无牙上颌种植时机评估的患者与临床医生报告结局及测量工具:系统综述
结果显示PROs和ClinROs在领域、方法和报告上存在显著异质性,评估方法差异大限制可比性,未观察到种植时机的明确模式,需要统一结局选择和建立核心结局集。
要点
- PROs共16种,口腔健康相关生活质量报告率最高(53.85%),疼痛强度38.46%。
- 评估方法差异大,结局异质性高,需建立核心结局集以提高可比性。
核心结论
- PROs和ClinROs在领域、方法和报告上存在显著异质性,需要统一结局选择和建立核心结局集以增强可比性和可靠性。
研究设计与样本
- 提取PROs、ClinROs及测量方法,基于研究设计评估偏倚风险,进行描述性分析。
主要发现
- 延迟种植在9项研究中报告,即刻种植在2项,两者均报告在2项。
- PROs共16种,口腔健康相关生活质量报告率53.85%,疼痛强度38.46%,修复体满意度23.08%,术后药物使用15.38%,其他各项7.69%。
- 肿胀15.38%,手术参数11.54%,发音和口颌功能行为5.6%。
- 评估方法差异大限制可比性,未观察到种植时机的明确模式。
临床怎么用
- 临床研究应统一PROs和ClinROs的选择与报告,推动建立核心结局集以提高证据可比性。
- 评估无牙上颌种植时机时,需注意现有研究结局异质性高,结果解释应谨慎。
局限性
- 纳入研究多为病例系列,仅1项随机对照试验,偏倚风险可能较高。
- 评估方法差异大,限制研究间可比性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To address what patient-reported outcomes (PROs) and clinician-reported outcomes (ClinROs) have been reported, and what measures (PROMs and CROMs) have been used to assess them in clinical studies on the timing of implant placement in the edentulous maxilla? MATERIALS AND METHODS: Systematic searches were conducted in five databases to identify longitudinal prospective clinical studies. PROMs, CROMs, and methods were extracted. Risk of bias was assessed based on study design, and outcomes were analyzed descriptively. RESULTS: Thirteen studies were included: 1 randomized controlled trial and 12 case series. Delayed placement was reported in 9 studies, immediate in 2, and both in 2. Regarding PROs, 16 outcomes were identified, including oral health-related quality of life (reported in 53.85%), pain intensity (38.46%), satisfaction with the prosthesis (23.08%), postoperative drug use (15.38%), and outcomes related to well-being during surgery, treatment satisfaction, oral health satisfaction, psychosocial impact, daily life impairment and prosthesis functionality, among others (each 7.69%). Eighteen ClinROs were identified. Implant survival was reported in 38.46% of studies, prosthetic complications in 30.77%, and prosthetic survival in 23.08%. Peri-implant health parameters-bone level changes, probing depth, plaque and bleeding indices-were reported in 23.08%. Fewer studies assessed swelling (15.38%), surgical parameters (11.54%), articulation, and oromyofunctional behavior (5.6%). Assessment methods varied widely, limiting comparability. No clear pattern was observed regarding the timing of implant placement. CONCLUSIONS: PROs and ClinROs exhibited significant heterogeneity in domains, methods, and reporting. Harmonizing outcome selection and establishing a core outcome set are needed to enhance comparability and reliability.
引用
- Romito GA, Dos Reis INR, Hassan MA, et al. Patient- and Clinician-Reported Outcomes and Outcome Measures Evaluating Timing of Implant Placement in the Edentulous Maxilla: A Systematic Review of Clinical Studies. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2026. PMID: 41732078. doi:10.1111/clr.14454
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。