通过国际电子德尔菲法开发多维口腔衰弱量表
本研究旨在开发患者报告的多维口腔衰弱量表。基于新建立的口腔衰弱操作性定义,通过系统文献检索和三轮国际专家电子德尔菲法,从185个潜在条目中最终确定24个条目,形成24项口腔衰弱量表(OF-24),用于临床和社区检测口腔衰弱。
要点
- OF-24量表涵盖咀嚼、吞咽、口腔运动技能和唾液分泌四个域共八个组件。
- 量表开发基于国际专家三轮电子德尔菲法共识,最终每个组件保留3个条目。
- 建议在广泛采用前在不同人群和语言中进一步评估该量表。
核心结论
- 开发了患者报告的多维口腔衰弱量表OF-24,用于临床和社区检测口腔衰弱。
- 建议在广泛采用前在不同人群和语言中进一步评估。
研究设计与样本
- 采用国际专家电子德尔菲法,25名专家参与三轮评估。
- 基于口腔衰弱操作性定义,涵盖四个域八个组件。
- 系统文献检索识别候选条目,初始条目池185个。
主要发现
- 文献检索共识别185个潜在条目,其中34个独特条目归入八个组件进入德尔菲流程。
- 第一轮因相关性低淘汰4个条目,第二轮评审45个条目(30个保留和15个新建议)。
- 第二轮因相关性再淘汰5个条目,基于重要性排名选出24个条目(每个组件3个)。
- 第三轮对条目进行清晰性和一致性修订,纳入专家对措辞和格式的意见。
关键数值与推荐
- 最终量表名为24项口腔衰弱量表(OF-24),包含24个条目,每个组件3个。
- 条目评估八个组件,分属咀嚼、吞咽、口腔运动技能和唾液分泌四个域。
临床怎么用
- OF-24可作为临床和社区环境中诊断、风险分层和早期干预的实用工具。
- 量表为患者报告形式,捕捉口腔衰弱的多个维度。
局限性
- 量表尚未在不同人群和语言中广泛评估,需进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Oral frailty is a distinct frailty phenotype encompassing multiple dimensions of oral functional decline. This study aimed to develop a patient-reported, multidimensional oral frailty scale using an e-Delphi approach with international experts. METHODS: Informed by a recently established operational definition of oral frailty, the scale was designed to assess eight components across four domains: mastication, swallowing, oral motor skills, and salivation. A systematic literature search identified candidate items, which formed the initial pool for evaluation by 25 international experts in geriatric dentistry, prosthodontics/oral rehabilitation, geriatric medicine/rehabilitation, and population oral health. Through a three-round e-Delphi, experts rated item relevance, proposed new items, selected top three items in each component and ranked them by importance, and provided inputs for response options, recall period, food and phonatory examples, and item wording. RESULTS: A total of 185 potential items were identified from the literature, of which 34 unique items fell under the eight components and were subjected to the e-Delphi process. Four items were eliminated in Round-1 due to low relevance, and 45 items (30 retained and 15 newly suggested) were reviewed in Round-2. Five items were further eliminated based on relevance in Round 2, and 24 items (3 per component) were selected based on importance ranking. These items were refined for clarity and consistency in Round-3, incorporating expert inputs on phrasing and format. CONCLUSIONS: A patient-reported multidimensional scale, named 24-Item Oral Frailty Scale (OF-24), has been developed for detecting oral frailty in clinical and community settings. Further evaluation of this scale across diverse populations and languages is recommended before its wide adoption. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: This e-Delphi study derived a patient-reported scale to capture all dimensions of oral frailty delineated in the recent operational definition. This scale offers a practical tool for diagnosis, risk stratification and early intervention.
引用
- Natarajan K, Wong ML, Chen MZ, et al. Multidimensional oral frailty scale developed through an international e-Delphi approach. J Dent. 2025. PMID: 41344422. doi:10.1016/j.jdent.2025.106276
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。