2026.107077

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。