无牙上颌种植负载时机的患者与临床医生报告结局及测量工具:前瞻性研究的系统综述
本系统综述纳入5项前瞻性研究,比较无牙上颌即刻、早期与延迟种植负载方案中患者报告结局(PROs)和临床医生报告结局(ClinROs)及其测量工具。PROs主要采用VAS评估疼痛、满意度、功能与美学,OHIP问卷用于生活质量;ClinROs缺乏标准化方法,异质性显著。作者建议标准化PROMs/CROMs的评估与报告。
要点
- 无牙上颌种植负载研究中,PROs常用VAS和OHIP问卷评估。
- 即刻与延迟负载比较的研究占多数,早期负载证据较少。
- ClinROs评估方法差异大,缺乏标准化工具。
核心结论
- PROs主要采用VAS评估患者满意度、疼痛、功能和美学,其次采用OHIP问卷评估生活质量。
- ClinROs无标准化方法,导致报告结局显著异质性。
- 需要标准化PROMs/CROMs的评估方法与报告以优化患者中心结局分析。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE、Embase、Scopus、Web of Science、Cochrane数据库2014年1月至2024年5月的前瞻性干预性和观察性研究。
- 纳入5项研究,其中4项比较即刻与延迟负载,1项比较即刻与早期负载。
- 排除颧种植体,使用Cochrane RoB 2和ROBINS-I进行偏倚风险评估,结果描述性报告。
主要发现
- PROMs如VAS工具在80%的研究中报告,用于评估7项PROs:疼痛、总体满意度、舒适度、言语、咀嚼功能、美学和自尊。
- 三项研究报告了OHIP-19、OHIP-20、McGill疼痛问卷和特定条件工具,评估咀嚼能力和口腔功能时肌肉活动两个结局。
- ClinROs包括种植体稳定性、精确度、咬合参数、牙周健康指标、手术结局和VAS美学评估,研究间差异显著。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估无牙上颌种植负载方案时,可参考VAS和OHIP作为PROs测量工具。
- ClinROs的选择需注意缺乏标准化,解读时应考虑方法学异质性。
局限性
- 仅纳入5项研究,证据基础有限。
- ClinROs方法学多样性导致结局难以合并比较。
- 检索时限为2014年1月至2024年5月,可能遗漏更早研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIM: To identify patient-reported outcomes (PROs) and clinician-reported outcomes (ClinROs) and their outcome measures (PROMs and CROMs) used in prospective studies comparing immediate, early, and delayed implant loading protocols in edentulous maxilla patients receiving implant-supported prostheses. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Protocol-driven electronic searches were conducted across MEDLINE, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, Cochrane databases-January 2014 to May 2024-to identify prospective interventional and observational studies comparing immediate, early, delayed implant loading in maxillary edentulous patients. Zygomatic implants were excluded. Risk of bias was performed using Cochrane RoB 2 and ROBINS-I, and results were reported descriptively. RESULTS: Five studies were included, of which four compared immediate versus delayed loading and one study compared immediate versus early loading. PROMs like visual analog scale (VAS) tool (reported in 80%) to evaluate 7 PROs: pain, overall satisfaction, comfort, speech, masticatory function, esthetics, and self-esteem. Three studies reported Oral Health Impact Profile (OHIP-19, OHIP-20), McGill Pain Questionnaire, and condition-specific instruments assessing two outcomes: chewing ability and muscular activity during oral functions. ClinROs varied considerably between studies, demonstrating significant methodological diversity. ClinROs included implant stability, accuracy, occlusal parameters, periodontal health metrics, surgical outcomes, and esthetic evaluation via VAS. CONCLUSION: PROs were predominantly assessed using VAS to evaluate patient satisfaction, pain, function, and esthetics, followed by the OHIP Questionnaire for quality-of-life assessment in immediate versus early/delayed loading protocols. ClinROs showed no standardized approach, creating significant heterogeneity in the reported outcomes. Standardization of assessment methods and reporting of PROMs/CROMs is needed to optimize analyzing patient-centered outcomes.
引用
- Pannuti CM, Hassan MA, Reis INR, et al. Patient- and Clinician-Reported Outcomes and Outcome Measures Evaluating Timing of Implant Loading in the Edentulous Maxilla: A Systematic Review of Prospective Studies. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2026. PMID: 41732074. doi:10.1111/clr.14451
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。