文献速递口腔正畸

掠夺性期刊论文对正畸Meta分析结果的影响

Predatory Publications Bias the Findings of Orthodontic Meta-analyses.
PubMed 文献 · J Dent Res · 2026-07-29

本研究量化了正畸证据合成中掠夺性或可疑期刊论文的出现频率,并检验其是否影响Meta分析合并估计。2020至2023年共纳入340篇正畸系统综述,其中33.5%的Meta分析至少包含1篇可疑原始研究。剔除可疑研究后,55%的Meta分析合并估计降低,45%升高,提示掠夺性论文可能偏倚正畸Meta分析结果。

要点

  • 约三分之一的正确Meta分析包含掠夺性或可疑期刊发表的原始研究。
  • 剔除可疑研究后,超过半数Meta分析的合并效应估计发生改变。
  • 正畸证据合成应常规筛查期刊合法性并行敏感性分析。

核心结论

  • 掠夺性和可疑期刊论文存在于三分之一的正确Meta分析中,并可能影响合并估计。

研究设计与样本

  • 从10,905条记录中纳入340篇具有可获取Meta分析数据的正畸SR,每篇SR选择一个MA优先主要结局或最早时间点。
  • 采用预设方法将期刊分类为合法、可疑或掠夺性,对包含至少1篇可疑研究的MA在两种情景下用随机效应模型(限制最大似然)重新计算合并效应估计。

主要发现

  • 在1992篇原始研究中,大多数发表于Medline索引期刊(n=1494;75%)。
  • 16.2%的SR发表在掠夺性或可疑期刊上。
  • 33.5%(114/340)的所选MA至少包含1篇发表于掠夺性或可疑期刊的可疑原始研究,21.4%(73/340)至少包含1篇发表于掠夺性期刊的原始研究。
  • SR发表在合法期刊(33.7%)、可疑期刊(30%)或掠夺性期刊(33.3%)时,纳入可疑原始研究的比例相似。
  • 在最终再分析集(n=106)中,剔除可疑/掠夺性研究后,55%的MA合并估计降低,45%升高。

临床怎么用

  • 在正畸证据合成和编辑评估中应整合常规期刊合法性筛查、研究质量评估以及排除可疑研究的敏感性分析。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

This study quantified how frequently questionable publications by predatory or suspect journals appear in orthodontic evidence syntheses and examined whether inclusion of these studies influences pooled estimates in orthodontic systematic reviews (SRs) with meta-analyses (MAs). Orthodontic SRs with MAs published in English between January 1, 2020, and December 31, 2023, were identified through multiple databases. One MA per SR (prioritized primary outcome/earliest time point) was selected when data were extractable from forest plots. Journals were classified as legitimate, suspect, or predatory using a prespecified approach. For MAs containing at least 1 predatory or suspect study, pooled effect estimates were recalculated under 2 scenarios using random-effects models (restricted maximum likelihood), including 1) all studies and 2) legitimate studies only. Changes were assessed using differences in the pooled estimates between scenarios. From 10,905 records, 340 orthodontic SRs with accessible meta-analytical data were included, most commonly addressing treatment modalities (32.4%). Among the 1,992 primary studies identified, most were published in journals indexed in Medline (n = 1,494; 75%). Overall, 16.2% of SRs were published in predatory or suspect (questionable) journals. One-third of selected MAs (114/340; 33.5%) included at least 1 questionable primary study published in a predatory or suspect journal, and 21.4% (73/340) included at least 1 primary study published in a predatory journal. The inclusion of questionable primary studies was similar whether the SR was published in a legitimate (33.7%), suspect (30%), or predatory journal (33.3%). In the final reanalysis set (n = 106), the pooled estimate decreased in 55% and increased in 45% of MAs after removal of suspect/predatory studies. Predatory and suspect publications are present in 1 in 3 orthodontic meta-analyses and may influence the pooled estimates. Routine legitimacy screening, study quality assessment, and sensitivity analyses excluding questionable studies should be integrated into evidence synthesis and editorial assessment in orthodontics.

来源:J Dent Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Maroulakos MP, Tatas Z, Al-Moghrabi D, et al. Predatory Publications Bias the Findings of Orthodontic Meta-analyses. J Dent Res. 2026. PMID: 42528280. doi:10.1177/00220345261466209

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。