美国牙髓病医师对单次与多次根管治疗的偏好与认知:横断面调查
该研究于2024年4月至6月对美国执业牙髓病医师进行匿名在线横断面调查,共462份有效问卷。结果显示单次根管治疗在坏死牙和不可逆性牙髓炎中分别有74.9%和92.6%的医师常规完成,多数认为两种方案并发症和成功率无差异,但根管无法干燥或弥漫性肿胀时多选多次就诊。
要点
- 单次根管治疗在坏死牙和不可逆性牙髓炎中分别有74.9%和92.4%的医师常规完成。
- 多数医师认为单次与多次方案在术后并发症(65.6%)或成功率(81.0%)上无差异。
- 根管无法干燥时92.6%选择多次就诊,弥漫性肿胀时79.9%选择多次就诊。
核心结论
- 美国牙髓病医师广泛实践单次根管治疗,多数认为单次与多次方案结局相当。
- 就诊次数仍取决于病例情况,尤其是根管无法干燥或存在急性感染时。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面匿名在线调查,30个条目,于2024年4月至6月对美国执业牙髓病医师实施。
- 共收到511份提交,462份符合纳入标准,回应率14.5%。
主要发现
- 常规单次完成根管治疗:坏死牙74.9%,不可逆性牙髓炎92.4%。
- 认为两种方案术后并发症无差异者65.6%,成功率无差异者81.0%。
- 单次完成最少见于根管无法干燥(92.6%选多次)和弥漫性肿胀(79.9%选多次)。
- 病变尺寸≥5 mm时单次完成率为60.4%,≥15 mm时降至37.9%。
- 男性性别是最一致的独立预测因素(8个场景中7个,OR 2.01-2.74);GentleWave使用独立预测感染相关场景的单次完成。
关键数值与推荐
- 常规单次完成根管治疗:坏死牙74.9%,不可逆性牙髓炎92.4%。
- 病变尺寸≥5 mm时单次完成率60.4%,≥15 mm时37.9%。
- 根管无法干燥时92.6%选择多次就诊,弥漫性肿胀时79.9%选择多次就诊。
- 男性性别独立预测单次偏好(7/8场景,OR 2.01-2.74)。
临床怎么用
- 单次根管治疗在美国牙髓病医师中广泛应用,但需根据根管干燥性和感染情况个体化选择。
- 根管无法干燥或存在弥漫性肿胀时,多数医师倾向多次就诊。
- 性别、年龄、地区和技术使用影响就诊次数偏好,可参考这些因素优化决策。
局限性
- 回应率14.5%,可能存在无应答偏倚。
- 横断面设计无法推断因果关系。
- 调查对象仅为美国牙髓病医师,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The optimal number of visits for root canal treatment remains debated. This study examined United States endodontists' single-visit versus multiple-visit preferences and identified demographic, regional, and technological correlates. METHODS: A cross-sectional, anonymous, 30-item online survey was administered from April to June 2024 to practicing United States endodontists. Associations between demographic variables and responses were assessed using chi-square tests. Binary logistic regression evaluated independent predictors of single-visit treatment across eight clinical scenarios. RESULTS: Of 511 submissions, 462 met eligibility criteria (response rate 14.5%). Routine single-visit completion was reported for necrotic teeth by 74.9% and for irreversible pulpitis by 92.4%. Most respondents perceived no difference between protocols in postoperative complications (65.6%) or success rate (81.0%). Single-visit completion was least common when canals could not be dried (92.6% multiple-visit) and with diffuse swelling (79.9% multiple-visit). Single-visit completion at lesion sizes of ≥5 mm was reported by 60.4% and declined to 37.9% at ≥15 mm. Male sex was the most consistent independent predictor of single-visit preference (7/8 scenarios; odds ratios 2.01-2.74). GentleWave use independently predicted single-visit completion for infection-related scenarios. Preferences varied significantly by age, practice region, and technology use. CONCLUSIONS: Single-visit treatment is widely practiced among United States endodontists, with most perceiving comparable outcomes. Visit number remains case-dependent, particularly when canal dryness is unachievable or acute infection is present. Preferences varied by sex, age, region, and technology adoption.
引用
- Tsai S, Kim JR. United States Endodontists' Preferences and Perceptions of Single-Visit versus Multiple-Visit Root Canal Treatment: A Cross-Sectional Survey. J Endod. 2026. PMID: 42214667. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2026.05.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。