无牙上颌康复临床指南首届全球共识:患者与跨学科专家单轮调查
两组分别在9项和8项条目上达成共识或强共识,涉及CBCT使用、固定全牙弓修复偏好、主要治疗结局等,并均强调需进一步研究上颌全牙弓种植修复。
要点
- 患者与专家在CBCT使用、固定全牙弓修复偏好等条目上达成共识或强共识。
- 共识条目还涉及硬组织增量需求、家庭护理方案、种植体寿命及成本效果。
- 两组均指出上颌全牙弓种植修复领域仍需进一步研究。
核心结论
- 两项调查结果为制定无牙上颌临床实践指南提供了患者与跨学科专家的宝贵视角。
- 缺乏共识的领域反映了治疗方法的现实差异、文献知识空白以及患者期望、专家意见与现有证据间的重要差异。
研究设计与样本
- 参与自愿、匿名、无激励且需知情同意。
- 共识定义为同意或不同意>75%且≤95%,强共识定义为>95%。
主要发现
- 患者应答率为60.3%,跨学科专家应答率为30.9%。
- 患者在9项条目下的15个陈述上达成共识或强共识。
- 跨学科专家在8项条目下的15个陈述上达成共识或强共识。
- 达成共识的条目包括CBCT使用、固定全牙弓修复偏好、主要治疗结局、硬组织增量需求、家庭护理方案、种植体寿命、操作难度、成本效果及患者报告结局。
- 两组均强调需进一步研究上颌全牙弓种植修复。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识:同意或不同意>75%且≤95%;强共识:同意或不同意>95%。
- 患者在9项条目下的15个陈述上达成共识或强共识。
- 跨学科专家在8项条目下的15个陈述上达成共识或强共识。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To gather perspectives from patients and cross-disciplinary experts on treatment practices and outcomes in managing the edentulous maxilla to inform a structured consensus process and highlight areas for future research. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An 18-item single-round survey was distributed in November 2024 with 68 patients and 68 cross-disciplinary experts. Participation was voluntary, anonymous, incentive-free, and required informed consent. Consensus was defined as > 75% and ≤ 95% agreement or disagreement, and strong consensus as > 95% agreement or disagreement. RESULTS: Response rates were 60.3% among patients, and 30.9% among cross-disciplinary experts. Consensus or strong consensus was achieved by patients on 15 statements across nine items and by cross-disciplinary experts on 15 statements across eight items. Items reaching consensus included the use of cone-beam computed tomography, preference for fixed full-arch prostheses, major treatment outcomes, need for hard tissue augmentation, home care regimens, dental implant lifespan, procedure difficulty, cost-effectiveness, and patient-reported outcomes. Both groups also highlighted the need for further research on full-arch implant rehabilitation of the maxilla. CONCLUSION: Findings from both surveys inform the development of clinical practice guidelines in treating the edentulous maxilla by providing valuable perspectives from patients and cross-disciplinary experts. Areas lacking consensus illustrate real-world variations in treatment approaches, highlight knowledge gaps in the current literature, and reveal important differences among patient expectations, expert opinions, and available evidence.
引用
- Lin GH, Brunello G, Jung RE, et al. 1st Global Consensus for Clinical Guidelines for the Rehabilitation of the Edentulous Maxilla: Patient and Cross-Disciplinary Expert Single-Round Surveys. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2026. PMID: 41732067. doi:10.1111/clr.70023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。