指南与共识口腔修复与种植

首份全球临床指南共识:种植牙无牙上颌康复核心结局集

1st Global Consensus for Clinical Guidelines: Identifying a Core Outcome Set for Implant Dentistry in Edentulous Maxilla Rehabilitation.
指南 / 共识 · Clin Oral Implants Res · 2026-01-01

OBJECTIVES: To identify a core outcome set (COS) to standardize outcome measures for studies on the rehabilitation of the edentulous maxilla in implant dentistry.…

要点

  • 最终COS包含34个结局:10项患者报告结局、22项客观临床医生报告结局、2项主观临床医生报告结局。
  • 第2轮Delphi中至少75%参与者评为7-9分的结局入选最终COS。
  • 第3轮评估显示21个COS结局与维护和/或治疗后并发症管理阶段相关。

核心结论

  • 采用COMET方法制定了种植牙无牙上颌康复研究的核心结局集,共34个结局。
  • 该COS有望提高结局报告一致性并促进干预效果比较。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于COMET倡议的标准化方法制定COS,为第1届全球临床指南共识(GCCG)做准备。
  • 通过8项系统综述识别结局,经临床与跨学科专家及患者调查扩展,开展3轮Delphi调查。
  • 第1轮Delphi在会议前进行,第2、3轮在面对面共识会议期间进行。
  • 共邀请105名专家,3轮Delphi应答率分别为87.6%、95.2%、92.4%。

主要发现

  • 系统综述与调查初步生成119个结局,第1轮后根据反馈精简。
  • 第2轮中34个结局被评为关键并纳入最终COS,包括10项PROs、22项客观ClinROs和2项主观ClinROs。
  • 第3轮中21个COS结局被认为与维护和/或治疗后并发症管理阶段相关。
  • 第3轮中3个结局被认为治疗前相关,另3个仅治疗期间相关。

关键数值与推荐

  • 第1轮采用9点Likert量表评分:7-9分为关键,4-6分为重要,1-3分为低重要性。
  • 第2轮中至少75%参与者评为7-9分的结局构成最终COS选择。
  • 最终COS包含10项患者报告结局:美学满意度、咀嚼功能/舒适度/不适、治疗/维护期间并发症、清洁便利性/口腔卫生效果、疼痛、患者整体治疗满意度、患者报告的主诉、修复体固位/稳定性、生活质量、言语/语音/发音功能。
  • 最终COS包含22项客观临床医生报告结局:生物学并发症、患者依从性史、种植体失败、种植体初期稳定性、种植体成功、种植体存留、机械/技术并发症、种植体周围健康(种植体水平)、种植体周围健康(患者水平)、种植体周围黏膜炎、种植体周围溢脓、种植体周围炎、菌斑指数/口腔卫生、术后并发症、角化黏膜存在、修复体失败、修复体成功、修复体并发症、影像学边缘骨水平、影像学边缘骨丧失、手术/术中并发症、角化黏膜宽度。
  • 最终COS包含2项主观临床医生报告结局:临床医生治疗成功、修复维护事件/并发症。

临床怎么用

  • 临床研究应采纳该COS以标准化种植牙无牙上颌康复的结局报告。
  • 该COS可用于患者选择、诊断工具、治疗计划、治疗过程、并发症管理及维护等阶段的结局评估。
  • 推广使用该COS有助于比较当前和新兴干预措施的效果。

局限性

  • 患者虽在初步调查阶段参与,但未直接参与Delphi调查,未来需加强患者参与COS制定。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To identify a core outcome set (COS) to standardize outcome measures for studies on the rehabilitation of the edentulous maxilla in implant dentistry. This work was conducted in preparation for the 1st Global Consensus for Clinical Guidelines (GCCG) for the Rehabilitation of the Edentulous Maxilla. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The COS was developed using a standardized and validated methodology, following the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials (COMET) initiative. Outcomes were first identified through eight systematic reviews covering surgical and prosthetic aspects of edentulous maxilla rehabilitation. This preliminary list was expanded by input from clinical and cross-disciplinary experts as well as patient surveys to capture additional relevant outcomes that were not represented in the literature. A 3-round Delphi survey was conducted. The first round was conducted prior to the meeting and the second and third round took place during the in-person consensus meeting. In the first round, participants could propose new outcomes and rated each item using a 9-point Likert scale, from 1 (not important) to 9 (critical), with scores of 7-9 denoting critical importance, 4-6 importance, and 1-3 low importance for decision making. In the second round, participants re-scored a revised outcome list incorporating written suggestions and consolidated overlapping items from the first round. Outcomes rated 7-9 by at least 75% of participants in the second round constituted the final COS selection. In the third round, these selected outcomes were evaluated for their relevance across the different stages of the GCCG workflow: patient selection, diagnostic tools, treatment planning, treatment procedure, management of complications during the treatment procedure, maintenance, and management of complications during maintenance. RESULTS: Of the 105 experts invited, response rates for the three Delphi rounds were 87.6%, 95.2%, and 92.4%, respectively. An initial list of 119 outcomes was generated from systematic reviews and surveys and subsequently refined after the first round based on participant feedback. In the second round, 34 outcomes were rated as critical and included in the final COS. These comprised 10 patient-reported outcomes (PROs): aesthetic satisfaction; chewing function/comfort/discomfort; complications during treatment/maintenance; ease of cleaning/oral hygiene efficacy; pain; patient overall satisfaction with treatment; patient-reported complaints; prosthesis retention/stability; quality of life; speech/phonetics/pronunciation function, 22 objective clinician-reported outcomes (ClinROs): biological complications; history of patient compliance; implant failure; implant primary stability; implant success; implant survival; mechanical/technical complications; peri-implant health (implant level); peri-implant health (patient level); peri-implant mucositis; peri-implant suppuration; peri-implantitis; plaque index/oral hygiene; postoperative complications; presence of keratinized mucosa; prosthesis failure; prosthesis success; prosthetic complications; radiographic marginal bone level; radiographic marginal bone loss; surgical/intraoperative complications; width of keratinized mucosa and two subjective ClinROs (clinician's treatment success; prosthodontic maintenance events/complications). Additional outcomes proposed during the second round were excluded since they represented general comments, process indicators, or alternative wording of outcomes already considered. In the third round, 21 COS outcomes were deemed relevant to the maintenance and/or post-treatment complication management phases, 3 were deemed relevant before treatment, and another 3 were deemed relevant only during treatment. CONCLUSION: The proposed COS for studies on the rehabilitation of the edentulous maxilla in implant dentistry was developed using the COMET methodology. Although patients' perspectives were incorporated during the preliminary survey phase, they did not participate directly in the Delphi, highlighting an opportunity for future research to further enhance patient involvement in COS development. The widespread implementation of this COS is expected to improve the consistency of outcome reporting and facilitate comparisons of the effectiveness of current and emerging interventions.

来源:Clin Oral Implants Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brunello G, Lin GH, Kopp I, et al. 1st Global Consensus for Clinical Guidelines: Identifying a Core Outcome Set for Implant Dentistry in Edentulous Maxilla Rehabilitation. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2026. PMID: 41732050. doi:10.1111/clr.70075

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。