动态计算机辅助种植手术在不同牙列缺损类型中的精度:系统综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入24项临床研究、687例患者和1147枚种植体,评估动态计算机辅助种植手术(d-CAIS)在单牙、部分和全牙列缺失中的精度。总体平台偏差1.03 mm、根尖偏差1.18 mm、角度偏差2.90°;单牙缺失在平台和根尖的线性精度优于部分和全牙列缺失,但差异无临床意义,角度偏差无显著差异。
要点
- d-CAIS总体精度:平台1.03 mm,根尖1.18 mm,角度2.90°。
- 单牙缺失线性精度优于部分和全牙列缺失,但差异无临床意义。
- 各牙列缺失类型的角度偏差无显著差异,d-CAIS均可适用。
核心结论
- d-CAIS在所有牙列缺失类型中均表现出可靠且相似的种植体植入精度。
- 单牙缺失在平台和根尖的线性精度高于部分或全牙列缺失,但差异无临床意义。
- 各组间角度偏差无显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,纳入截至2025年4月15日发表的任何已发表研究(除外病例报告)。
- 纳入24项临床研究,共687例患者和1147枚种植体,评估d-CAIS精度。
- 采用随机效应荟萃分析评估平台和根尖线性偏差及角度偏差,并比较单牙、部分和全牙列缺失组间差异(p < 0.05)。
- 对纳入研究进行偏倚风险评估。
主要发现
- 种植体水平总体精度:平台1.03 mm CI [0.95; 1.11],根尖1.18 mm CI [1.10; 1.27],角度2.90° CI [2.61; 3.17]。
- 单牙缺失:平台0.90 mm CI [0.82; 0.98],根尖1.02 mm [0.88; 1.16],角度2.65° [2.19; 3.11]。
- 部分牙列缺失:平台1.08 mm [0.96; 1.20],根尖1.23 mm [1.14; 1.32],角度3.10° [2.75; 3.45]。
- 全牙列缺失:平台1.15 mm [0.85; 1.56],根尖1.41 mm [1.14; 1.67],角度2.59° [1.51; 3.68]。
- 单牙缺失在平台(p = 0.0212)和根尖(p = 0.0101)的精度高于部分和全牙列缺失;角度偏差无显著差异(p = 0.2611)。
临床怎么用
- d-CAIS可用于各类牙列缺失(单牙、部分、全牙列)的种植体植入。
- 单牙缺失的线性精度虽略优,但差异无临床意义,不应据此改变术式选择。
局限性
- 结论受本研究局限性影响。
- 单牙缺失与部分/全牙列缺失的线性精度差异虽具统计学意义,但无临床意义。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess the accuracy of dynamic computer-assisted implant surgery (d-CAIS) in dental implant placement for single, partial, and complete edentulism, and to compare how these edentulism types affect surgical accuracy. DATA: Any published studies, except for case reports, assessing d-CAIS accuracy were included until April 15, 2025. Risk of bias was assessed. Random-effects meta-analyses assessed linear and angular deviations at platform and apex levels, and examined differences among single, partial, and complete edentulism groups (p < 0.05). SOURCES: Electronic search was performed on MEDLINE, PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, along with hand-searching and cross-referencing without any limitation for publication year. STUDY SELECTION: Data from 24 clinical studies, including 687 patients and 1147 dental implants, were analyzed to assess d-CAIS accuracy. The meta-analysis at the implant level found a mean overall accuracy of 1.03 mm CI [0.95; 1.11] at the platform, 1.18 mm CI [1.10; 1.27] at the apex, and 2.90 °CI [2.61; 3.17] for angular deviation. For single tooth gaps, deviations were 0.90 mm CI [0.82; 0.98] at the platform, 1.02 mm [0.88; 1.16] at the apex, and 2.65° [2.19; 3.11]. Partial edentulism groups showed 1.08 mm [0.96; 1.20] at the platform, 1.23 mm [1.14; 1.32] at the apex, and 3.10° [2.75; 3.45] for angular deviation. Complete arches had 1.15 mm [0.85; 1.56] at the platform, 1.41 mm [1.14; 1.67] at the apex, and 2.59° [1.51; 3.68] for angular deviation. Single tooth gaps demonstrated greater accuracy compared to partial and complete edentulism at the platform (p = 0.0212) and apex (p = 0.0101). No significant differences were observed in angular deviation (p = 0.2611). CONCLUSIONS: Within the limitations of this study, d-CAIS demonstrated reliable and comparable accuracy for dental implant placement across all types of edentulism. Greater linear precision at both platform and apex was measured in single-tooth implant placement compared to partial or complete edentulous cases, although these differences were not clinically significant. No significant differences in angular deviations between groups were observed. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Even if single-tooth gap resulted the most accurate when compared to partial edentulism and complete arches, these differences were not clinically significant. dCAIS may be used for dental implant placement in various types of edentulism.
引用
- Pozzi A, Lorenzi C, Arcuri L, et al. Navigation implant surgery accuracy in different types of edentulism: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Dent. 2026. PMID: 41687954. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2026.106560
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。