牙周健康与疾病的环境影响潜力量化:生命周期评估研究
该研究采用生命周期评估方法,量化了家庭口腔护理(电动或手动牙刷、牙膏、牙线)及不同程度牙周病临床治疗的环境影响。结果显示,牙周病越重,因就诊、治疗和诊所能耗增加,总体环境影响越大;诊所治疗的环境影响约为家庭预防护理的2-4倍,重度牙周病患者可达10倍。家庭使用手动与电动牙刷在所有影响类别上无统计学差异。
要点
- 牙周病越重,临床治疗的环境影响越大,重度患者可达家庭护理的10倍。
- 家庭预防护理的环境影响远低于诊所治疗,是减排关键。
- 手动与电动牙刷在家庭使用中的环境影响无统计学差异。
核心结论
- 牙周健康与疾病的环境影响应综合家庭护理与临床治疗评估,后者是主要排放源。
- 有效的家庭口腔卫生有助于预防疾病,并减轻牙周治疗的环境影响。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用生命周期评估方法,量化家庭日常口腔护理及牙周健康与不同阶段牙周病临床治疗的环境影响。
主要发现
- 牙周病严重程度增加,总体环境影响因就诊、治疗和诊所能耗增加而增大。
- 平均患者临床治疗的环境影响(含碳足迹)约为家庭预防护理的2-4倍。
- 重度牙周病患者临床治疗的环境影响约为家庭预防护理的10倍。
- 家庭使用手动与电动牙刷在所有影响类别上无统计学差异。
临床怎么用
- 临床应强调有效预防性口腔卫生,以限制疾病进展并减少资源密集的牙周治疗需求。
- 维护牙周健康可同时改善患者结局并促进可持续口腔护理。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To quantify environmental impacts of periodontal health and diseases, ranging from at home preventive care to dental treatments. METHODS: A Life Cycle Assessment was conducted to quantify environmental impacts of daily at home oral care routines using either an electric or manual toothbrush, plus toothpaste and floss, and environmental impacts of clinical treatments for patients with gingival health and varying stages of diagnosed periodontal disease. RESULTS: As periodontal disease severity increases, so does the overall environmental impact due to more visits, treatments and energy used at clinic. For the average patient, the environmental impact (including carbon footprint) from in-clinic treatment is approximately 2-4x higher compared to at-home preventive care routines with either manual or electric toothbrush, and 10x higher for patients with more severe forms of periodontal disease. At home, there is no statistical difference between using a manual and electric toothbrush across all impact categories. CONCLUSIONS: The environmental implications from periodontal health/disease are best assessed by analysis that includes at-home routines and in-clinic disease management; the latter is the dominant emission source. Effective at-home oral hygiene routines aid in preventing disease and are considered beneficial to mitigate the environmental impacts from periodontal disease treatment in dental clinics. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: From a clinical perspective, the findings reinforce the importance of effective preventive oral hygiene in limiting disease progression and reducing the need for resource intensive periodontal treatment. By integrating environmental and clinical considerations, this study highlights that maintaining periodontal health delivers dual benefits for both patient outcomes and sustainable dental care delivery.
引用
- Duane B, Martin N, Mulligan S, et al. Quantifying the environmental impact potential from periodontal health to disease: Findings from a life cycle assessment study. J Dent. 2026. PMID: 42086141. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2026.106735
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。