理解氟化物犹豫:一项定性范围综述
分析识别出五个相互关联的犹豫域:认为氟化物有害或有毒、对益处或必要性不确定、对科学专业或政府机构不信任、对自主权同意和环境伦理的担忧、对特定给药方式的不适及对替代品的偏好。氟化物犹豫是多层面的解释过程而非简单的知识缺乏。
要点
- 氟化物犹豫包含五个相互关联的域,涉及危害感知、不确定性、不信任、伦理担忧和给药方式偏好。
- 犹豫不仅由信息塑造,还受情感反应、生活经验、育儿规范、网络 discourse 和机构可信度解读影响。
- 应对氟化物犹豫需结合清晰科学沟通与对信任、自主权和社会情境的关注。
核心结论
- 氟化物犹豫是一个多层面的解释过程,而非简单的知识缺乏。
- 应对氟化物犹豫需要将清晰的科学沟通与对信任、自主权及预防建议接受的社会情境的关注相结合。
- 承认经验视角并增加政策决策透明度的策略可能增强氟化物指南的可信度和采纳度,但鉴于信任不均和信息争议的广泛环境,某种程度的犹豫可能持续存在。
研究设计与样本
- 定性范围综述,检索PubMed、Scopus、Embase和CINAHL至2025年4月。
- 采用标准化图表法提取数据,并通过归纳性、扎根理论指导的主题分析进行综合,辅以持续比较和反思性备忘录。
主要发现
- 识别出五个相互关联的犹豫域:认为氟化物有害或有毒;对益处或必要性不确定;对科学、专业或政府机构不信任;对自主权、同意和环境伦理的伦理担忧;对特定给药方式的不适及对替代品的偏好。
- 犹豫不仅由信息塑造,还受情感反应、生活经验、育儿规范、网络 discourse 和对机构可信度的解读影响。
- 关于氟化物的决策反映了 navigate 不确定性、保护儿童和维持健康选择控制的更广泛努力。
临床怎么用
- 与患者沟通氟化物时,应结合清晰科学信息与对信任、自主权和社会情境的关注。
- 策略应承认患者的经验视角,并增加政策决策的透明度,以增强指南可信度和采纳度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Fluoride is widely regarded within dentistry and public health as a safe and effective measure for preventing dental caries. Public ambivalence toward fluoride has intensified in recent years, reflected in ongoing disputes over water fluoridation. This scoping review synthesizes qualitative evidence on how fluoride hesitancy is constructed and expressed across social and clinical contexts. Qualitative studies examining perceptions, beliefs, and decision-making related to fluoride use were identified through searches of PubMed, Scopus, Embase, and CINAHL to April 2025. Twelve studies met the inclusion criteria. Data were extracted using a standardized charting approach and synthesized through an inductive, grounded theory-informed thematic analysis supported by constant comparison and reflexive memoing. Five interconnected domains of hesitancy were identified: (1) perceptions of fluoride as harmful or toxic; (2) uncertainty about benefits or necessity; (3) mistrust of scientific, professional, or governmental institutions; (4) ethical concerns regarding autonomy, consent, and environmental integrity; and (5) discomfort with specific delivery modalities paired with preferences for alternatives. Hesitancy was shaped not only by information but also by emotional responses, lived experience, parenting norms, online discourse, and interpretations of institutional credibility. Across studies, decisions about fluoride reflected broader efforts to navigate uncertainty, protect children, and maintain control over health choices. Fluoride hesitancy is a multifaceted interpretive process rather than a simple knowledge deficit. Addressing it requires approaches that pair clear scientific communication with attention to trust, autonomy, and the social contexts in which preventive recommendations are received. Strategies that acknowledge experiential perspectives and increase transparency around policy decisions may enhance the credibility and uptake of fluoride guidance, but some degree of hesitancy is likely to persist given wider environments of uneven trust and contested information.
引用
- Chen SMS, Ong YJ, Soh LY, et al. Understanding Fluoride Hesitancy: A Qualitative Scoping Review. J Dent Res. 2026. PMID: 41846415. doi:10.1177/00220345261428043
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。